Something about this book didn't quite work, but I can't figure out what. It has an interesting premise - when the beloved, color-loving queen dies, the heart-broken king banishes all color from the kingdom. The prince grows up in a grey world, until he receives a bright, rainbow-colored pet for his birthday. The court-appointed color catcher turns out to be evil, happy to do away with the prince along with his colorful pet so that he (the color catcher) can somehow end up in charge of the kingdom. The prince and his pet find the court painter imprisoned underground, and eventually the three escape and bring both color and happiness to the king and the entire kingdom. The illustrations are in the same genre as Tim Burton.
The story feels choppy - the color catcher goes after the pet, the pet disappears, the king and the prince have a heart-to-heart about why the king banished color, the prince says that he'll change the rules when he is king, the color catcher overhears this and says "then we must make sure you never become king", a spider appears dangling a piece of colorful full in front of the prince's face, the prince takes off after the spider to find the pet, the color catcher chases the prince... it just feels choppy.
(Note: I received a free advance reading copy of this book from the publisher at an American Library Association Annual Conference. I was not required to write a positive review. Thank you, Roaring Brook Press!)