Customer Reviews

The Soloist

5 star:		(21)
4 star:		(21)
3 star:		(17)
2 star:		(9)
1 star:		(4)

 

 

This movie is primarily about the relationship between the weary journalist and the homeless artist, and Downey and Foxx give great performances. It sensitively deals with issues of charity and friendship in ways that challenge conventional ideals, and I liked the fact that in the end, Downey's character seems content to stop playing the role of "rescuer" and instead lets events play out to their natural conclusion. In fact, Foxx's character, for all the mental distress he faces, seems more grounded at times than Downey's character, and you might wonder whether the soloist refers to the cello virtuoso or the journalist who seems to learn what it means to be a friend rather than going solo through life. In that respect, it's a show that operates effectively on more than a superficial level.

Now if they could just have spent a little more time coaching Foxx on his fake cello-playing skills...alas.

I think it's quite extraordinary that none of the reviews of the Soloist discuss the use of Beethoven's work in the film, which in my view reveals a shocking ignorance on the part of the critics. For example, the use of the cello part from the rondo of the second movement (the funeral march) of the 3rd symphony is brilliant, and reveals far more than just the playing skill of Ayres. Ditto the use of the Triple Concerto, various string quartets, less well-known parts of the 9th Symphony, all of which brilliantly move from the cello parts to the lager ensemble and back. It's a moving, innovative, and gorgeous use of Beethoven's work, and it makes a much larger point that the critics seem to miss entirely: Beethoven's work, most of all is about transcendence, the brotherhood of mankind, and the profound spiritual value of music. That's how the Soloist uses the composers's work to tell the story. Beethoven and music are Ayres' path to transcendence, and the way Beethoven's work is handled in the film makes this point clearly. The Soloist is worth seeing (and hearing) for the music alone.

People who see this film as a political statement miss the whole point.

Having casually checked this out recently, knowing absolutely nothing about the film beforehand except from its brief description on cable, which sounded interesting to me, I was and will forever continue to be, stunned by how great this movie is, for me at least. I have since watched extended parts of it as well as the whole thing, several times, have permanently recorded it onto DVD for future enjoyment, and my initial reactions remain the same with each viewing. This is one of the best movies I've seen in a long time. The fact that this didn't really make any box office buzz or profit is not surprising, given the subject matter. But the generally favorable but highly mixed, both positive and negative feelings and opinions about it from other reviewers and critics, and especially the lack of industry awards for this (i.e., Golden Globes, Oscars, etc.), are puzzling to me.

IMHO, this film is simply wonderful throughout, beginning to end, and has moved me to very moist eyes upon each and every viewing, tears of both profound sadness and sublime joy alike. I suspect that most people who have seen this, and have given it thumbs down, are missing the boat here. Although I always try to give, at times grudgingly, respect for the opinions, beliefs, and feelings of intelligent, enlightened folks, no matter what the film, I find it hard to fathom how and why anyone could watch this, stick with it to the end, and not see this as something really special.

The first time I watched this "cold," knowing almost nothing about it and only later discovering that it was all based upon a true story and the characters based upon real people, I nonetheless strongly suspected such was the case early on in the film and to the finish. It just had to be, I reasoned, because so many Los Angeles locales and environments, and particularly specific "Angeleno" details and ideas explored within it, rang so true and familiar to me. This is because of my own personal experiences with LA-centric, relevant places, people, concepts, issues, and events of substance and reality, for nearly a third of my lifetime.

Perhaps the main reason why a lot of folks who didn't or don't think that highly of this as I do, is because of this lack of personal connectedness to it, which I have and they may not. And that goes to all the filthy rich big shots of Hollyweird who chose to basically ignore this, come awards time. I accept these factors as givens, but honestly, this film has universal themes and observations, which really should appeal to most common people with sentimental hearts and rational minds. That this didn't seem to resonate powerfully with more upon release or since, I can accept. But it's a shame, because this really is extraordinary filmmaking, and distinctively honors what it apparently sets out to pay homage to, throughout.

The film, screenplay adaptation by Susannah Grant, is based on a series of columns written by Los Angeles Times columnist Steve Lopez, who chronicled the plight of Mister Nathaniel Ayers, Jr., a middle-aged, homeless, drifting LA "crazy," but a former Julliard-trained musician with schizophrenia, originally from Cleveland, Ohio. The beginnings of this project were eventually inspired by and detailed in Lopez's book "The Soloist: A Lost Dream, an Unlikely Friendship, and the Redemptive Power of Music" which was published in the spring of 2008.

Nicely but not heavy-handedly or intrusively directed by Joe Wright, starring Jamie Foxx as Nathaniel and Robert Downey Jr. as Steve, the movie features original soundtrack music from Golden Globe and Academy Award-winning composer Dario Marianelli, as well as subtle and intense excerpts from works by Beethoven and the enchanting Cello Suite No. 1 by Bach. Needless to say, throughout, great music and the possible redemptive love, "grace," and healing power of it (with even a bit of Neil Diamond thrown in), plays a big part here. But within that basic structure and notion, a superlative visual and cinematic rendering of same, exemplifies the life-changing supremacy of simple friendship which can develop between often-disparate human beings, and which can bring to each, symbiotic rewards. For "the soloist" here doesn't just apply or refer to homeless, at times obviously schizophrenic but talented Nathaniel, but to Steve the talented and humanistic yet cynical reporter as well. By film's end, both forge a life-affirming relationship, despite their immensely different personal blessings and circumstances in life. A real life, rewarding relationship and friendship which apparently continues to present day.

Detailed musical and visual bits in this movie take quite moving and unexpected twists and turns throughout, more than once from far above and apart from the noisy madness of Los Angeles. And about an hour into the film, it unashamedly ventures (when Nathaniel closes his eyes and listens to a full symphony orchestra playing Ludwig Van) into a very delightful and totally spiritual, "closed-eye vision" colorful representation of music as might've been imagined by the late, legendary experimental filmmaker Stan Brakhage. This "closed-eye" section, while brief, came as a complete surprise to me, but should resonate with anyone who has ever really experienced firsthand, the exquisite "beauty" of great music as a transcendental art form. Truth be told however, these moments are only a few in a series of ever meaningful and majestic ones, in what I consider a virtually perfect film.

This movie is not without its lighter sides, and brief but effective moments of humor, but is at its best when relating various true, and serious elements of the modern USA, social/civilized failings as a whole. These range from the obvious, yet-unlearned tragedies/lessons of Hurricane Katrina's impoverished masses, to its equating of those with the continuing utter shame of LA's skid row and homelessness problems and our whole depraved "health-care" system. Also dealt effectively with is the complex and at times troubling, but deeply romantic (in the classic sense) relationship between Lopez the reporter and his ex-wife and co-worker/boss. As well as the search for connectedness to their fellow human beings in a world seemingly gone mad, among which all the characters in this movie, share equally.

As I've said, this film deals with subjects, people, places, and situations which are uniquely familiar to me, having spent so much time in Southern California in circumstances similar to both that of Mister Steve Lopez and Mister Nathaniel Ayers. Jr. At times there, I was near the top, and other times near the bottom. And I can speak with factual understanding of being both a part of the highs of the fancy award ceremony world of mayors and celebrities which Lopez experiences, to nearly being homeless out there myself in the unbelievably bleak environment of skid row and surroundings, which makes up Nathaniel's world.

I could write so much more in praise of this amazing filmic endeavor, but I will just say this in closing. This is truly a work of art, its power and realism enhanced by true events and people and locales, and while it may not be fully appreciated as I write this, I'm sure in the future, it will be seen as a classic, great film with a message which almost everyone, in time, should eventually identify with, in a very special, if wholly individual way. And by the way, again, the very title refers both to Mr. Ayers AND Mr. Lopez, if some haven't caught on or never will, to that.

This is a work, minute by precious minute, to be revered and cherished forever, which I at least, most certainly will.

If there were ever any doubt that Robert Downey Jr. is one of our best current actors out there, then this film should put them to rest. Still having doubts? Check out his more current resume: Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang, Good Night and Good Luck, Iron Man, and his amazing Tropic Thunder. And these are just a select few that I've cherry picked. This isn't to say that Jamie Foxx (Dreamgirls) didn't do a great job. It's just that Downey Jr. is showing up in some awfully great roles and performing them to perfection, as witnessed here in THE SOLOIST.

This is a story close to my heart. Similar in theme to Lars and the Real Girl, this story doesn't circle around a town coming together to help one man's pysche. This story is about two men who orbit in entirely different galaxies and how a passing swipe ends up creating a lifetime friendship. Yes, there's the mental illness aspect to it and Foxx plays the role of Nathaniel Ayers exceptionally well. His schizophrenia is obvious, and living on the streets hasn't helped. And when newspaper reporter Steve Lopez (Downey Jr.) tries finding a story to write about, he stumbles upon Nathaniel's past as a Juilliard Music School drop-out. Nathaniel plays a violin with only two strings, and as Steve Lopez writes about his newfound friend in the paper, a donation comes floating in: a beautiful cello.

This cello has multiple draws for Nathaniel, and some of them aren't good. The positives are that Nathaniel can play a beautiful instrument beautifully. And that he finally starts forming a friendly tie with someone (anyone!) It just happens to be Steve Lopez. Steve starts showing him around the current musical scene. But with Nathaniel's reawakening comes the remembrance of his past and how he got to where he is. His mental breakdown comes crashing back into current memory, even as Steve, his new friend, tries to help him out more and more.

The side-story of Steve and his wife's reconciliation (Catherine Keener, An American Crime) is pretty much fluff for the movie/story and doesn't add much. It is the touching and powerful story of a friendship forming amidst a respect for one another, a love of music, and facing the challenges of an oft-times debilitating mental illness that drives this wonderful film.

And the music ain't too shabby either.

The sum of the parts of this DVD are way better than the whole. I certainly enjoyed The Soloist, it is a good movie. But once I began exploring the bonus features on this DVD, the whole became so much more. This is the first time since watching Criterion LaserDiscs with real live director or film historian commentary, have bonus features been this movie enhancing.

The Soloist is a solid movie about a Los Angeles Times journalist that meets a homeless man playing a two stringed violin. The film follows Steve Lopez (Robert Downey Jr.), the journalist, through his emotions trying to help Nathaniel Anthony Ayers (Jamie Foxx). The two men end up developing a deep friendship. Gratefully the screenwriter chose not to make this a happily ever after film. The nearly 2 hour film explores insanity, homelessness, and how well meaning people may or may not help these people.

Where things just go crazy wonderful is in the deep bonus features. The film opens with a very strange plea by a very odd looking person - almost priest-like, 'if you see a homeless person, they probably don't want money, they really want to just have you say hello. To get more involved with helping see this website.' Its a strange message, delivered by a strange person, and very confusing for the first time viewer. Jumping into the bonus features, it turns out this is the real live Steve Lopez.

The Bonus Features:
Beth's Story - a powerful 1.5 minute animated film about a girl who's parents die, she moves from foster home to foster home, finally lives on her own, gets sick, can't pay her bills, and becomes homeless - I cried.
A Making of Featurette like none I've ever seen. Not only did this film portray a side of life I hope I never see, nor you see; but they put their money where their mouth is - they hired the homeless to actually perform in this film.
A video about the real live Nathaniel Anthony Ayers, Steve Lopez, and his sister. Done with heart and tenderness. It is a beautiful interview piece.
A series of deleted scenes that frankly are hard to tell why they were left out. Several fill plot holes that I found a little disconcerting during the film.
All total there is roughly 45 minutes of bonus features. They give context to how this film was made and why.

I had a few problems with the film itself (they were quickly tossed away after seeing the bonus features). On first view, the Lamp and Mission areas just seemed all too Hollywood. They were packed with homeless people, too much seemed to be going on, they almost looked polished or unreal. As with most true stories, truth is way stranger than fiction. Apparently this is reality on this street, it was not over done. There were some minor pacing problems, early on the story kind of stalled here and there. And I went from thinking that Steve Lopez was this awesome fantastic person, to what his ex-wife says at one point - he is just capitalizing on somebody else's misfortune. The worst moment of this was when Nathaniel calls Mr. Lopez asking for help; but he is too busy receiving an award for his LA Times articles about Nathaniel Ayers.

The acting is superb in this film. Jamie Foxx is just outstanding, he proved his acting ability in Ray (that he isn't just a clown like in Booty Call), and just builds in this film. After seeing the real Nathaniel Ayers - Mr. Foxx nailed the performance. Robert Downey Jr. is such a talented actor, to say Iron Man, Tropic Thunder, and this film in one breath is some amazing credit to his abilities. He actually improved on the real Mr. Lopez. By far my favorite actor in this film is Nelsan Ellis who played David the director or advocate at Lamp/The Mission.

The film alone is more like a 4 star film. John Wright basically has three films to his credit, The Soloist, Atonement, and Pride and Prejudice. The latter two are not great but good films. The downside to this lack of experience is a number of scenes that run too long and others that run too short - or leave plot holes. Frankly I would have traded some scenes off to include three of the deleted scenes - when viewed they fill plot holes and the film makes much more sense. Camera work is overall very good. Steady shots are good and solid, handheld is kept to a minimum. I noticed a few jarring cuts from solid shots to handhelds that didn't make good sense. The use of boom shots and huge sweeping pans was a bit over the top most of the time. Near the end there are one shots between Mr. Lopez and Ayers - framing is used to great advantage, placing Mr. Lopez on the weak side and Mr. Ayers on the strong side of the frame. A powerful subtle technique.

The film is rated PG-13. There is a bit of strong language, but mostly it is held to a minimum. The subject matter is tough, insanity, and homelessness its probably not fare for those younger than 13. There was a scene or two where my 13 year old son felt a little bit nervous - the voices that Mr. Ayers hears in his head are rendered a bit too real at times. The whole production company was very wise to achieve a PG-13 rating. First and foremost this film could reach the widest audience. I don't feel like they compromised anything by keeping the language in reign.

I've always had a fear of homelessness. This film struck a very strong chord for me. It helped me see that there are small things that everyone can do, that can make a difference. This is a beautiful film.

Despite some good acting, I have to confess, I gave into the itch to press the "fast-forward" button through some parts of this draggy rendition of what I felt could have been a better telling of what seemed a very good "based-on-real-life" story.

Endless scenes are devoted to artistic self-indulgent "filler" that doesn't move the story forward. For example, there's long scenes of listening to Jamie Foxx play so-so cello music, while visually all you see is pigeons soaring through the city. Or the worst, several (seemingly, endless) minutes devoted to a Fantasia-inspired light show set to Beethoven orchestra music (which looks just like what you see on your computer when you play a song and there's no video available.)

But after the movie, I wanted to see what the real people portrayed by the actors looked like and how true the movie was to the real story. WOW! The extras on the DVD are what make a difference with this one, and what lifts it enough to make it worth watching.

While there's only a short (but fascinating!) interview with the real-life columnist and homeless musician portrayed, combined with the other DVD extras, like the Director's version, a look inside the world of the homeless in L.A. and how real homeless people and their everyday lives were incorporated into the making of the movie gave me a whole new appreciation for the movie. In fact, I found myself going back and re-watching parts of the movie because I was so intrigued by the unexpected insights the extras had provided.

Bottom Line: The movie isn't that great - but the true story and the eye-opening DVD extras make this worth a watch.

If you really have a deep emotional feeling, you will cry when you watch this movie. It's about a homeless person who is freaked out by Beethoven and his music; and a columnist of Los Angels times.

Lopez happened to meet a homeless person, Nathaniel, playing violin in the street. He wanted to write a story about him. Nathaniel, though was having mental illness despite his ability to play violin efficiently. Lopez tracked his family down, which helped him to know more about Nathaniel's past life.

When someone read about Nathaniel in the newspaper, it opened their heart with a feeling that they wanted to gift him with something. An old lady sent him a cello, which probably was one of her precious belongings. Nathaniel was very glad to have a new cello, which he was really mad about when he was young.

He played the cello among the homeless people in Los Angeles. He loved the simple kind of life which he was living and did not need anything which we consider GREAT things in this world. Neither he had a family nor a home but he was pretty much satisfied with what he had and what he was. He truly was one of the richest and satisfied person in the world if we look from the other side though he did not have any belongings except his cello and a few items which he used to carry them on his cart.

The story made very clear that you are a happy man if you are satisfied with what you are. It also brings about the fact that there are many homeless people living in the street of Los Angeles (around the globe I'd rather say), which made me think about how fortunate I am to have a house of my own and a family.

I can't say this is a five stars movie, though I don't hesitate to spend time watching it.

Directed by Joe Wright
Starring Robert Downey Jr, Jamie Foxx, Steven Root, Catherine Keener

I saw a news story about Nathaniel Ayers, a homeless musician, and his friendship with Los Angeles Times columnist Steve Lopez. It was fascinating. So, would a film about this be as interesting? Or, would I just prefer seeing a documentary about the story? Let's find out. The Soloist: Blu Ray was recently released on Blu Ray by Dreamworks.

The Movie

Steve Lopez (Robert Downey Jr.) is a busy man. He is a writer for the Los Angeles Times, and he is trying to balance a career, an ex wife and all the other life responsibilities we all have.

Enter into Steve's life Nathaniel Ayers (Jamie Foxx). Steve discovers Nathaniel, a homeless man, playing a two stringed violin in the park one day. He is fascinated by him immediately. He talks to Nathaniel and discovers that he is a Julliard trained musician. It is Nathaniel's struggles with schizophrenia and his overall mental health that made him drop out of school and live on the streets.

The two enter into an unusual and cautious friendship and Steve is inspired to chronicle the developing relationship in a series of articles in his paper. But, as life is unpredictable, who knows what lies ahead for both men?

The trailers for this movie were insufferable and poorly executed. If you were to judge this movie based on those, a viewer could feel that he was about to witness a Lifetime "never mind the acting, here is the message" type of film. The Soloist is definitely not that film.

The performances shine here. As expected, Robert Downey Jr. turns in another fine performance and Foxx continues to surprise film fans with his impressive emotional range as an actor. He holds his own in scenes with Downey, not a small feat.

Also noteworthy are the performances by the always fantastic Catherine Keener and fans of the HBO show True Blood, be on the lookout for a standout performance by Nelsan Ellis (Lafayette). I think he is an actor on the rise.

While only a few scenes might be a bit over dramatic, overall the story told resonates with emotional truth and the direction is tasteful and straightforward.

I found myself engrossed in the film and am very happy I didn't just judge this film on the inadequate trailers.

So, this is one to definitely check out. Fans of Downey and Foxx will certainly enjoy their first rate performances and this nicely produced film.

6.5/10

The Video

Presented in anamorphic widescreen, the film is presented in a AVC incoded transfer. The transfer is first rate and wonderfully presented in the Blu Ray format. The overall image is highly detailed and vibrant. The black levels are highly respectable.

8/10

The Audio

Presented in Dolby 5.1 True HD, the film has never sounded better. The dialogue is crystal clear and well mixed. There is nice usage of the speakers in a 5.1 environment.
7/10

The Packaging and Bonus Features

Presented in a standard amaray Blu Ray case, the artwork suits the film presented well.

Some nice bonus features await your perusal on this release. First up, an enjoyable and informative commentary with director Joe Wright is offered.

An Unlikely Friendship: Making the Soloist is a well produced making of feaurette. Kindness, Courtesy and Respect: Mr. Ayers and Mr. Lopez features the real men discusses their relationship and the film.

One Size Does Not All: Addressing Homelessness in Los Angeles is a featurette about the homeless concerns in the city of angels. Julliard: The Education of Nathaniel Ayers delves into Ayers education and reveals that Grammy Winning Cellist Yo Yo Ma was a classmate of Ayers.

Rounding things out is an animated short about homelessness Beth's Story, Deleted Scenes and the theatrical trailer.

9/10

Overall (Not an Average) 7/10

The Review

The Movie6.5/10
The Video 8/10
The Audio 7/10
The Packaging and Bonus Features 9/10
Overall (Not an Average) 7/10

-Suzie Lackey
See more DVD reviews at [.....]

I loved this film. Jamie Foxx is outstanding in his performance as a homeless mentally ill talented violinist/cellist who battles internal demons on a daily basis. His portrayal of Nathaniel Ayers, Jr. brings his character to life. You feel Ayers' pain and his joy. Foxx is able to embody both the mind of a genius and the mind of a greatly mentally disturbed man.

Robert Downey, Jr. is equally outstanding as the Los Angeles Times columnist Steve Lopez who wants to save Ayers from his demons. His friendship with Ayers is totally believable. Lopez is proud when Ayers makes a small step for change in his life.

And there are a number of great scenes in the film. The one that stands out of the most is the the scene in which Lopez convinces Ayers to go to a rehearsal for the Los Angeles Philharmonic Orchestra. At the last minute, Ayers refuses to go because he can't take his shopping cart, which contains all of his worldly possessions. Lopez later is forced to compromise with Ayers. He and Ayers race down the streets of LA with Ayers' prized shopping cart so that Ayers can attend the rehearsal. This scene was so sweet and touching.

You also feel Lopez's frustrations when he realizes that he must accept Ayers for who he is-- a mentally ill genius. I loved the settings of the film--skid row and the LA Times newsroom. Their sharp contrast showed the differences between Ayers and Lopez. However, despite these differences, they were able to bond as two men.

This is a film that you should add to your "must see" list.

When I saw this movie, I didn't know anything about the factual situation on which it was based. I didn't know about the book by Lopez, one of the two main characters, or the "60 minutes" show describing the relationship between Los Angeles Times reporter Steve Lopez and his friend Nathaniel Ayers, a brilliant but deeply troubled musician. Thus, I tried to see the movie for itself, rather than relate it to a life situation or to a book or show.

In a corner of Pershing Park in downtown Los Angeles, there is a large statue of the great composer Beethoven. I don't know why it is there, but a commemoration of Beethoven needs no excuse. A reporter named Steve Lopez, played by Robert Downey Jr., visits Pershing Park for lunch. Always on the lookout for a good story, Lopez meets an unlikely companion near the Beethoven statue: a homeless African American man who pushes an old shopping cart with all his worldy possessions and who plays a battered two-string violin. This person is Nathaniel Ayers played by Jamie Foxx. The two men strike up a conversation and Lopez learns that Ayers had once attended the prestigious Juilliard School of Music in New York City.

At first, Lopez is opportunistic, looking primarily to make a good story. But he soon develops a genuine friendship for Ayers. The homeless and visibly disturbed Ayers had been a child prodigy and then a student of the cello at Juilliard. When Lopez' first column about Ayers appears,stressing his musical gifts and his descent into homelessness, a generous woman gives Lopez her cello to give to Ayers. Ayers loves the instrument and loves music. Ayers' favorite composer is Beethoven, and he plays and talks about Beethoven's music constantly, including the cello line from the third symphony, string quartets, the cello sonatas, the "Triple" concerto, and more.

Ayers appears to be both schizophrenic and paranoid. He frequents a Los Angeles homeless shelter known as "The Lamp" while spending his days dodging traffic and trying to make music. The movie describes Lopez' efforts to help Ayers pursue his music again.

The movie describes the redemptive power of music, particularly the music of Beethoven. Ayers plays his music with a passion that any lover of music will recognize. Lopez, who is not musical, comes to understand this trait in his friend. The many scenes involving Beethoven, his statue, Ayer's playing and ramblings, and the playing of other musicians shows the power of his music to bring value to life. One of the most moving scenes in this movie comes at the end. While the credits roll at the end of the movie, the Los Angeles Phiharmonic plays the beautiful, serene slow movement from Beethoven's "Choral" symphony. The movie was filed in Los Angeles and in Cleveland, where Ayers spent his childhood.

Ayer's life and Beethoven's music are juxtaposed effectively with skid row Los Angeles. Many of the scenes were shot on location and feature actual residents of The Lamp. These scenes were effective for what they showed of skid row and for their relationship to Ayers' illness and to the power of music. Beethoven of course did not have the power to cure schizophrenia. His music, however, gave Ayers a reason to live.

Portions of the movie don't work very well. There is unnecessary psychedelic imagery accompanying many of the scenes featuring Beethoven's music. And the movie tends to wander when it delves into Lozez' private life, separate from his relationship to Ayers. But the core of the movie, the friendship, Ayers' troubled life, his love of music and of Beethoven, and the portrayal of skid row make this movie worth seeing. The acting of the two major characters, Downey and Foxx is persuasive.

I thought of one of my favorite authors, Charles Bukowski, in watching this movie. Bukowski is sometimes called the "Poet of Skid Row". He is famous for his tough, hardscrabble life and for his love of classical music. But compared to Ayers and The Lamp, Bukowski appears almost middle class and staid. This movie illustrates the power of music to sustain life even under the most trying emotional and physical surroundings.

Robin Friedman