To get the free app, enter your email address or mobile phone number.
The System of Liberty: Themes in the History of Classical Liberalism Paperback – July 4, 2013
Top 20 lists in Books
View the top 20 best sellers of all time, the most reviewed books of all time and some of our editors' favorite picks. Learn more
Frequently Bought Together
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
--Randy E. Barnett, author of The Structure of Liberty: Justice and the Rule of Law
"This is a lucid, concise, but at the same time a deep overview of the origins and structure of classical liberal thought. With a fluid and engaging style, Smith corrects many of our modern misconceptions about how early liberals understood themselves and the terms on which they debated. Anyone interested in liberal thought, whether in its 'classical', modern 'high liberal', or libertarian forms, will find this a valuable resource. Even critics of classical liberalism will find, thanks to Smith, that classical liberal thought contains a great deal of forgotten wisdom."
--Jason Brennan, author of Libertarianism: What Everyone Needs to Know
"George H. Smith is an independent scholar who for many decades has lectured and written about the history of classical liberal and libertarian ideas. The System of Liberty is his first extended take on this history to be published by a high-level academic press-a tribute both to Smith's dogged scholarship and to the rise in the respectability of the libertarian tradition he explains and espouses...the information and analysis are always interesting." -Brian Doherty, Reason Magazine
More About the Author
Top Customer Reviews
The book is very well written and is truly an intellectual page turner. The ideas it covers are very relevant in many of today's political/intellectual discussions and there are several sections of the book that I re-read in order to think the ideas through more thoroughly.
The book covers "Themes in the History of Classical Liberalism" and it has chapters that cover: "Liberalism, Old and New", "Liberalism and the Public Good", "Liberal Ideology and Political Philosophy", "The Idea of Freedom", and "Conflicts in Classical Liberalism" among other topics. I learned a lot in each chapter but there are 3 chapters that I want to focus in on in this review.
The chapter on "Liberalism and the Public Good" covers some key ideas related to natural rights, utilitarianism and the public welfare. John Locke and the early liberals believed in the compatibility of natural rights and the public good. Smith explains 4 roles that the public good plays in John Locke's political philosophy and he makes the key point that "Locke indicated that concern for the public good restricts what a government may do." He then proceeds to cover the early utilitarians by discussing the ideas of Joseph Priestley. He concludes the chapter with a discussion on the vagueness of the concept of the public good including an insightful discussion of the US Constitution and the general welfare clause.
The chapter on "The Radical Edge of Liberalism" is my favorite chapter in the book.Read more ›
The book also provides a public service by correcting popular misconceptions of liberal thinkers. While Herbert Spencer used the term "survival of the fittest" in his writings, he was no social Darwinist. He explicitly rejected that term and what it stands for. He used "fit" to mean "fitted to one's environment," without any of the normative implications his opponents so eagerly ascribed to him. There is also a valuable discussion of why individualism does not imply atomism, but rather the opposite.
Smith has packed a lot of knowledge into a short volume (225 pages). This is the kind of book where multiple readings would continue to pay dividends. Highly recommended.
(Edited to correct a minor grammatical error.)
George H. Smith gives a libertarian survey of liberalism's origin, growth, and, what he sees as its decay into progressivism. Utilitarian thinking emerges as the poison that moved supposedly liberalism in a conservative, authoritarian direction, embracing what Spencer labelled "the expediency philosophy" at the expense of the older rights-based approach. While such a common narrative works, I propose dividing liberalism into three phases -- classical liberalism, democratic liberalism, modern liberalism -- which should make the rise of progressivism look internal, evolutionary, and organic.
Rights! Resistance! Revolution! Liberalism, from its beginnings, has been about change. Absolutism solved the problem of decades upon decades of terrorism in Europe (called "anarchy" in that period) by centralizing power in the hands of a final arbiter of disputes. Yet this provided no answers if, how, and when to update a government that is behaving unreasonably.Read more ›
There were some tantalizing hints in the chapter entitled, "The Anarchy Game," that need to be explored. Where does George H. Smith now stand? Has he reconsidered constitutionalism? In the chapter, "Sovereign State, Sovereign Self” he writes that the State is a normative institution and that, “This means that a moral claim (specifically a claim about rights) is implicit in every coercive measure it takes.” So, is the “constant consent” required by Rational Anarchism doomed to fail? Is a “better” Constitution required for a more perfect union?
Specifically what amendments or rewriting of the U.S. Constitution are needed to stop and reverse the encroachment of government upon our individual rights? What are the hazards of a Constitutional Convention? Is “The Repeal Amendment” which is a proposed amendment to the US Constitution designed to restore the balance of power between the federal and state governments that our Founders originally envisioned really needed?
Thomas Jefferson wrote:
“Each generation is as independent of the one preceding, as that was of all which had gone before. It has then, like them, a right to choose for itself the form of government it believes most promotive of its own happiness . . . .”
The recent war of words between mainline Republican Governor Christy and libertarian Senator Rand Paul show us we need the ammunition to fight a political and moral war in 2016. So, Mr. Smith, are you ready to go to Washington?
Semper cogitans fidele,
Most Recent Customer Reviews
Anybody committed to the idea of liberty needs to read this book. It caused me to deep-dive into ideas that I hadn't really considered before. Read morePublished 3 months ago by Pat Petrini
George Smith does an incredible and necessary task of discovering the origins between classical liberalism (Libertarianism) and modern liberalism (welfare state/socialism). Read morePublished 10 months ago by Jose A. Tovar
George Smith is one of the all time best libertarian writers and thinkers. I highly recommend this book for a more in depth understanding of the meaning, and origin of individual... Read morePublished 12 months ago by Steven Vandervelde
George H. Smith has provided us with a magnificent history of the ideas that created the modern world by introducing the concept of individualism, human rights, and laissez faire. Read morePublished 14 months ago by JoeCobb
It's been a while since I've read George H. Smith's The System of Liberty: Themes in the History of Classical Liberalism, but I thought it was pretty terrific. Read morePublished 14 months ago by Billie Pritchett