My wife bought this book just before we were married, and we read it together. On the whole, I'd say it has some useful suggestions. However, before reading this book, please consider the following:
This book ISN'T FOR EVERYONE. Why? Well, consider this:
One of the biggest lies I've ever heard is that "We're all the same deep down inside; we just have different ways of expressing ourselves."
Well, that's not true at all. I've found that different people are very much looking for different things in life, in love, etc. A relationship that might be very satisfying to some might be hell for others.
It really comes down to your own hardwiring. Some people are cut out to be drawn to certain things, some aren't, and that's the bottom line. There's nothing wrong loving a book like "The Total Woman"; conversely, there's nothing wrong with saying "This book just isn't for me, and that's that!"
Having said that, allow me to offer a few points:
1) First and foremost, if you are of the feminine persuasion, and find that you firmly believe that the man should be the Head of the household, King of the castle, President of the family, etc., then this book is definately for you. You'll find a lot that's useful here. If you aren't, then you won't.
It's that simple.
If you are "the man is the boss" type, then just accept that as being what's in your heart. Read this book (along with "The Surrendered Wife", "The Joy of Sex", and "Fascinating Womanhood") to find out more about creating the marriage you want.
[Please take note: If you don't buy into "the man is the boss" belief system, you might still benefit from reading this. You still might be able to cherry-pick a few good ideas. First amoungst those good ideas is that men (like most people) generally respond very well to being treated with kindness and consideration.]
2) Mrs. Morgan informs her readers about something quite specific to the masculine gender: Respect and admiration, especially when coming from a woman he loves, can oftentimes be valued by a man more highly than even true love itself. This, along with a genuine willingness on his wife's part, to respect his opinion regarding issues that he really does know more about than some other people (you, for example), really do go a LONG WAY towards fostering love in a man's heart. Far more so, anyway, than do belittling, insulting, controlling, incessant nagging, and cold-hearted, condescending behavior.
Having said that ...
3) PLEASE BE WARNED: Nothing in "The Total Woman", nor in the books just mentioned above, will change the heart of a violent, abusive, and controlling husband. If he is hitting you, verbally abusing you, or elsewise engaging in demeaning, hurtful, derogatory actions, then move out, and move out now. He has no right to treat you as though you are his own personal dumping ground. He is the one with the problem, not you. Get counceling, get help, and make it clear to him that you aren't going to take it anymore. Just be very clear: "The Total Woman" CANNOT solve such marriage/relationship problems as violence, verbal and sexual abuse, etc.
Now that that's out of the way ...
4) Even if you are a woman who believes that the man is the President/King/Head of the family, there are a few ideas here that one should be cautious about.
For example, while it's a great idea to be alluring and seductive (most husbands adore seeing their wives in stiletto heels, sexy hairdos and lovely lingerie), many of the suggestions here might not be specific to what your husband likes. Some men love a woman in a sexy evening gown; others like tight jeans, high heels, and a revealing halter top; some very much love both, some like neither, and the list just goes on. I'd recommend looking at the big picture on this one. Find out what seems to "do it" for your man, and then ... do that!
Simply put, Mrs. Morgan's suggestion to greet one's husband wearing nothing but saran wrap may delight him ... and it may not. You know best what will work for you and your husband. If you don't, you may just need to experiment a little. You'll find out what works as you go along.
Please keep in mind here that finding attractive attire is as much about how you feel as it is about how you look. Remember that you wear the clothes, they don't wear you. The key is to find the alluring attire that expresses your unique feminine beauty, and lights your husband's fire too. That's what it's all about.
5) A word about following his leadership: This book recommends that your husband shall make the final decisions about things; this advice is supported by a conservative interpretation of relevant Biblical text.
Even if you completely agree with that conservative interpretation, please be advised: I DON'T recommend biting your tongue. Your insight as a woman, specifically your woman's intution, is of ENORMOUS VALUE to your husband. The value of women's intuition simply cannot be over-stated. Any man would be foolish to ignore the insight that his wife has to offer, not just to their marriage, but also to his life. This is where the Biblical concept of "Two are better than one" very much comes in.
Please keep in mind, ladies, that a man who loves you WANTS to hear what you think, and he wants to know what you feel. Please don't interpret anything you read in this book as "just don't ever disagree with him, and he'll be crazy in love with you ..."
... Because that just doesn't work.
What does work, especially in a Bible-based marriage, is finding a respectful, tactful way of expressing your views when you two don't agree. Is it possible to pay a compliment even as you're expressing dissent? For example: "You are very intelligent, and I'm always seeking your insight and advice regarding issues that confront me, both at home and at work. Still, it seems that this time, I'm just seeing things very differently than you are. I'm not trying to win this argument at all costs, mind you: I just need to know that you've heard my differing views, and that we can agree to disagree if that turns out to be what's best. I just need to know that you respect the way I feel, even if you don't agree. I know that you always have good reason to decide things the way you do; it's just that I do, at least in this particular instance, feel very differently about this than you do."
Granted, that's a bit long-winded, but it does lay a foundation for keeping the intimacy in your relationship healthy, even when there are disagreements. Marabel is very correct about one thing: Men very much need to know that their wives have a great deal of respect for them, and don't look down upon them. Nothing is more repulsive to a man than a condescending, controlling woman; this is exponentially true in his homelife.
If your husband responds to the above by trying, at all costs no less, to convince you that his views are the right ones, listen to him, and give him the space to say what he needs to say. However, when he's done, be as lovingly fiesty as you need to be to get him to recognize that now, it's YOUR turn to express to him how you feel about things.
Be clear that you don't demand that he agree with you, and that you're not so much trying to convince him, as you are simply expressing your need to be heard, and your freedom to be yourself, and have your own views. Didn't he fall in love with the woman that you are, even if the two of you don't always agree?
If hubby can't handle that, then that's his problem, not yours. Gently remind him that as much as you truly, deeply respect him, your heart is just in a different place regarding this issue at hand. Saying "It's not that I don't love you, of course I do. I just need you to recognize my right to be distinct from you, even as we are united in marriage as one. We are two different personalities, and you are a man, while I am a woman. There will be times when we just can't agree. I deeply respect you, and I need to know that you respect me, too."
It might be a tough concept for him to accept at first. Sadly, men can be slow to see the wisdom of the above; a man tends to think it's all about winning the argument and bringing you around to HIS way of thinking. However, eventually, if you are gentle-yet-adorably-fiesty in your application of the above, you'll see good results.
PLEASE TAKE NOTE: Even if you do incline towards the man-is-the-boss persuasion, don't tell him you agree with him if you really don't. "Thou shalt not give false witness to thy neighbor" very much comes into play here. God doesn't want you to misrepresent yourself, and you won't be doing the man you love any favors if you do. Just tell him the truth about how you feel. Be respectful and tactful ... and completely truthful.
The rest of the book contains a few pearls of wisdom here and there. Learn what you can, and move on to other books.
Well, this review has turned out to be longer than I intended; it seems I had a lot to say. Suffice it to sum up that, while "The Total Woman" has its uses, and can be quite helpful, your marriage is ultimately yours to figure out. While that's no easy task, this book help you along your way. Just remember to pick and choose only the things that you believe will work for you, and experiment a little to see what works best.