Customer Reviews

Thee, Hannah!

5 star:		(7)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Hannah was a little Quaker girl who admired something that was considered taboo according to Quaker beliefs. That something was vanity, which was symbolized by a bonnet that her neighbor wore. It had pretty ribbons unlike the plain bonnets that the Quakers wore. The plot of the story does not become clear until near the end of the book. She realizes why it is so important for Quakers to put aside vanity. Hannah learns the true meaning of being a Quaker when she gets to assist runaway slaves who have become disconnected from the Underground Railroad trail. The slaves are a woman and her baby. The woman sees Hannah and beckons her to come to her hiding place in an alley. Hannah then tells her parents about the woman who is in the alley. That night, her parents and the other Friends find the woman and take her to the place where she is supposed to make her connection and join her husband. At the end of the story, this slave tells Hannah that she knew Hannah would help her because of the bonnet she was wearing. Quakers were known for their plain bonnets. This is how Hannah learned the true meaning of helping, which is what the Quaker religion is based on. I found this story to be as relevant today as it was when it was first written. As we still struggle in this country for freedoms, we must not forget that people are placed in positions to help us. The struggle for freedom does not belong to one single race. We accomplish this act by working together. Further, I found the book to be very sensitive, touching, and beautiful. Through the simplicity of the characters, their ideologies, and the author's surprising ending, the book stands out as an extraordinary and artistic literary work. MayfromOK@webtv.net

Hannah -- Nanny to her family -- is an 8 year old Quaker girl, living in Pennsylvania in the days of the the Underground Railroad. She loves pretty things -- ribbons or flowers on bonnets; pantaloons with lacy edges; colorful sashes wrapped around dresses. Of course, as plain folks, her family doesn't approve of these non-functional, showy things.

The language is old fashioned -- the family speaks in the old Friends way of using "thee" when addressing family members. Hannah gets into numerous mishaps, and after every one, her parents gently explain to her why she need not have frills to be valuable.

Hannah's mother says,"'Thee must wait till thee has learned that the color of the dress doesn't matter, and that pantalettes and sashes do not matter. Thee must learn what thy bonnet stands for. Thee must learn Quaker ways.' Mother patted Hannah's shoulder and told her to sit and think about it.

"Hannah thought and thought, but she couldn't quite understand what it all meant. 'Why can't Sally and I wear things the big girls wear? And what does my plain, ugly bonnet stand for?' she wondered. But she was unhappy to have made Mother sad, and when she went downstairs, she hoped she could remember to do everything just as Father wished."

But of course, there is still another temptation or two to surrender to, and the consequences to deal with. Hannah doesn't really understand until the very end of the book, when she is called upon by a runaway slave, whose little boy is sick, to get help. Hannah does this, and much later the woman explains to her how she knew Hannah could be trusted (having to do with the wearing of a plain bonnet.)

The story, written in the 1940's, is based on stories the young Marguerite de Angeli (b. 1889, d. 1987) heard from an 80-year-old Friend of hers, Hannah Severn. Illustrations are quaint, as is the dialogue. A very nice book for Quaker adults or children (kids who today may have some similar contemporary questions about clothing, computers, and other longed for things.) I'm not sure we have as good an answer for simplicity as Hannah found.

There's a quiet peacefulness to this book which takes place in Philadelphia before the Civil War. Illustrated in watercolor and fine pencil drawings, Marguerite de Angeli tell a genuine story of a young Quaker girl's curiosity, desires and ultimately, her courage. She also gives us a view into the times-- including the Underground Railroad. I especially adore how each chapter starts with the street calls--oyster man, pepper pot lady, and more.

Few of Marguerite de Angeli's books remain in print. Look for others at your local libraries and second hand book vendors.

Nine o'clock, and all's well!

Nine o'clock of a rainy night!

Michelle Edwards, A Knitter's Home Companion, Chicken Man

Every child I know who has read it has found it both funny and captivating. If you buy it, the whole concept of saying "thee" all the time is pretty funny and your kids might imitate it for a while and want you to play along. It's fun! But the book tugs on the heart as well. Especially, for this African-American family, the part where Hannah renders aid and assistance to the runaway slave has always been particularly moving and a great conversation starter.

I loved it as a child, bought it for my nieces and nephews, then for my own child and now for my grandkids. I loaned my last copy to a friend whose 2nd grade child had just learned about slavery and was having trouble dealing with how America could have accepted it. Well, not everyone accepted it and Marguerite de Angeli brings this point home in her typically gentle, unobtrusive manner. But I never got my book back so here I am, buying it again. It is well worth every penny and is a great addition to any family's permanent collection.

I highly recommend it.

Know this book from my childhood. Is first rate and as a Christian homeschooler highly recommend it. A priceless story about a little Quaker girl, (my grandmother was a Quaker), who learns that beauty comes from a light within!

Marguerite DeAngeli is one of the best writers of children's books. Not only was she a gifted writer, but she was a fine illustrator too. I have read her books to my children and now I purchase them for my grandchildren for their parents to read to them and/or to be read by them. I highly recommend her stories to everyone; for adults to read also. I hope to see all of her works republished someday for the stories are just as timely today as they were when first written.

One of my favorite childhood books, I didn't even understand the runaway slave aspect until much later. What did always resonate, however, was the struggle that Hannah goes through to balance her desire for material possessions and beautiful things, with her parents' and her faith's wishes that teach her to be simple and rely on what is in her heart for her self worth. Her inner battles with envy over her more worldly friends is something every young girl can relate to. Hannah has weaknesses and she fails but she is always forgiven and her conscience is always at work - an excellent, thoughtful role model without being preachy. The reader struggles with Hannah to do the right thing and make the right choices. Plus the illustrations will stay with the reader a lifetime - Margeurite D'Angeli is a two time Caldecott honoree so words and pictures synthesize in a beautiful rhythm. I cannot recommend this book highly enough - it is a delight.

The book that I ordered is new, but this reprint from the original printing does not do the illustrations justice.
I have a old hardback copy signed by the author/ illustrator and the pictures are more vibrant.
It is still one of my favorite books and I gave it as a gift to grateful recipients.

reading it in this day and age is no easy task. My children were bored and all the "thee"'s were getting to be quite annoying. We read a very wide range of children's literature - Thornton Burgess, Frances Hodgson Burnett, other classics, etc. But this one really didn't interest us at all. I was disappointed since I had heard such good things about it.