Customer Reviews

Then Man Within

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(4)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

*The Man Within* follows a fellow named Andrews through his horrifying experiences of paranoia and self-doubt, made all the worse by the fact that some people want to kill him. Andrews is wanted by the police in connection to the murder of an officer, pursued by his former co-smugglers because of his betrayal, and loathed by the locals because of his testimony against a group of popular criminals. There is only one person - the angelic Elizabeth - who provides him with any support, but she also creates for Andrews his biggest dilemma: to face death for someone whom he may never be able to love, or to find a new life, but without the one person who would make it worth living.

The writing does not show Greene at his peak, but it does demonstrate an early ability to craft brilliantly complicated characters and problems of morality in a manner similar to Dostoevsky..

I'm usually leery of favorite authors' first and last books. They never seem to be up to the standard of the books that come between. In Graham Greene's case, his last novel, "The Captain and the Enemy," certainly holds true to that rule of thumb. However, "The Man Within," his first, holds its own with any of Greene's fabulous later novels. This has all of the elements that would later become Greene trademarks: the conflicted and flawed male protagonist, the murky mood of intrigue and corruption, the delightful local flavor. You can just see Graham Greene novels filmed in crisp black and white (as many of them were). "The Man Within" is an excellent intro to Greene's work for a Greene neophyte and a welcome treat for die-hard fans.

The Man Within is a fantastic book about love and fear. It has elements of action, courtroom drama and good old-fashioned romance. The main character constantly assures us that he is a coward and unworthy of the love given him by the farm girl Elizabeth and also of his former associate whom he betrays in the begining of the book, yet he continues to perform uncharacteristic acts of bravery. His motives for these acts of bravery bring into question the true nature of courage and greatness. This book is surprising at every turn and yet every event, and every conversation makes total sense. It's a difficult book to put down, and you'll probably want to read it again.

The Man Within was Graham Greene's first published book, and a big best seller back in 1929. He was very young when he wrote it, 25 years old,and you can feel it, especially in the love scenes, but heck, it's still Graham Greene, and he writes like a god. All the elements that appear in his later, more famous books--great plot, lush description, beautifully turned sentences, themes of love and God and faith and betrayal, of struggles with the dark side of human nature, they're all here.

A young man called Andrews has ratted on his friends, a gang of smugglers. He hides out from them in the first place he can find, an isolated cottage. A beautiful and saintly girl lives there and gives him shelter. He falls in love with her. She urges him to do the right thing, to go to court and testify against the smugglers.

Since this is Greeneland, everything is in shades of gray; the man he has betrayed is actually the only man who has ever been good to him, a kind of father figure. And Andrews is no hero; he didn't rat on his gang because they were criminals, he ratted on them because they treated him like he was a nobody. And nobody wants these men to go to jail; the townspeople, the police, and the courts are rife with corruption.

Throughout the book, Andrews continually steps outside himself to question his motives and to struggle against his baser instincts. As the quote by Sir Thomas Browne says, "There's another man within me that's angry with me."

The Man Within begins as a standard Hollywood gangster movie, and ends as a soul-searing story of redemption. It's not The Heart of the Matter, it's not The End of the Affair, but it is a bit like going back in a time machine and seeing the first glimmerings of what turned out to be a world-straddling, God-given talent.

If you look at the lists of Graham Greene's GG's) publications in the front matter of your books, you'll see "The Man Within" given as GG"s first book. However two books, "The "Name of Action" and "Rumor at Nightfall" preceded "the Man Within." But they were rejected by the publisher. Greene was happy working as a sub-editor at "The Times." Had "Man" been rejected, the world might have lost GG as one of the 20th Century's greatest English-language writers. The first two books disappeared, GG hoped, into oblivion. Perhaps dedicated searchers can find copies on the dusty top shelves of rare book stores. "The Man Within" takes place in the late 19th Century in the Sussex Downs and in the town of Lewes where the Assizes (English Superior Courts) are held. "Man" is the story of Andrews, a lonely young man and Elizabeth, a lonely young woman, but their relationship is complicated. Smuggling liquor from France is a major enterprise, and the authorities (Gaugers) are ever on the lookout for smugglers. Andrews, a rather reluctant sailor, sent an anonymous letter to the authorities providing information on the smuggler's ship's arrival. In an ensuing battle a Gauger is killed, and several smugglers are apprehended. Fleeing across the Downs, Andrews comes across Elizabeth's cottage. A coffin, holding the body of the man who sort of reared Elizabeth, lies on a table. Of course a trial of the arrested smugglers is held, and Andrews is a key witness. But the community is closely knit, and a guilty verdict essentially impossible. Significantly, neither the community nor the court has any respect for Andrews, the traitor and informer. Andrews was in danger of losing his life. Also fleeing was Joe Carylon, the ship's master, and two fellow fugitives. Much of the rest of the story deals with interactions among Andrews, Carylon (who has befriended Andrews), and Elizabeth. When Andrews had to leave Elizabeth's cottage to obtain food and water, he gave Elizabeth his initialed knife to defend herself. Andrews also taught Elizabeth how to place cartridges into a gun. Carylon, intelligent but of ape-like ugliness, liked Andrews, and the feeling was reciprocated. Andrew's father, captain of the "Good Chance," was beloved by his sailors, but his harshness led to the death of Andrews's mother. Curiously, he had Andrews learn Lain and Greek. Following his death, Carylon became skipper of the "Good Chance," but he lost this in his flight from the law. The story ends tragically. Elizabeth sends Andrews out with a pail to fetch water. He also seeks help from a neighbor, who calls Elizabeth a "bloody hoor." Andrews returns to the cottage to find the door wide open and the room ablaze in candle light, Carylon seated at a table, and Elizabeth dead, an apparent suicide with Andrews's knife. The reader is left with a lot of speculation. Was Elizabeth actually a "bloody hoor," perhaps with the man who raised her? Did she set up Andrews to be led off to be jailed and even hanged? Who was the man within--the ghost of Andrews's father, from whom he now appeared to be exorcised? Another projection of a troubled Graham Greene? [Elizabeth apparently resembled Vivien, Greene's first wife.] [The Man Within" pissed off GG"s dad.]

I came to this book because I was looking for a completmentary book for a literatue essay.

This book, while not very fast paced, is interesting since it's (to me), an introspective look at a Judas figure. Thematically, the book is mostly about redemption and forgiveness.

There's not much to be said, because each person's reading experience will differ, but I think that if you're looking for a book that you can mull over, this is a good book to read.

A more complete review of the book can be found here: [...] (I'm sorry, but I reviewed it in the context of another book).

Francis Andrews is on the run because he informed against a gang of smugglers of spirits - of which he used to be a member - by means of an anonymous letter to the customs, resulting in the death of a ganger who was shot during a set up. Now Carlyon and his men are after Andrews to take revenge. One night, as he is fleeing from his pursuers, Andrews comes across a cottage in Hassocks where he is given shelter by the beautiful Elizabeth Garnet.

As Elizabeth slowly grows to trust Andrews, she learns from him about his past, his violent father, smuggler and owner of the ship "Good Chance" with which he used to transported brandy to England. He also tells her how, after his father's death, he met Carlyon who suggested that he joins the crew. Andrew then tells Elizabeth how deeply he detested these men because he could never ascertain himself in front of them the way his father had. Betraying them was thus a way for him to show his fellow smugglers that he "is of importance now".

It is then that Elizabeth suggests that Andrews go to Lewes the following day where the Assizes are to be held and bear his witness to show his courage. Indeed, a difficult and dangerous decision for Andrews to take...

A powerful novel about courage, cowardice, love and faith. It is commendable that Mr Greene achieved to write such a mature novel at the age of only 23.

"The Man Within" by Graham Greene was Greene's first published novel, and, I think, the reader can tell. The story centers around a man, Andrews, who has been involved in smuggling with some blackguards, and who has fled the group after a crime was committed. He flees right into the home of a woman, Elizabeth, who is in the process of burying the man who has been her guardian of sorts. She convinces him to testify against the other smugglers at the trial, and he goes to the city to do so. When he returns they profess their love for each other but face further dangers together. In the end, Andrews must face the negative influence his father has been on him in his life and the actions he has committed in reaction to that influence.

While there were some interesting facets of the book and its characters, I took a long time to get into it. The beginning, particularly, is VERY slow moving. The novel lacks the things one loves Greene for; the subtly written yet overwhelmingly powerful struggles the characters engage in with morality and/or religion, as well as a narrator who is unreliable and yet sympathetic.