11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Remarkable Story of a Value Investing Legend, March 23, 2011
This review is from: There's Always Something to Do: The Peter Cundill Investment Approach (Paperback)
Peter Cundill, the subject of this book, took control of the All-Canadian Venture Fund in 1975 (which became the Cundill Value Fund), and over the next 33 years he averaged a compound annual rate of return of 15.2%. Put differently, $10,000 invested in Cundill's fund in 1975 grew to over $1 million during that time. The assets under his management in this fund jumped from about $8 million to $20 billion over the same time (obviously, there were inflows to the fund). That's significant, because keeping a very strong track record becomes progressively harder as the amount of money you are managing gets large. Cundill's success over such a long period of time is simply remarkable. Okay, so how did he do it? Please read on.
The title of this book is taken from a quote by value investor, Irving Kahn: "There's always something to do. You just have to look harder, be creative and a little flexible." That's a good description of the work process for any value investor, and it's an especially good description of what Peter Cundill did to earn his success.
Way back in 1968, a book titled "The Money Game" (about the go-go investing years during the 1960s) became a best seller. The book's author followed with another, not-quite-as-popular book, "Super Money." It was "Super Money" that 35-year-old investor Peter Cundill read during a plane trip in 1973. In that book, he read about Benjamin Graham's (and David Dodd's) classic book, "Securities Analysis," and after reading Graham and Dodd's book Cundill seriously took up in-depth value investing. Benjamin Graham had that kind of effect on people. Years earlier, a young Warren Buffett read Graham's "The Intelligent Investor," and remarked that "the scales fell from my eyes." (By the way, just about all of these books are still available, and they may rightfully be described as almost timeless.)
Basically, Cundill came to the realization that a stock isn't necessarily cheap simply because it has a low price-to-earnings ratio, a nice dividend yield or even a high growth rate. All these things may be good, but a stock is cheap when careful analysis of the company's balance sheet reveals that the stock's price is meaningfully lower than its intrinsic value. That's classic Graham-and-Dodd, margin-of-safety value investing, and it is what Cundill excelled at.
Although "There's Always Something to Do" is well-written by author Christopher Risso-Gill, one very interesting aspect of this book is its frequent quotes from Cundill's daily journal compiled over 45 years. Thus, the reader gets to hear directly from Cundill, and his at-the-time comments about buying ABC or selling XYZ stock are not filtered through after-the-fact 'analysis.'
This book covers most of the investment topics you would expect to read about a value investor, including a global search for value (like John Templeton was famous for), and a focus on unglamorous areas of investing (which is where values sometimes hide) like distressed corporate securities and defaulted sovereign debt.
Toward the end of this enjoyable book is a chapter that describes in some detail a number of the qualities that make for a great investor: insatiable curiosity, patience, concentration, attention to detail, independence of thought, humility and skepticism to name some. From personal experience, I would note that they are all easy to say and hard to do.
In short, this book represents an excellent addition to the library of anyone who is serious about value investing. One last thing: In 2006 Peter Cundill was diagnosed with Fragile X, a degenerative neurological disorder, and he passed away very recently (on January 24, 2011), at age 72. He will be missed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Eureka Moment - Finding The 'Margin of Safety' Approach, March 7, 2011
This review is from: There's Always Something to Do: The Peter Cundill Investment Approach (Paperback)
Though Peter Cundill did not find the Benjamin Graham value approach until relatively later in his investment career, he found it nevertheless and was quite successful at the process once identified and mastered it quickly. What makes this book a worthy candidate for any investor's bookshelf is that Peter Cundill kept a daily journal for forty-five years which is used extensively in conjunction with the text. If you are mildly acquainted with the deep value 'margin-of-safety' process, this quote from his journal should sound familiar, 'be prepared to put money into anything, anywhere, provided that the downside is measurable and acceptable and the chances of a good profit appear to be better than 50%. I will not take gambles, but it is part of my job description to be ready to take very carefully calculated risks.' That is in essence, protect the downside first and the upside will usually take care of itself.
All in all, Peter's process of 'Buying a Dollar for Forty Cents' is a worthy addition to the investment community and to the margin of safety framework. As the potential reader can not search this book yet, a sample of the first few chapters are as follows: (twenty-two chapters in total)
Forward - By Prem Watsa (Fairfax Financial)
Chapter 1 - The Eureka Moment
Chapter 2 - Getting To First Base
Chapter 3 - Launching A Value Fund on Value Principles
Chapter 4 - Value Investments In Action
Chapter 5 - Going Global
Chapter 6 - Swapping Continents
Chapter 7 - A Decade of Success
Chapter 8 - New Dimensions
Chapter 9 - Investment Stratagems
Chapter 10 - Surviving a Crash
Chapter 11-22, Worthy Reading
Valuable References:
Security Analysis: Sixth Edition, Foreword by Warren Buffett (Security Analysis Prior Editions) by Graham & Dodd
The Aggressive Conservative Investor (Wiley Investment Classics) by Martin J. Whitman and Martin Shubik
Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits and Other Writings by Philip A. Fisher
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting trader, poor book, May 12, 2011
This review is from: There's Always Something to Do: The Peter Cundill Investment Approach (Paperback)
Before I red this book I had never heard before of Cundill before. I thought it would be an interesting read, since value investing appeals to me and this book would have a diary of Cundill and his investment adventures. Cundill has an impressive track record so I bought this book.
Apparently he was not very successful in investing until he red Securtiy Analysis from Graham and started studying value investing in depth. What I found interesting is the way he looks at the assets of a company, the book value more precisely. Also the way he makes his entry into value plays, averages down and sells half his position ones his gains are equal to his initial investment.
Unfortunately, that was all I was able to get out of this book. The diary entries that are mentioned in this book are very brief and kind philosophic talk on value investing and trading in general. Most frustrating is the lack of security analysis or the way Cundill would look at a company or a balance sheet. Somewhere in the beginning of this book a short list of selection criteria is noted that Cundill uses to scan for investments. That's kind of helpful, but if you've red more books on Value Investing like me it doesn't add much value. The whole book continues like this praising Cundill the Great Investor, but nowhere it really gets deep into Cundill his analysis of investments.
In that way don't expect to get lots of useful stuff out of this book for your trading.
If you're not bothered by that, in case you just want a nice read on value investing, you might try this one. Otherwise, I'd give it a pass. There are more useful books on value investing out there.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No