28 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Most stories are competent but superficial, October 10, 2011
This review is from: Down These Strange Streets (Hardcover)
I recently realized one thing I've been liking about multiple-author short-story collections: Most of the contents stand alone. I always appreciate new fantasy and SF set in worlds I've come to love. However, I find it increasingly exhausting to embark on authors who are new to me. I can't just pick up a book any more. When I look up potential purchases on the basis of a review or ad, almost all turn out to be part of some interminable series, so that I'd have to buy umpteen additional books to fully comprehend one. Because I want to read an ongoing story line all at once, I end up setting aside books for years till the author finally completes the series.
Unfortunately, many of the 16 stories in Down These Strange Streets are outtakes from different huge series that I've never heard of. And many of these spend so much room introducing whiz-bang characters and concepts from their world, and feeding new readers bits of backstory, that little room is left for actually telling this story. Plots tend to be thin and character development nonexistent. You can't sympathize with any character when you're constantly trying to get up to speed on exactly how many kinds of supernatural entities exist in this world and what magical gizmos they use. The worst offender is Glen Cook's "Shadow Thieves."
Notable exceptions are: First, Joe Lansdale's "The Bleeding Shadow," a harrowing tale of a Depression-era blues musician seeking supernatural aid for his art. The difficult relationship between the musician's sister and her sometime boyfriend (who have teamed to intervene) has real emotional depth. "Styx and Stones" is an overly cute title that has little to do with the story. It's a competent and well-researched historical mystery by Steven Saylor, set in ancient Rome. I've previously encountered his characters Gordianus and Antipater in an SF magazine and was almost intrigued enough to embark on the series, but decided not when I discovered there are already at least 11 books and more to come. Bradley Denton's "The Adakian Eagle" uses Dashiell Hammett as an important character. If you're not familiar with his real-life bio, it helps to read a short one online. This is the best story in the book. The narrator is a resentful, but still likeable, young soldier stationed in Alaska during World War 2. He is trying to balance military duty with human morals, to discover who and who not to trust, and to control his own destructive impulses, among events that will determine the rest of his life. Character development? Plot? You bet.
Down These Strange Streets probably has a winning commercial formula, a carefully chosen mix of authors and worlds that markets something to every potential reader. It's just that most of the stories are, at best, workmanlike.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Pleasantly Surprised, October 15, 2011
This review is from: Down These Strange Streets (Hardcover)
This is a book that grew on me as I read. I initially ordered it (Kindle) just because there were several authors I know and read. A couple of those (S. M. Stirling and Diana Gabaldon) were not quite what I would have expected in this book, but as it turned out, they were both enjoyable reads. Those two individuals have an unfortunate habit of writing very long novels that can drone on and on - a short story format precluded that. Some of the stories did seem more like samples/snippets from a longer book - that is; the ending was abrupt and unresolved. Another reviewer mentioned that some of these are outtakes of longer series - it's a challenge to write a short story that can stand on its own and still be meaningful to followers of the series. It CAN be done; one such story in another book drew me into Kat Richardson's Greywalker series. Unfortunately that was not always the case in the stories contained here.
But even those less than satisfying attempts were, overall, better than I was expecting. Some of the worlds introduced were enjoyable enough for a short story but not ones that I would be interested in reading a series about. And some of the story twists were unexpected, veering away from the all-to-common vampire/werewolf "formula." I'll give this book high marks for that.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
mixed bag, October 16, 2011
I bought this for the Diane Gabaldon story, but thoroughly enjoyed the whole book. The stories don't have a linking theme other than their otherwordly-ness, and yet all were enjoyable.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
