Customer Reviews


10 Reviews
5 star:
 (8)
4 star:    (0)
3 star:    (0)
2 star:    (0)
1 star:
 (2)
 
 
 
 
 
Average Customer Review
Share your thoughts with other customers
Create your own review
 
 
Only search this product's reviews

The most helpful favorable review
The most helpful critical review


18 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars A landmark work
I must admit I was a little bit skeptical opening this book, due to its reputation for intolerance. But the very first page will make you realize just how important it is. This is a plea, a loud call to save Israel before it is to late. It is not the much maligned ignorant intolerant ranting that it is accused of. Rather this enlightening work, written by hand and...
Published on November 2, 2004 by Seth J. Frantzman

versus
1 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars More pro-zionist propaganda and lies. See the review below. It is fact.
It is a well known fact that the author of this book was extremely racist (and preoccupied with the most violent predilictions). I am so tired of the zionists portraying the innocent victim imagery (when clearly they are not). The article below is an expose of the zionist lies.

'Why are jews persecuted?', by Jayne Gardener.

I always used to...
Published 19 months ago by Suhail Ahmad


Most Helpful First | Newest First

18 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars A landmark work, November 2, 2004
This review is from: They Must Go (Hardcover)
I must admit I was a little bit skeptical opening this book, due to its reputation for intolerance. But the very first page will make you realize just how important it is. This is a plea, a loud call to save Israel before it is to late. It is not the much maligned ignorant intolerant ranting that it is accused of. Rather this enlightening work, written by hand and smuggled out of a Ramle prison, calls for the separation of the Arabs and Israelis as the only hope to a true and lasting peace. Anyone who has been to Israel will understand that this is necessary. But for those still taken in by what Kahane called the `myth' of coexistence this book will explain in excruciating, terrifying detail the truth behind the coexistence of the 1920s and 30s, the endless riots and assaults on Jewish refugees and Jewish villages. Separate chapters detail the transfer of Germans from Poland and Czechslovakia after World War Two, as well as enlightening paragraphs on the India-Pakistan transfers of 1948 and the transfer in Cyprus in 1974 and even among the Turks and Greeks in 1921. But this book also tells the dismal stories of places where transfer did not take place such as Sri Lanka or Burma, where strife, hatred, intolerance and racism have resulted.

Of course it is easy to label this book hateful, for most of us raised in the West it will seem incredibly intolerant and primitive, but this book understands the truth about how things really are in 90% of the world. For anyone interested in the survival of Israel, for anyone wanting to understand the modern day Israeli right, and for anyone wanting a totally new view of the conflict this is a must buy.

Seth J. Frantzman
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


19 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars Logic and Clarity, May 12, 2002
By 
This review is from: They Must Go (Hardcover)
Kahane's politics, while controversial and highly criticized, are made clear and concise in this work. Once having read this book, the reader has no doubt as to Kahane's philosophy and ideology on the matter of the Arabs in Israel. He uses logic and clarity in the presentation of his politics and does an incredible service to his readers with the use of historical precedent.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


12 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars Fabulous. Twenty years later, Rabbi Kahane was correct., April 4, 2006
This review is from: They Must Go (Hardcover)
I wanted to read what this Rabbi Kahane fellow written on this subject after hearing his very articulate, informative and detailed debates with such individuals as Alan Dershowitz, Dennis Prager and many others. I was amazed at this inspiring and courageous man's perceptions and solutions for the problems that contaminate Israel and subsequently every other Liberal/Socialist democracy in their continual drift into immorality. Twenty years later, with the immense political scandals, corruption and the realities of Islamic/Communist terrorism, Kahane was right. This work was written when Rabbi Kahane had been imprisoned without legal reason nor trial. He was the only Israeli leader to attack their major problem head on: The Arabs. Islam, if one takes the time to read the Islamic holy books, is against anything non-Islam. Islamic Law is directly against the Jewish State, the rise in Islamic terrorism and rise of a terrorist organization to bring about a solely Arab/Islamic "State of Palestine" speak truth for Rabbi Kahane's views, even 20 years after his murder. The fact of the matter is that the Quraan as well the Communist Manifesto legitimate and advocate terrorism weather it be religious terrorism or political terrorism the result is the rule by one imperialist genocidal religion or one expansionist yet murderous ideology. "From Time Immemorial" - J.Peters, "The High Cost of Peace" - Y. Bodansky and "To Eliminate The Opiate" - Rabbi M. S. Antelman and lastly Www.JTF.Org for reality based information on Israel and America. Great read highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars The Flood., September 6, 2010
This review is from: They Must Go (Hardcover)
As I read Dr. Kahane's "They must go" book, an old joke comes to mind.

A pious Jew lives in a two-story house with a flat roof. His radio announces the coming of a flood. The Jew puts on his Shabbat outfit, grabs his prayer book, goes out to the street-facing balcony and starts praying to God for survival.
An empty taxi arrives and offers to take the Jew to higher grounds.
The Jew refuses the service. Why would he use the taxi? All his life he was fulfilling the Torah laws, prayed diligently, gave to the needy. Surely, God will not let him perish.
The flood comes and inundates the first floor.
The Jew rises to the second floor, approached the window and continues praying to God.
A boat approaches his window and offers to take the Jew to higher grounds.
The Jew refuses the service. Why would he use the boat? All his life he kept within the Torah laws, prayed diligently, gave to the needy. Surely, God will not let him perish.
The waters inundate the second floor.
The Jew rises to the flat roof, and continues praying to God for rescue.
A helicopter comes over him and offers to take him to dry land.
The Jew refuses the service. Why would he use the helicopter? All his life he followed the Torah laws, prayed diligently, gave to the needy. Surely, God will not let him perish.
The helicopter leaves and the waters continue to rise.
The Jew continues to pray fervently until the waters get up to his chin. At the last moment he pronounces the prayer "Shema Israel..." and drowns in the rising waters.
Immediately upon arrival to Heavens, the Jew storms to God's Headquarters.
"How dare you" - he shouts in God's face, "Don't we have a Covenant with You? Did I not follow the Torah laws? Did I not pray diligently? Did I not give to the needy? How come you let me perish?!"
"Yes" - God replied, - "I know how good a Jew you are. You were always in my care. Before the flood started, I sent you a taxi. When the waters inundated the first floor, I sent you a boat. When you were standing knee-high in water on your roof, I sent you a helicopter. What better care did you expect? Apparently, you did not have the will to survive."

The Jews could let all Arabs flee Israel in 1948. Instead, the Israelis pleaded with them to stay and be given equal rights.

The Jews could encourage the Arabs to leave Israel in 1967, when they were petrified by the Israeli Six-Day War victory and expected to be indiscriminately slaughtered, as they would do to the Jews upon an Arab victory. Instead, the Jews stopped the Arab flight.

It is now obvious, as it was obvious to Dr. Kahane all along, that blood-letting will not stop between the Jews and Arabs in the Land of Israel until either the Arabs will be deported or the Jews slaughtered. The question now is only - what vehicle will God send to fulfill this vision. Will the Jews use it?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


29 of 42 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars Should have been listening to him all along, October 1, 2001
This review is from: They Must Go (Hardcover)
Now that we see Palestineans dancing in the street over American deaths, we can finally stop deluding ourselves as to their better intentions. Rabbi Meir Kahane forsaw the ultimate failure of the peace process in Israel in 1980 and for his troubles he was branded a Jewish Nazi, an Ayatollah, an extremist, etc.

While his argument tends to the extreme and while he paints the picture in blacks and whites, he does have a good point in this treatise.

Basically, the Palestineans feel that their land has been stolen. They will not be bought by educational opportunities, land for peace deals or economics. All liberal attempts to do these things only insult the Palestineans. His argument is that we must save lives by removing Arabs from Israel (including the so-called occupied territories) once and for all. To fail in this will only cause bloodshed on both sides.

It's sad to know how right he was proven by the Barak administration (one which I supported up until the attempts to give away Jerusalem). It would have been better to listen to Kahane in the 70s, but it's not too late to listen to him now.

Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


16 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars What a book!, November 21, 2001
By 
Cassio Sztokfisz (São Paulo, Brazil) - See all my reviews
This review is from: They Must Go (Hardcover)
Rabbi Kahane shows the greatest and most realistic understand of the question about the arabs who live in Israel, as citizens.He explanates the impossibility of jewish-arab togetherness in Israel and the threat which is Arabs living in Israel.Quoting several researches, journal articles, Torah(bible)passages and historical facts, Rabbi Kahane clearly reveals the blindness and fear of Israel's government about the question, making critics on both left and right wing parties.But he doesn't stop on the critics; he goes further and proposes a solution which, in my point of view, is very reasonable and logic. Anyone looking for an unbiased and realistic thought over the Israeli arab question must read this awesome book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


18 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars http://masada2000.org, December 12, 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: They Must Go (Hardcover)
Rabbi Meir Kahane was a prophet for our time. The exponentially growing Israeli-Arab population is a "Cancer" within Israel. Within a short time, they will be the majority within the State of Israel and can "demogratically" vote out Israel and vote in still another ARab State! Thus, They MUST Go!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


13 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars THEY MUST DEFINITELY GO, March 2, 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: They Must Go (Hardcover)
THIS BOOK CLEARLY EXPLAINS WHY THERE WILL NEVER BE A PEACEFUL SOLUTION TO THE ARAB ISRAELI CONFLICT.THIS BOOK EERILY PREDICTS THE FUTURE OF THE CONFLICT WITH IMMACULATE PRECISION.THE AUTHOR WAS ASSASINATED BY AN ARAB TERRORIST IN NEW YORK IN NOVEMBER OF 1991 WHILE PREACHING HIS MASTERFUL IDEAS AT HIS PULPIT.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


1 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars More pro-zionist propaganda and lies. See the review below. It is fact., June 21, 2010
This review is from: They Must Go (Hardcover)
It is a well known fact that the author of this book was extremely racist (and preoccupied with the most violent predilictions). I am so tired of the zionists portraying the innocent victim imagery (when clearly they are not). The article below is an expose of the zionist lies.

'Why are jews persecuted?', by Jayne Gardener.

I always used to wonder what it was about Jews that made people throughout history despise them. If they were indeed "God's chosen" I thought, they had to be the unluckiest people in the history of the world. Why were they persecuted throughout history?. Why had the Nazis herded them into cattle cars and taken them to "extermination camps" to dispose once and for all of the "Jewish problem?"

I suddenly recognized that if Hitler had developed a "Final Solution" to the Jewish question, that there had to have been a "Jewish Problem." Could the Jews have in any way behaved in such a manner that would make the countries in which they resided turn against them, or were they just unfortunate, innocent victims?. I set out to find answers for my questions, turning to the Internet, but also reading many books on the subject. What I found became incredibly disturbing to me.

I had not known that throughout history, the Jews had been expelled from 79 countries, some countries more than once. I had not known that the majority of the claims they made about the Holocaust that I had believed unquestioningly for so long were in fact fraudulent.

The books I had read and the movies I had seen about the "Holocaust" and wept over, were nothing but thinly veiled attempts to garner unwavering sympathy for the state of Israel and an excuse to extort billions of dollars from Germany and 1.25 billion dollars from the Swiss banks. I learned that Hitler was actually an illegitimate half jew. His mother was a maid in a jewish household and the head of the household raped her. To this, day, all of Hitler's writings have not been released, and historians are now suspecting that Hitler's diaries have been tampered with and falsified.

I discovered that a book I had read many times as a teenager and cried about, 'Anne Frank's Diary', had been at least partially written by someone other than Anne Frank. I learned that the confessions at the Nuremburg Trials and the executions of so many German "war criminals" were extracted under torture and the defendants were being tried, judged and condemned by their very accusers.

I learned about the "false flag" operations, especially the Lavon affair and the tragedy of the USS Liberty, an American ship that was attacked by the Israelis during the 1967 war. 34 young American men were killed and many more wounded. To add insult to injury, the Israelis claimed that it was simply an unfortunate case of mistaken identity, something the survivors of the Liberty have always vehemently denied. They, however, were threatened with court martial if they were ever to tell their stories.

I learned about the Jonathan Pollard spy case and other incidents of Israeli Jews spying against their supposed "closest ally". I became shocked and horrified as I learned about the treatment of the Palestinian people in the occupied territories at the hands of the Israeli Defense Forces and the Jewish settlers. Israel purports to be the only democracy in the middle east, but it's only a democracy for Jews. Non-Jews are not considered equal.

I was horrified and disgusted to see pictures of innocent Palestinian children burned beyond recognition or beheaded or tortured and suffering from serious gunshot wounds after being targeted by the IDF for no other reason than that they are Palestinian. I was disgusted to learn of the absolute hatred jews have towards muslims and Islam and their evil plot to wipe the muslim population off the face of the Earth, to steal muslim lands and their inherent natural resources.

I found out about the Jewish history of avariciousness, larceny, lying, manipulation and their questionable and usurious business practices. I learned about their roles in the radical homosexual movement, the radical feminist movement, the jewish owned pornography industry as well as their over-representation in the abortion industry.

I discovered their major role in organized crime (including the drug trade) , in the slave trade, in the civil rights movement and in Communism, an ideology that is responsible for the deaths of untold millions and the repression of many millions more. I learned that the black market organ trade is owned and controlled by jews in America and Israel. In fact 80% of black market organs end up in Israel.

I learned that it was Jewish supremacists behind the war against Christianity. It is they who want God out of the Pledge of Allegiance and all symbols of Christianity removed from public life. They have driven Christianity from the public schools despite Christianity being the majority religion. They have hijacked Christianity by mixing it with pagan beliefs of mythra and calling it Christmas and adding the masonic symbol of the cross. I learned of the satanic masonic rituals, which have all been taken from the kabbalah (jewish black magic). Indeed, it is jewish black magic that is the backbone of free-masonry.

I read about their hatred towards non-jews and referring to us as 'gentiles' (which is an offensive term) and their hatefulness of the Babylonian Talmud and their utter disrespect for, and hostility towards Jesus Christ, the Virgin Mary and Christianity and Christians in general.

I learned about their "chutzpah" in claiming that 'Gentile' lives were worth no more than the lives of barnyard animals but that they considered Jewish lives to be akin to God Himself. It is okay for a jew to steal from a 'Gentile' or to kill a 'Gentile' (even to rape a 'gentile' girl and later kill her!), but Jewish lives are sacred. It is also a sin for a jew to charge another jew interest but it is a blessing to charge non-jews interest!. In fact the whole extortionate system of interest was designed by jews 2000 years ago!.

I learned of their control of the majority of wealth, the media and academia despite them making up less than 2% of the population (even lower in Canada).

They are behind the ridiculous political correctness movement and hate crime legislation that was drafted so as to silence anyone who might figure out their agenda and attempt to shed light on it.

Honest men like German Rudolf, David Irving and many more, previously recognized as great historians, were arrested, charged with hate crimes and incarcerated simply for having made academic enquiry into a specific period of history.

Other so called "revisionists" or "holocaust deniers" have been intimidated, harassed, assaulted and smeared, simply for trying to get at the truth.

I found out that the Jews are responsible for our wide open immigration policies that have created the phenomena of "multiculturalism," "diversity," inclusiveness" and "pluralism."

It is mostly they who push for race mixing and miscegenation, knowing full well that it would eventually lead to those of white European descent being minorities in their own countries and the eventual extermination of white European DNA.

It is patently clear that the war in Iraq is due solely to Israel wanting to cripple the muslims by destabilizing their Arab governments in order to achieve hegemony in the middle east.

It would be unthinkable for Israeli jews to die for this cause, so they manipulated the US into the war with the help of the Jewish Zionist "Israel firsters" in the Bush administration in order that the blood of way too many young American men and women is shed instead.

It is they who control the middle eastern foreign policy of the most powerful country in the world, the USA. It is they who control congress, the senate and the puppet president, George W. Bush. It is the jews of America and Israel who control the production and price of crude oil and manipulate the international economy for their own evil gains.

They have so much control in movies and television that we are now subjected to endless programs and Hollywood movies that grossly offend and demonise Islam, muslims values and degrade the traditional family

After sober reflection on what I had discovered about Jewish supremacy and Zionism, I had to abandon all my previously held notions as to the history of Jewish persecution. What I have trouble understanding is why they continue this behaviour in whichever society they live, knowing that eventually they will overplay their hand and their perfidy will be exposed yet again. Have they so much contempt for history and learned nothing?.

As more and more people become aware of what is going on and who is responsible for it, anger is going to rise as it already has in the former Soviet Union and eastern European countries.

They may control television, movies and the print media, but they don't control the internet. At least not yet. Blogs and websites devoted to "outing" the Jewish supremacists will ultimately be their downfall.

If everyone who sees this information passes it on to at least one other person, the crimes and misdeeds of the Jewish supremacists and Zionists will be exposed. Please, do your part.

Pass it on. Our world as we know it is counting on you and if the Islamic prophecies come true, then a great leader will emerge from the muslims and take the battle to Israel and end the tyranny of the jews.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


9 of 47 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars "Mein Kampf", for the Israelis..., January 29, 2005
This review is from: They Must Go (Hardcover)
What is the difference between the filth, bigotry and racism espoused by Meir Kahane in the 1980's, and the xenophobic, black-propaganda vaunted by Adolf Hitler himself in the 1930's?

Apparently, not much...

* Both sought to maintain the "sanctity" of their homeland, as well as the purity of their cultural/ethnic background.

* Both sought the persecution and containment of legal citizens simply because they were NOT of the "right" ethnicity.

* Both seem to have offered a "final solution" to their respective "dilemmas" (However, Kahane's version is a much more 'politically-correct' genocide, wherein the euphemism "transfer" is utilized [Thank you, to the Propaganda Department]...)

* And last, but certainly not least, both - tragically - had enough seemingly joyous and supportive fellow citizens (of their own ethnicity of course) to have them elected to the parliament of their respective countries.

In fact I can sum this book up in two words (of which, many others will agree, I'm sure):

Heil Kahane!

Oh wait, in fact, that's what they called his biography, isn't it...

The co-incidences and similarities between Kahanes ideology, and that of Hitler's is a tragic, and absurd irony (especially in light of the recent 60th anniversary of the holocaust.)

After reading this Jewish Supremacist diatribe, the reader will quickly realise that the famous term, "Never Again!" - at least in Rabbi Meir Kahane's mind - actually means, "Never again [to the Jews]"...

Exclusivity is from the realm of tyrants & dictators; when will we learn?
___________
[...]
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No


Most Helpful First | Newest First

This product

They Must Go
They Must Go by Meir Kahane (Hardcover - Oct. 1981)
Used & New from: $19.00
Add to wishlist See buying options