Most Helpful Customer Reviews
20 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Second book in a delightful series, August 1, 2006
"Thirty-Three Teeth" continues the saga of Dr. Siri Paiboun who, well into his seventies, is more or less drafted to serve as the coroner of Laos. The first in the series, "The Coroner's Lunch," was, for me, the nicest surprise I had all last year (from a book, that is), and the new one is, if anything, even better. What makes these books so wonderful? Well, practically everything. The characters are fresh, the writing is sharp and, in this age of bloat, kept refreshingly short. The setting is completely unexplored up until now, and in Cotterill's vision it's a comic-opera banana dictatorship run by incompetents whose only real motivation is to dig a protective moat around their own rear ends, a place where truth comes in a distant second to doctrine and expedience. But what I like best is the way Cotterill interweaves into his mysteries the internal world of the Laotians, rich in both spirit and spirits. Dr. Siri -- not entirely to his pleasure -- has gained entry into the world of the dead, and his dreams are full of the people whose deaths he somewhat reluctantly investigates. This additional layer is never intrusive and never overdone. It gives us insight into a worldview that is very different that that of the West, one that is in some ways richer and more beautiful. It wouldn't be fair to write even a few paragraphs about this book without saying that Cotterill is also very funny. From my perspective, this is the most delightful new series in several years. I ordered the new one, "Disco for the Departed," months before it came out, and it's currently sitting on my To Be Read shelf -- I keep putting it off because once I start it I'll read it in one sitting, and then it'll be over. Give Colin Cotterill a try. I've bought several copies of the first two books to give away, but since I probably don't know you, you'll have to pay for your own.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
More than just a sequel, March 9, 2006
Dr Siri will live on in my mind as a great gumshoe (or sandal) detective and also as being quite representative of the wonderful humor and intellect of the Lao people. My Lao wife (only 6 months in the US from Vientiane) also read the book, laughed throughout and confirmed the geography and characters. Even if you have little interest in the country or people, this is a great detective novel. If you are interested in Lao, you will find a wealth of rich detail. Colin...write some more!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
We Have Spirit, Yes We Do, We Have Spirit, How About You?, November 27, 2005
This second book in the Dr. Siri series continues the adventures of 72-year-old state coroner of the newly liberated People's Democratic Republic of Laos, circa 1976. Readers who haven't read the first book ("The Coroner's Lunch") should definitely stop and go back, as it provides a great deal of background and depth for the characters, including explaining just how Dr. Siri has become the carrier of the spirit of a millennia-old Hmong shaman. The setting finds the Pathet Lao government shakily trying to consolidate its power by banning longtime cultural holidays such as Songkran (New Year) and the Rocket Festival, inviting in plenty of Soviet and other Communist advisors (there's a kind of silly cameo by Kim Jong Il), and arranging for the exile of the deposed royal family. Against this backdrop, three major plotlines emerge. First, someone or something caused a government worker to toss himself off the seventh story of a building. Second, an unknown creature or person is killing women in Vientiane, leaving behind ravaged corpses that look like the victims of grizzly bear attacks. Finally, a pair of charred corpses await Dr. Siri's inspection in the former royal city of Luang Prabang. The first book in the series subverted genre convention by weaving in the supernatural. In it, the spirit world was shown to be a healthy and thriving force with direct influence in the physical realm. Here, that aspect takes over the plotlines to a much greater degree. Both the mystery of the suicide and the mystery of the mauled corpses are directly linked to the spirit world, and Dr. Siri's trip to Luang Prabang is also heavily tinged with supernatural elements. Readers who like their crime books realistic will find this one much too far-fetched to enjoy, as Siri spends more time collecting clues from enigmatic spirits than anything else. Besides the overemphasis on the supernatural, the book just doesn't measure up to the first in a number of other ways. The local color is almost completely lacking, and the dialogue and interactions between characters are far less engaging. In fact, without the background on them from the previous book, they would be far too sparsely drawn. The sole exception to this is Nurse Dtui, who is given a substantial role to play, and has hidden depths revealed. Owing to events of the first book, Dr. Siri himself is somewhat different as well, a little more happy-go-lucky and unburdened, much more of an impish figure. This is all well and good, but it robs him of some of the weight that made him so compelling a figure the first time around. This was a letdown after the series' strong start, hopefully the next book will ease off on the supernatural aspect and give Dr. Siri some a really juicy plot to explore.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|