| ||||||||||||||||||||||||
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Great Role Model,
This review is from: Thomas Mellon And His Times (Calvin Center Series) (Paperback)
I enjoyed reading this very interesting book. It along with the autobiographies of Ben Franklin and Andrew Carnegie give many insights on how to raise yourself up from poverty and contribute to society.His insights on the court system based on his 10 years as a judge I think are useful today. Read this before hiring an attorney or going to court. Most tantelizing are his descriptions on how he raised and related to his children and helped them to become successful. He clearly was a stern, strict Presbyterian. But at the same time he was a warm loving parent. His insights on how to raise children to be both successful and close to their parents are more useful than most current child rearing books. And of course for many the most useful part of this book is his description of how he raised himself up from a poor immigrant farmer to the founder of one of America's most wealthy families. I come from a very poor family and now own my own business. I have adult children who I have a good relationship with. I have read this book 3 times over the last 10 years. Each time I get more insights on how to lead a better more successful life. I have probably read 200 books in the last 10 years. I think this is one of the best. And one I enjoyingly return to every 2 to 5 years.
4.0 out of 5 stars
A true who done it lies in these pages,
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Thomas Mellon And His Times (Calvin Center Series) (Paperback)
I agree that Thomas Mellon is a very, very good writer. I also enjoyed the book a few times. It is hard for me to understand how someone could come away with the "work ethic only", or "Horatio Alger" story when it comes to this book. The Judge pretty much makes no bones about the fact that he set his sights on marrying into a family (the Negleys) whose property he then flipped into what would become Mellon Bank. We are not treated to that part of the story here. Don't misunderstand - I don't begrudge the Judge, but History is not well served in some instances. It is the Judge's account, though. The "Mystery" I speak of is the identity of "A" in the 'Vexatious Litigation' chapter. This is complicated, but we have 2 biographers, both excellent writers and reaserchers, coming to different conclusions as to who this person is while studying and having access to the same material. The Judge lays it out bare in his account (so bare that it was deleted from the second printing back when). Burton Hersh, in his book "The Mellons: A Fortune In History" (1978) relates the story and names J.B. Corey as the nemesis. David Cannadine, in his recent book "Mellon: An American Life" (2006) - mainly about Andrew W. Mellon - names Felix C. Negley as the culprit. Let me briefly quote book and sources: TMT: "...the litigation commenced in 1876 and ended in 1880, but its roots reached as far back as 1859...I entered into a parnership with him ('A') in September of 1959...according to our arrangement I furnished the money to purchase valuble coal works at Braddocks [and] Sandy Creek...in July 1864, our partnership ended by mutual consent." (Notes: Chapter XVI, pgs. 182-204: "A" is PROBABLY [my upper case] J.B. Corey with whom Mellon did business in coal until 1863 [sic]..." BJH: "...functioning unnoticed as the 'capitalist' behind J.B. Corey and Co....for perhaps 20 years the Judge's association with Corey undertunneled his investments...Corey ran the works; Mellon supplied the cash. Corey directed Mellon's capital into mines at Braddock and Sandy Creek." (Notes: TMT as source from book). DC: [in 1859, Mellon]...ventured more deeply into the coal business, and went into partnership with his wife's cousin, Felix Casper Negley. He financed the purchase of coal works at Braddock and Sandy Creek, but despite kinship...Mellon was later obliged to resort to 'vexatious litigation'. Much more successful was his partnership with J.B. Corey...who became a lifelong friend." (Notes: TM's property dealings 1855-1869 are itemized in the indexes held in Pittsburgh by the Recorder of Deeds.) Now, if you follow those sources it leads to the inevitable conundrum - which is hard to fathom since the case of "A" is a substantial part of the Judge's frustration, invective, and Chapter. Ironically, the only item that I have that was passed down through my family with regard to Felix C. Negley (he is my great-great grandfather) is a letter to him written by his "faithful substitute" in the Civil War, dated early 1865, addressed to him, describing events at Petersburg. A strange heirloom at best, but even stranger when one considers that the Judge states that the partnership was dissolved in July, 1864, when, as he says, ['A'] caught the military fever..." The only way that this can be solved is to actually go to the Recorder of Deeds in Pittsburgh and find out, but what does this say for the accuracy or even veracity of anything in ANY of these books? Yes, it was a long time ago...but not that long ago and somebody did not do their research homework too well. Very frustrating.
5.0 out of 5 stars
Even if you aren't a Mellon, you will enjoy this book.,
By
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Thomas Mellon And His Times (Calvin Center Series) (Paperback)
Judge Mellon is a very talented writer. It is following a Scotch Irish family from their home in Northern Ireland to their life in Pittsburg. I love this book. The Judge's brother, Samuel, is my great-great grandfather and it was enjoyable reading about him.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Suggested Tags from Similar Products(What's this?)Be the first one to add a relevant tag (keyword that's strongly related to this product).
|
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|