Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not the usual fantasy fare, June 9, 2004
This is not a book to read if you're seeking a stirring adventure. Thomas does go on a long, strange trip, but the focus is as much on how his life impacts the people important to him as it is on his experiences in Elfland. Kushner's decision to write only Thomas's Elfland experiences in his own voice, then, is a clever one. Also, seeing Thomas before and after his journey through the eyes of others reveals the extent of the change in him more thoroughly than if we remained in his head. Kushner does an excellent job of giving each of the four narrators a distinct perspective, a difficult thing to do. And because they see different things in each other and percieve their relationships with one another differently, there's the opportunity to ponder how it is we get along in the world when we all have disparate visions of reality. This is a marvelously subtle way to question whether True Thomas can ever wholly tell the truth. Is the truth absolute, or is it changeable depending on individual understanding? This question lingers long after the book is shut. So why did I give Thomas the Rhymer only three stars? Well, for all the lovely writing and thoughtful structure, it left me cold. For one, the Faery Queen who is the heart of all this trouble and change seemed to me little more than a blowup doll. She laid a couple of spells on Thomas, but mostly all they did was copulate, and I needed either for her to be more interesting or to feel more of why Thomas was infatuated with her. (Because of the distance I felt from her, also, the ending of the book was less moving for me than it should have been.) Apart from that, I felt Kushner passed over a great opportunity to explore what the effects of Thomas's truth-saying might be. There was some of that, certainly, in the final section of the book, but much was made of the gift of truth-telling in Faery (and whether it was a gift at all), and then very little was done with it. Reading this book is a gamble. It has its virtues, and if you think you'll enjoy piecing together a larger meaning based on the fragments of story and varying points of view, you'll probably enjoy it well enough. However, if you want a story that swallows you whole and spits you out at the end with no respite to sit back and intellectualize, this may not be for you.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Another world, another time -- and that's the truth, January 23, 2003
Ellen Kushner has used an old ballad to create a fascinating and lovely tale of a young harpist and singer. Thomas appears one day at the door of an older and childless couple in the country who take him in and begin to love him as a son. He in turn, loves and respects them, all the while finding himself fascinating to and fascinated by a neighbor girl whose fiery temperament charms him. Off and on he reappears, leaving behind the courts of the nobility where he sings and plays for their pleasure. One day, while visiting his friends, he wanders onto Eildon Hills and meets the queen of the faeries. She takes him with her to her home where he abides for 7 years. He becomes her lover, her plaything, and a challenge to others in the land, because he is forbidden to speak to anyone except the queen. Having fulfilled his bargain, the queen returns Thomas to his own world, burdened with a terrible gift: He can only speak the truth. Told by Gavin, the elderly farmer, Thomas, and the girl whom he marries upon his return, the story of the life of True Thomas unwinds almost as a song does. There is melody, harmony, and many verses. For those who come to believe, the end will bring tears to their eyes. Readers who enjoy this book might also enjoy Kushner's earlier novel, Swordspoint. She does not write often, but she writes well.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Lyrical, Yes, But Otherwise..., October 26, 1999
By A Customer
Actually, I would give this book one star or none at all, but the writing is so beautiful, and the "supporting" cast in the real world is wonderful. However, I truly did not like the land of faery, I did NOT like the Faery Queen, and Thomas himself annoyed the hell out of me for the majority of the novel. The arrogance of Thomas and his obvious lack of love for his human wife (a wonderful character) completely spoiled this book for me. The elderly couple with whom Thomas occaisionally lives are likewise wonderful, but they cannot save the novel. The Queen of Faeries is just as irritating as Thomas is, and the faery court is a melee of cruel, heartless creatures. In the end, Thomas may have been given the dubious gift of truth, but he has not found the gift of wisdom. Yuck. Without the supporting characters in "our" world and the inherent beauty and subtlety of Kushner's writing style, this book would not be worth reading. Unless you enjoy arrogant, irritaing, contradictory, selfish, and ultimately unchangeable characters.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
