43 of 47 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The rebirth of the gods..., May 6, 2008
In 2004, Marvel initiated a major reboot of the Avengers franchise, with "Avengers" becoming "New Avengers", the new "Young Avengers" title, and new volumes of "Captain America" and "Iron Man". Thor's title was also cancelled, but no new reboot was immediately forthcoming, as, behind the scenes, such creative talents as Neil Gaiman and Mark Millar came and went, before it finally arrived in the hands of J. Michael Straczynski. After an absence of three years or so, Thor finally made his return to publication in the summer of 2007, with JMS writing and Olivier Coipel on art (in the intervening period, Millar had gone on to do a fakeout return in "Civil War" that turned out to be a cyborg-clone created by Iron Man, Mr. Fantastic, and Yellowjacket).
Michael Avon Oeming's excellent 'Ragnarok' story arc that concluded "Thor v.2" ended with the twilight of the Gods, where Thor realized that they had been enslaved in cyclical birth and death for years by beings known as Those Who Sit Above In Shadow. Thor broke the cycle, allowing him and his fellow Asgardians to at last rest. It was a brilliant story, and it left a new Thor series to go in virtually any direction it wanted. JMS opts here to advance into a new status quo, making the explicit point that the cycle is now broken, and the Asgardians' future is now completely open for them to decide; to a point, at least. Men, it is argued, decide if the Gods exist, and Thor's old alter ego Donald Blake, somehow now a mystical entity, recalls Thor from the void in order to revive the gods and face the future, which without them is perilous. So Thor returns to Earth, merged with Blake in a relationship that now resembles that of Rick Jones and Captain Marvel (the Marvel one). Establishing the city of Asgard in Oklahoma, near a quaint town, Thor ranges out to recover his fellow gods and, little by little, reacquaint himself with the world of men.
As far as an epic return goes, this has its moments, but it ultimately opts for a more sedate approach, one which conveys the mystical and mythical nature of Thor and his people, though at the same time it can be more than a bit slow (something aided by the erratic shipping schedule due to artist Coipel, though that is not an issue reading in trade). This arc sees Thor gather most of the pieces of his former life, with little action (there are maybe three fight scenes, total, one of which isn't a fight at all), and only two real instances of the greater Marvel Universe intruding. One is brief, and a major piece of setup, which I will leave for readers to see for themselves. The other one is major, and it represents JMS' biggest misstep on the series so far. As mentioned above, Iron Man, the leader of the pro-Registration side in the "Civil War", created a Thor clone, and here JMS drags him on stage so that Thor can beat him up. Some kind of reckoning was due for that, obviously, but, quite simply, when it comes to writing Iron Man, J. Michael Straczynski is a hack. He is incapable of treating the character, one of Marvel's oldest heroes, as anything other than a fascist punching-bag Snidely Whiplash allegory for the Bush Administration, and it drags down every single appearance the character makes in his works. He is, perhaps more than anyone, responsible for the "Iron Fascist" that many fans decry, and he shows here that he hasn't learned a thing about treating the character with respect. The confrontation, which needed to happen, is so badly written that it loses any meaning (not that that stopped many fans from cheering Thor on anyway).
Elsewhere, the story JMS chooses to tell is generally quite good, if, as said, slow. He concocts a series of amusing interactions between the Asgardians the local townspeople, while do a great job of portraying the nature of real gods, not just powerful superheroes. All this is rendered with beautiful detail by Olivier Coipel.
All in all, it is a worthy reintroduction for the Thunder God, though one hopes that, having brought Thor home, JMS will pick up the pace in future volumes, because there is so much for Thor to do.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Finally, Thor Hath Returned!, October 10, 2008
This review is from: Thor, Vol. 1 (Paperback)
The best thing about the new Thor isn't his costume redesign--it's writer J. Michael Straczynski's choice to ditch the faux-Shakespearean language that Thor used to speak. For Thor purests, I'm sure it's a travesty. But I've never been a fan of the Thunder God, and can't wait to see what other changes are in store (one of the biggest changes has to do with Loki...wait until you see what's become of him!). The smackdown with Iron Man lives up to the hype, although the ending is predictable and shows Tony Stark for the weasel he's become. The book is also humorous, more so than Straczynski's Spider-Man at least. This is a solid piece of comics writing.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Thor is back from the dead...for better or worse, May 7, 2008
It seems like an eternity ago (for me anyway) that Thor and his fellow inhabitants of Asgard met their demise in Michael Avon Oeming's excellent Thor: Disassembled arc (co-inciding with Brian Michael Bendis' disassembling of the Avengers), so seeing the classic Marvel hero make a return is something I've been anticipating. Babylon 5 creator and former Amazing Spider-Man writer J. Michael Straczynski gets the writing duties pretty much by default (the first, excellent review on this page will fill you in on the details), and he doesn't do a bad job as he begins to re-establish Thor's place in a post-Civil War universe. Thor/Donald Blake has made Oklahoma City his place of operations, as he attempts to locate his fellow Asgardians in this first storyarc of the new ongoing series. While it is a solid new beginning for Thor, not a whole lot really happens in this storyarc. In fact, some may find it kind of boring really. I appreciate what Straczynski is trying to do here, but it just feels like there was more that could have been put here, and it also feels like there are just missed opportunities aplenty. House of M artist Olivier Coipel provides some great artwork though, so this first arc isn't a total loss. All in all, J. Michael Straczynski makes a promising, albeit flawed, first impression with this Thor relaunch, and here's hoping that things will get better from this point forward.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
![[Start the discussion]](http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/x-locale/communities/discussion_boards/start-new-discussion-sec._V192250339_.gif){kind=small}
