Most Helpful Customer Reviews
34 of 36 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Amazing Collection That Sums Up The Historical Moment, June 8, 2004
This review is from: Those Who Forget the Past: The Question of Anti-Semitism (Paperback)
After the horrific shock of 9/11 and the slaughter of the reporter Daniel Pearl (to whom this book is dedicated) many in the West woke up to the fact of widespread, slavering Jew-hatred in the Arab world and hostility and prejudice in a Europe that thought it could finally shrug off the guilt of the Holocaust because of so-called "Zionist atrocities." The great reporter and historian Ron Rosenbaum wrote a newspaper column suggesting, following up on Philip Roth's fine 1993 novel "Operation Shylock" that a "second Holocaust" was possible if not probable. (That is, the annihilation of Israel by modern weapons of mass destruction.) His column stirred up quite a fuss, which in turn led to this massive, brilliant collection of essays edited by Rosenbaum. The question of renewed anti-Semitism is examined from an exhaustive array of perspectives: historical, literary, political. Rosenbaum includes his original essay along with a stunningly thorough introduction. Cynthia Ozick provides an afterword, "The Modern Hep!Hep!Hep!", which prophetically summarizes the hateful course of crimes against Jews through the centuries. Some of my other favorite contributions: David Mamet's feisty look at the "blunt trauma" of his nostalgic love of Israel. Philip Greenspun's darkly sardonic examination of the real dynamics of terrorism. Simon Schama's unflinching, revolting tour of hatred on the Internet. Laurie Zoloth's hair-raising eyewitness account of the famous anti-Semitic near riot at San Fransisco State. Todd Gitlin and Melanie Philips on how anti-Semitism has largely moved from the political right to the left. Marie Brenner's first-hand report on the growing, despicable conditions in France. Daniel Gordis' plea to the non-Israeli Jewish left to get serious and stop intellectualizing the murder of Jews. Harold Evans neatly puts things in their proper perspective. It isn't anti-Semitism to question the wisdom of specific Israeli policies. However, "it is anti-Semitism to vilify the state of Israel as a diabolical abstaction; it is anti-Semitic to invent malignant outrages; it is anti-Semitic to consistently condemn in Israel what you ignore or condone elsewhere; it is above all, anti-Semitic to dehumanize Judaism and the Jewish people so as to incite and justify their extermination." (page 47) In this trying and difficult time of war this book is a sobering reminder of what is at stake, and why we in the West fight.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A brilliant collection of articles, October 28, 2004
This review is from: Those Who Forget the Past: The Question of Anti-Semitism (Paperback)
This book deals with hatred of Israel and many of the reactions to it. It consists of about 50 separate essays. One of the inspirations for the book was Philip Roth's novel, "Operation Shylock," and the relevant excerpt from this book is included as one of the essays. That essay explains the threat of Israel becoming a sort of extermination camp for Jews, with nuclear weapons rather than Zyklon B being the relevant weapon.
The book, which begins with an excellent introduction by Ron Rosenbaum, is a superb collection of ideas and thoughts. One of the essays that impressed me the most was by Tom Gross, describing the ghastly reporting by the British media of the events in Jenin in April, 2002. Until I read this article, I just couldn't believe that the folks at the Guardian would abandon all journalistic standards just to hurt a few Jews by spouting some absurd lies about Israel. After all, no matter what they thought about Jews or Israel, these people were professionals who I thought were unlikely to wish to destroy the good reputation the Guardian had so carefully built up. Such destruction would cost them money! But this article showed me that they had indeed turned the Guardian into something far less valuable than it had been in the past (perhaps thinking that such an approach would appear more sensational and improve their sales).
I also especially enjoyed the articles by Paul Berman, Robert Wistrich, Gabriel Schoenfeld, Ruth Wisse, Melanie Phillips, Joshua Muravchik, Martin Peretz, Cynthia Ozick, Fiamma Nirenstein, and Bernard Lewis. And of course, I had to read the essay by Daniel Gordis that started "Dear Jill." No, it wasn't to me, it was to Jill Jacobs. But it was a scary look into the politics of a graduating rabbinical student.
There are articles by various opponents of Zionism, including Tariq Ramadan, Edward Said, and Judith Butler. I think it was a good idea to allow the reader to see a little of how they view the world.
I certainly recommend this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
written by the decent race, July 11, 2004
This review is from: Those Who Forget the Past: The Question of Anti-Semitism (Paperback)
It is rare, I suppose to recommend a book by noting who contributed to it, but then again it is rare to find the late Edward Said and Cynthia Ozick condemning the same thing and with equal passion. And yet they like intellectuals from all over the world have come together, in this book, to gaze with heart-breaking pain at the age-old specter of anti-Semitism. Their "solutions" are many; their ideological commitments are numerous but they have one thing in common: they refuse to look away from this hideous spectacle though looking at it causes them intense pain. It is with pain that Melanie Phillips writes, "Want to make yourself, really, really unpopular if you're a Jew? Try saying that the world is witnessing a terrifying firestorm of hatred directed at Israel and the Jewish people in which the Europeans are deeply implicated"; it is with pain that Edward Said writes that "There is now a creeping, nasty wave of anti-Semitism insinuating itself into our political thought and rhetoric...When I mentioned the Holocaust in an article I wrote here last November I received more vilification than I thought possible.." The pain these authors feel is evident; so evident that the reader will need to take breaks from this book. Frequent breaks. For the pictures it paints-from the European, American, Arab, or Israeli perspectives are not pretty ones. They are ugly as only racism can be ugly. But the authors of this book do not flinch from this ugliness; they stare it in the face. They expose it for what it is. They do not hide it behind euphemisms and double standards; they assure it that (as Harold Evans puts it) "There are things which are bad, and false, and ugly, and no amount of specious casuistry will make them good or true or beautiful." This book was written by those who dared to look, unflinching at this ugliness and, more, to write about it; to expose it. And that is what makes this book, if not enjoyable, then immensely precious and worthwhile. For it was written by the decent amongst us. I recommend it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
