From School Library Journal
PreSchool-This version of the traditional nursery rhyme has much that would recommend it for sharing at storytime. The kittens appear as large, vibrant figures on clean white backgrounds with a visual subtext featuring a pair of mice unmentioned in the song but who add humor to the tried-and-true verse. Siomades adds a last-minute twist when, once the mittens are found, Mother Cat temporarily misplaces the pies thanks to the mischievous mice. Preschoolers will love the pink, orange, and blue kitten trio and their purple mother, as well as the zesty endpapers that feature collages of brightly colored mittens. When viewing the book individually, they will also be able to spot where the missing mittens are hiding. In spite of the Tom and Jerry art style, Siomades's rendition will rate high on the kid-appeal scale.
Sue Sherif, Fairbanks North Star Borough Public Library, AK
Copyright 2000 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Sue Sherif, Fairbanks North Star Borough Public Library, AK
Copyright 2000 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Booklist
Siomades, who last time out reworked the Itsy Bitsy Spider (1999), is adept at engaging very young children with the brightness of her illustrations. Here, she delivers an effervescent, interactive retelling of the classic nursery rhyme. The illustrations have a fingerpaint quality that should have special appeal for the preschool set: the bright pastel kittens are adorably hapless; their misadventure with the mittens counterpointed by mischievous, thieving mice. Youngsters will enjoy seeing the mice abscond with the pie and like looking for the hidden pictures of mittens and pie scattered through the pictures. An excellent read-to and discover-together book that will work quite well at story-hour time. Connie Fletcher



