5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Fun and enjoyable, but not my favorite in the series, September 2, 2009
This review is from: Three Weddings and a Bar Mitzvah (86 Bloomberg Place Series #4) (Paperback)
I've really enjoyed this series and looked forward to this one coming out. The girls are back to finish up their relationships
and go on with their lives. Generally a fun read, but I had a few issues with this one, a few things that struck me personally.
1. Everyone getting saved. In Book 1, it seemed that Megan was the only Christian in the bunch. By the finale, it seems like all
four girls and their boyfriends have become godly-minded people. I mean, shouldn't we want them to all get saved? Sure. But it's
just so untrue to life that I can't buy the idea. Gil and Anna were ambivalent Catholics, Kendall plainly told Megan not to try to
"convert" her, and Edmond's kind of been a religious question mark until book 3. Now everyone is a committed Christian. A happy
ending for sure, but not believable. Christianity is too polarizing to see many outcomes like this.
I hope no one takes offense, but I really disliked the Megan-Marcus storyline. (This is a personal thing because I don't believe
in missionary dating.) In Book 1 Marcus is dating Kendall (and pressuring her for sex), in Book 4 Marcus is a missionary to Zambia?!?
Yes, of course people can change. I just didn't find it to flow naturally and believably. Marcus has always seemed a lot more into
Megan (who is a Christian) than he really is into God.
2. (MINOR SPOILER ALERT)
A minor character passes away, and a new Christian asks a mature Christian if she can pray "in reverse" that the deceased would
be able to "find" God even though she is gone now. The mature Christian decides this is "childlike faith" and does so. I found
this very disturbing theologically. Just my personal belief again.
3. Is it really in Kendall's best interest to rush into a marriage with Killiki? She knew him for what, two months?
Other than this little tidbits, I found it to be a good read. Goodbye, Bloomberg Place. (Mrs. Carlson, a spinoff might be fun!)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Questionable, September 28, 2009
This review is from: Three Weddings and a Bar Mitzvah (86 Bloomberg Place Series #4) (Paperback)
I did not know that this was the final book in a series, and I had not read the preceding titles; however, I was able to follow the plot. One of the characters has a small child and the care of the baby takes up a good deal of the storyline. The planning of weddings and showers are another major portion of the plot. The Bar Mitzvah is quickly glossed over.
The characters are somewhat believable, but I wonder at some of the dialogue. There's a sense of being in love with love. Anna dates and works with Edmond, yet days goes by without any communication and a giant misunderstanding ensues. Megan and Marcus have an odd relationship, and I found the conclusion hard to imagine. Kendall's island love is confined to a few phone calls. Lelani and Gil are the most believable couple, but with a domineering mother, neither get disturbed enough to react.
I did not like the twisted theology presented when after a death, one character wants to "pray in reverse" for the deceased. After a prayer, there is a sense of satisfaction that now the deceased is a Christian. I find this strange for a book that is labeled Christian fiction.
I'm sure that those who have read the first three books in the series will enjoy reading how it all ends.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No