20 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fascinating American Tour in Mid-1800s, April 30, 2008
This review is from: Throes of Democracy: The American Civil War Era 1829-1877 (Hardcover)
I was enthralled by this tour around America during such a critical period of development. McDougall is a respected, decorated academic historian and brings this professional authority to the pages. However, this book is fabulous for amateurs like me, interested in history but not in pursuit of a Ph.D. The myriad of social and cultural elements are what make this a fascinating study. Most history tomes focus on political aspects, as this certainly addresses. But I like reading about things that are less well-known--people, domestic habits, inventions, social things. To name a few in McDougall's book: the invention of photography, women desiring fine china starting in the 1820s, saloons in Chicago, Lincoln wondering what to do with the freed slaves, the age of steel, railroads, pioneer trails to the West, water supply, all the stuff that typical political history books miss.
While "Throes of Democracy" is 600 pages with terrific maps, it's a rapid trip, easy to read with lots of juicy stories and details. There are 144 pages of footnotes which I'm sure the academics require, and some of them are enlightening, but I didn't need them. I have read a few of the author's previous books and this is the best one yet.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Tale of Human Nature Set Free, December 5, 2008
Professor Walter McDougall of the University of Pennsylvania develops his understanding of American history as a "tale of human nature set free" throughout his lengthy study "Throes of Democracy: The American Civil War Era 1829 -- 1876" (2008). This book is the second of three volumes devoted to a history of the United States. The first volume "Freedom just around the Corner" covers the period 1585 -- 1828 while the third volume has not yet appeared. McDougall is a scholar in love with the United States but deeply conscious of its paradoxes. Further setting the tone for his history, he writes in his Preface "I believe the United States (so far) is the greatest success story in history. I believe Americans (on balance) are experts at self-deception. And I believe the 'creative corruption born ot their pretense goes far to explain their success. The upshot is that American history is chock-full of cruelty and love, hypocrisy and faith, cowardice and courage, plus no small measure of tounge in cheek humor." McDougall says he has written his history with two broad rules in mind: avoid cant (he uses a more earthy term) and and "write as if you are already dead." On the whole, he follows through. McDougall writes from a philosophical/religious perspective which I will discuss below.
The book begins and nearly ends with fire. It opens with a description of an 1835 fire in New York City which destroyed lower Manhattan. And one of the last sections of the book tells of the great Chicago fire of 1871 which gutted much of the city. In both cases, McDougall finds that the cities rose from their ashes through the energy and untrammelled efforts of individuals and community. The fires became blessings as old structures were burned away and entrepeneurs rebuilt the cities to be more powerful, energetic, and corrupt than they were before the catastrophies. The drive for power and wealth combined with civic improvement as McDougall repeats his theme that many Americans of differing perspectives tried to "do good by doing well."
The history proper begins with the presidency of Andrew Jackson, continues through the Civil War and Reconstruction, and concludes with the compromise of 1876 which resulted in the election of Rutherford B. Hayes to the presidency and ended Reconstruction. This is a great deal of widely different materials to handle in a single volume. McDougall's narrative is frequently disjointed. Especially in the first part of the history, the period before the Civil War, McDougall tends to slight the political history of the period. The reader doesn't get a convincing view of the long history of events leading to secession and conflict. What McDougall offers instead is a picture of what he describes as hustling -- a theme which he finds characterizes American life. It is a story of individuals rich and poor devoted to their own individual welfare who use their freedom in the widest possible ways in the attempt to realize their individual dreams. It is a story of con-men, entrepeneurs, writers, capitalists, farmers, circus performers, soldiers, builders. McDougall tells the story of a nation on the make. He also finds it a story lacking an overriding sense of national purpose and meaning, which he finds the great shortcoming to date of American life.
Many historians see the Civil War as the pivotal event in American history but McDougall does not. He sees a continuity in events before and after the Civil War in that the basic nature of American life, individualism and hustling remained essentially in place as what McDougall terms America's civic religion of individualism. So, he argues (mistakenly)that at the outest of his administration, Abraham Lincoln tried to follow the temporizing, compromising posture of Buchanan until events proved the hollowness of this approach. The country lacked a stable frame of reference and authority, McDougall argues, and was instead a land of competing forces in which individual goals were projected on the nation as a whole. Among American writers, McDougall severely criticizes Emerson and Thoreau, not, indeed, for being money driven, but for fostering an ethic of radical individualism that McDougall finds essentially mirrored the individualism already in place. The corruption and failure of Reconstruction was also due for McDougall to lack of national resolve. The age following Reconstruction, the Gilded Age, was corrupt and venial, but it also made America the most materially successful nation the world had ever seen.
Some of the stronger elements of this book lie in the details: in the portraits of individuals well-known and little known, and in its scenes of the pace and notoriety of urban life in New York City, Chicago and elsewhere. McDougall admires Herman Melville. I appreciated his use of quotations from Melville's still under-valued collection of Civil War poems, "Battle-Pieces" to frame his treatments of Civil War combats. McDougall punctuates his narrative with short insert histories of each state admitted to the Union during the time frame of his study beginning with Arkansas in 1836 and ending with Colorado in 1876. These inserts are written in a reflective, almost poetical style and capture something of the individuals who formed and populated each of the states. The book is generally written in a colloquial, down-to-earth, informal style. The endnotes are important to read.
The hero of McDougall's study does not appear until the concluding section of the book in the person of Orestes Brownson (1803-1876). Brownson was a seeker in the best tradition of American individual beginning as a transcendentalist and ultimately converting to Roman Catholicism. With this conversion, Brownson, for McDougall, became a profound critic of American individualism. For McDougall, Brownson showed that the spirit of individualism was chaos and selfishness writ large. From Emerson to the most agressive financier or huckster, Americans confused their own desires for power and wealth with the nature of America. McDougall advocates for what today is called communitarianism, but his approach is even broader. He argues that individualism fails and needs a source of authority outside the scope of human reason or the human person. This authority is generally thought to be religious and is described by the term Revelation. Neither Brownson nor McDougall expected or desired Americans to adopt Catholicism or any other single religion. But as the book progresses, McDougall's claim that American individualism needs to be reshaped to acknowledge a source of authority outide the self and that this authority is ordinarily and best found in religion becomes increasingly prominent. This position is put forward at length in the discussion of Brownson and in McDougall's concluding quotation from a religious skeptic, Frederick Douglass.
"I hold that the pulpit is capable of being a powerful agent in the dissemination of truth, and I hold that truth is the power of God for the salvation of the world, and I do not limit truth to mere spiritual matters, but to man in all his relations in the family, in the church, in the government, and in the world." (p. 610)
More a philosophical than a political or social history, McDougall's book has its limitations. But it offers a provocative, thoughtful view of the American experience.
Robin Friedman
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Dr. McDougall achieved his aim, April 23, 2008
This review is from: Throes of Democracy: The American Civil War Era 1829-1877 (Hardcover)
The first two reviewers of Walter McDougall's masterpiece of prose are sharply divided in their views. My take on this historical romp through the mid 1850's is that McDougall was looking to pick an argument with each and every one of his readers. There is something here for each of us to cherish and to question.
First, McDougall's biting wit and scathing comments on the people and events of the day make page-turning reading. He treats monumental and small events with the same degree of scrutiny. He has made me reconsider some of my views on the mid 19th century. I am currently gathering materials for a book on a very narrow topic of the Civil War period. I hope I can tell my story with just a smidgen of the insight that he has used to tell his.
Dr. McDougall, thanks for making me reconsider my approach to historical writing. At its best, history is challenging and fun. You make it fun. I encourage anyone who hated history in high school to read this book. You will be pleasantly surprised, and most likely will order volume 1 of the series. I can't wait until the next installment.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
