Customer Reviews

Through Fire & Water: An Overview of Mennonite History / Out of Print

5 star:		(5)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This is a very easy to read book of Mennonite History. It was designed to be used as a text book in a high school or college setting. The stories are very well told, and very well laid out. The accompanied photographs and illustrations make it even more of a comfortable read. The authors are very informed about this area of study, and it shows through their work.

The book is an easy read, informative, and comprehensive. The strongest point of the book is the beginning up through the 1800s. It is accessible and yet professionally written.

However the 20th century coverage excludes some major events. The book does not address the "plain" groups starting at the beginning of the 20th century and continuing until now, and then the fundamentalist-modernist controversies of the 1920s, the response in the 1940s-50s, the revivalism in the 1950s. These were essential turning point in Mennonite history in North America that has given the word "Mennonite" many expressions.

I'd recommend Stephen Scott's An Introduction to Old Order and Conservative Mennonite Groups as a beginnier's guide in conjunction with this book. It is also accessible, and provides details of the plain groups.

I came into contact with this book while preparing a speech for a class I was taking at James Madison University. Expecting it to be just another laborious history text, I found myself immediately surprised and couldn't put the book down!

Through Fire and Water taught me several things about the Christian faith I never knew. And the sacrifices of persons profiled in the book, were both humbling and inspiring.

No matter what your denominational influence, this is a must read for every Christian!

Though Mennonites and Old Order Amish lived in the countryside around where I grew up, I knew only about their practices and some of their beliefs. Their history was largely a mystery to me. Reading this book gave me a taste of the persecution they have suffered around the world for their commitment to peace and non-resistance. This text is remarkably well-written and even entertaining at points. Perhaps good for high school juniors and seniors, adults will also appreciate this straightforward introduction to Anabaptist history.

Having just completed "Through Fire & Water," I am left with mixed feelings. The authors tell the story of Anabaptists and Mennonites. The book seems relatively complete in that it identifies the European origins of "rebaptizers" and traces their migration across Europe, to America and Russia, and around the world. The book is filled with interesting vignettes and anecdotes that help make the story quite interesting. In fact, the entire book is composed of vignettes assembled into a narrative that becomes increasingly coherent as the book progresses. There are no long or excessively detailed stories that might cause you to lose interest.

In essence, this book appears ideally suited for a high school audience that is learning about Christian history. Those who do not spend much time reading, or have little interest in reading, should also find the book quite enjoyable. This is an easy and informative read, and the book tells an important story.

Those looking for a more substantial narrative or more thorough research might prefer to begin with other texts. The opening chapters are so broad that no coherent narrative emerges. Throughout the book, only a minimal amount of research is used to support the vignettes. The prose is also very basic and straight ahead.

That said, I do feel that "Through Fire & Water" presents a good introduction to Mennonite history. I am glad I took the time to read this text. If you are looking for an entertaining an accesible introduction to Mennonite history, then I think you too will be glad you selected this book.

I am finally getting a chance to sit down and write down my thoughts on this book from Herald Press, sent to me by the folks at Mennonite Publishing Network. It actually was one of my favorite reads on the Anabaptist Movementin quite some time. To all my fellow friends and family in an Anabaptist church, reading this book, weather you read or not, will be far from a waste of your time. Church history buffs will enjoy hearing a little more 'from the other side'.

I truly believe this book is going to become an essential book to the church, within regards to the telling of our story. Growing up in Lancaster Pennsylvania, I was well aware of the many little `informational` books that where sold at shops on the Amish side of town, explaining who the Mennonites are, who the Amish are and telling a brief overview of our history. Honestly, I believe `Through Fire and Water: An Overview of Mennonite History` has the potential of replacing all of those and becoming the standard of a much more elaborate, well rounded and insightful history of where we came from and how it is defining just where we are going.

One of the best selling books to hit MPN history, is the Naked Anabaptist. Honestly, as much as I enjoyed the read, I believe this book, Through Fire and Water, should be a mandatory read before and after one reads the Naked Anabaptist. The Naked Anabaptist explains us as a broader and more modern context, this gives us the essential look at just where our roots are.

Through Fire and Water deeply explores all branches of the Anabaptist movement, within the dark theater that is `Church History`. Starting in the beginning, carefully showing our dance outside of the Protestant Reformation, this book artfully displays our history through both facts and the telling of stories, both past and modern Anabaptists. It takes the time to explain our history, our branches and our migrations (Amish, BIC, Russian Mennonites, MB, etc) as well as tell their stories of who they where, where they came from and what circumstances shaped their existence. I especially enjoyed new insights on people like George Bluarock, where we truly get a opening glimpse at how radical he was as he marched into Catholic services, to cry hypocrisy.

It sheds new light on areas that I wasn't aware of, including Menno Simon's humor, who often signed his letters `The Cripple who Loves You`. It also gave me a more in-depth glimpse at the Russian Mennonites, which our different then my own Swiss heritage.

The book is written in almost a play format. It opens with the scene of our Christian Heritage, laying out stories and reformations of our history. It then enters and carefully explains the bad and the good of our emergence in the 16th Century of Europe, setting the stage for us as bandits on the run. From there we learn our Story of how we became Mennonite, Brethren in Christ, Amish, etc - how our migrations to Russia and America erupted. Before closing with the most rounded look at our history I have ever experienced in one book - it dives into how our history as shaped us into the missional community we are today, including our pitfalls, but celebrating our spread across the globe, to be the several million church members we are today.

As a Pastor, this is one of the books I will be most recommended when people ask me and our church plant, Who are the Mennonites?

As a Mennonite, this book gave me a much more rounded look into our history and the affects it has had on us - but also on what pieces of the Kingdom we have come to understand through our heritage.

Finally as a Christian, it is a book that tells the other side of the Church History. The side often forgotten and not told, it is part Martyr's Mirror, part Naked Anabaptist and part Confession of the Mennonite Perspective.

One of my favorite sections was titled, From Anabaptist to Mennonite, exploring how we became compromised as the quiet of the land and how we migrated onward from there. This place of being quiet is where some of us in the church, are still defaulting our lives, loosing the passion our heritage presents in living out the Lord's Prayer, on earth as it is in heaven. It was also exciting to see my 10th Great-Grandfather mentioned, Jacob Engle, the founding Pastor of the Brethren in Christ. The book is roughly 350 pages of history, that is written with the same passion, those before us, lived out in their lives. It was engaging, energetic and motivational. Many times I not only had to laugh or shake my head, but even was ushered to tears over the story of where we come from. This book made me wish time travel was possible to meet with these `common joes`, so many years before that lived extraordinary lives.

We felt this book would be a good read for someone who is converting from the Muslim faith to Christianity and is also looking for a church home in the Mennonite tradition. We have found the book to be a very valuable tool for this purpose.

This book does not just cover early Mennonite/Anabaptist roots it covers early church roots as well.

Written in a style that is easy to read and digest. It is an easy read and very informative!

Now in a revised edition, Through Fire and Water: An Overview of Mennonite History is an accessible and reader-friendly chronicle of the history of the Mennonite faith, from its roots in the radical Reformation of sixteenth-century Europe to today's worldwide Anabaptist presence. Particular emphasis is given on the evolution of the Mennonite faith in North America and in Russia. Black-and-white photographs and illustrations pepper this edifying account of a faith firmly grounded in nonviolence - despite the brutal realities that compromise survival during the turbulence of world history. An excellent addition to general-purpose religious history shelves.

I uncovered this book while searching for information about Amish and Mennonite cultures. I found it to be a very good history of the Anabaptist movement with very good information about the schisms between Anabaptists and other reformation movements. It also had valuable material relating to the divergence of Jacob Amman and the Amish from the larger Mennonite community.

What was lacking for me was information about the modern orders within the Mennonite church. How do modern Mennonite orders differ from the Amish in customs and beliefs? How do Old Order Mennonites differ from the Amish and other Mennonite sects? How many Mennonite sects are there today? How did they come to diverge? How come some Mennonites wear conservative clothing and drive cars, yet some Mennonites are indistiquishable from other "contemporary Americans"? Are there regional patterns to these divisions?

Some of these may seem like naive questions, but as a non-Mennonite trying to learn about the culture, I found myself wanting more of this information.

Overall, however, the book is a great history. The illustrations are over-caricatured and overdone, and the silly drawing on the pink book jacket is not going to help sell any copies -- but these are minor complaints.