Most Helpful Customer Reviews
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Genre Confusion, July 27, 2000
"Did you like *Throwing Smoke*?" I asked my ten year old son. "Yeah," he said. "Were the characters convincing?" I asked. "Yeah," he said. "What about the dialogue?" I asked. "It was great. But there was too much baseball. Or something." The baseball, of course, was why I bought the book, and it seemed an odd statement coming from a child who wouldn't put down Will Weaver's baseball trilogy even to eat. Then I read the book. The dialogue *is* funny; the book, well written, but the author places *Throwing Smoke* in a limbo of genre. When Whiz starts printing up baseball cards for fictional team players who mysteriously come to life, the book (*strongly* rooted in baseball and baseball terminology) turns towards the gothic. These players, all ace at what they do, are zombie like. Where do they go at night? What do they secretly talk about together? Why does nothing more interesting happen with them? Where the heck is this plot going? *Thowing Smoke* raises more questions about its tepid supernatural effects than the baseball frame of the story can contain. I will avoid details, but when a story enters the world of the supernatural, rules must be followed, expectations must be met. In *Throwing Smoke*, they aren't. As for the baseball team-comraderie part of the book, well, that's not very compelling either -- the supernatural material is too distracting. *Throwing Smoke*, much as I wanted to like it, pulls in two direction and can't come up with a reconciliation between the two. The book needs a fast ball, but it just can't deliver.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Book Review:Throwing Smoke, March 6, 2006
A Kid's Review
Do you like books that are exciting and have to do a lot with sports? If so then the realistic fiction book,Throwing Smoke, by Bruce Brooks is a great read for you. Throwing Smoke is about young boys and girls on the Bredhurst Newts baseball team. The baseball team hasn't won a game in five years but they think they have a chance this coming up baseball season because everyone has been practicing super hard and they got a new pitcher from out of state and yes, he throws smoke. If you want to find out if the Bredhurst Newts will win their first game in five years I suggest you read this awesome, heart pumping, tear dropping, mind racing, extraordinary book by Bruce Brooks, it will be the best book you've ever read, trust me.
Vincent Cary (aka) Whiz is the primary, dynamic, and the antagonist character in the story. Whiz has many traits which include, he's very athletic, kind, caring, responsible, honest, respectful, dedicated, quiet, superb, captain and pitcher of his baseball team. Whiz is a good pitcher but he's let his team down and lead them to a lot of loses. The Bredhusrt Newts haven't won a game in five years. Whiz pitches are accurate but very slow. The hitters always crush the ball when they are up to bat. Whiz still pitches cause the Bredhurst Newts play for fun, they don't care if they lose. It's about team work.Things twist around in the story when Ace Jones transferred from out of state to the small town of Bredhusrt. Ace Jones has been playing baseball for along time and he also pitches. He throws smoke, i mean you can't even see his pitches there so fast. Some of the players on the Bredhust Newts see Ace practicing his pitches and ask him to pitch for the team. Whiz gets super jealous but thinks he will lead the team to there first win. Ace Jones has many traits which include, he's very athletic, smart, kind, caring, respectful, responsible, and dedicated. He puts his heart into baseball, and is the secondary character, static character, and the protagonist of the story. Will Whiz let Ace pitch? If Ace does pitch will the Bredhurst Newts win their first game? If you want to find out I suggest you read this amazing book.
Throwing Smoke by Bruce Brooks is a great fantasy book that every child should get a chance to read. On a scale from one to ten I would rate this book an eight. I really enjoyed how the theme was baseball because I play baseball and i have experience. I also enjoyed how I have a lot of connections with the characters in the story, for example me and Delancy Brunet both play 2nd base. If you are a reader that is interested in baseball and interested in action filled books I suggest you read this awesome book by Bruce Brooks. It's an awesome book for all ages.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
Great book for good readers, October 2, 2006
A Kid's Review
I liked this book but it made no sense to me at times. I had to read sentences over and over to understand what was going on .The book was really good when I understood what was going on and the book was funny most of the time and always fast paced "that's why I kept reading". I thought the author used great detail and grammer. I thought I wouldn't like the book but I was wrong. I recommend this book for ages 9-15
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|