1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Miscellany of P-47 Aces!, June 27, 2008
This review is from: P-47 Thunderbolt Aces of the Ninth and Fifteenth Air Forces (Osprey Aircraft of the Aces No 30) (Paperback)
To complete their coverage of P-47 aces, Osprey combined the Jug aces from the ETO-based 9th AF, a tactical organization, with those assigned to the 325th FG, the lone Thunderbolt group in the strategic 15th Air Force in the Med. It's a literary marriage of convenience...but it works. While the aerial exploits of the 'Checkertail Clan' are fairly well known, those of the 9th AF aren't, so Jerry Scutts' book, #30 in the 'Aircraft of the Aces' series, is a useful visit with old friends and new acquitances.
Though 9th AF Thunderbolts' main duty was fighter-bombers ops, almost two dozen 9th AF pilots made ace in the Republic fighter. Air combat between the Luftwaffe and 9th AF Jugs was fairly rare, resulting in many 9th AF groups having only one ace or none. High-scoring aces included Ed Fisher (362nd FG), Bob Coffey (365th FG), Bob Johnston (50th FG), Ed Edwards (373rd FG) and John Wainwright (404th FG); none of whom had totals in the double digits. By contrast the top 325th FG ace - 'Herky' Green - scored 10 kills while flying Thunderbolts.
If half votes were allowed, I would have given P-47 THUNDERBOLT ACES OF THE NINTH AND FIFTEENTH AIR FORCES 4 1/2 stars. While Scutts does a fair job on the 9th AF aces, he spends too much time describing the 9th's fighter-bomber exploits. I would have preferred more combat reports, etc. dealing with the air-to-air trade. Likewise he didn't include an index!
On the plus side, Scutts is a fine author and the narrative flows easily, especially the shifts back and forth between covereage of 9th AF units and the 325th sections. There's 90 photographs of pilots and aircraft along with 10 pages of nifty color side-views by Chris Davey. Ninth Jugs had some spectacular nose art as borne out by Davey's profiles of 'Wee Speck,' 'Five by Five' and 'Live Bait!'
Air combat and especially Jug fans should latch on to Scutts' book. It's an enjoyable, informative guide to some famous and not-so-well-known aces who flew that monster of a fighter. Recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No