3.0 out of 5 stars
Do we really understand time at all?, February 6, 2011
Engaging and somewhat philosophical text pulls the reader into the narrative early. Art and text are divorced. Had the topic been related to poetry this disconnect might have worked, but the topic of time is inherently technical. The text and art should work together to tell a story much larger than either art or text is capable of articulating on its own.
Time is a concept that is measured not only by humans. "...it seems that most, perhaps all, other living things have ways of measuring time." There are several interesting experimental results from the natural world which illustrate animals and plants measure time and react to their world based on their perception of time.
In many parts of the world, great effort was invested in developing calendars. The author asserts that the close link between calendars and religion was intended so that humans could gain power to influence their destinies and their Gods. I struggled with the author's explanation for the origin of a Sabbath day and disagree with the School Library Journal review that the author does a good job of linking calendars and religion. Chapter six states that the superstitions of the ancient Assyrians with regard to the phases of the moon is the reason why a majority of religions in the world today set aside one day a week for worship. While many aspects of time and calendars can be quantified using the scientific method, the meaning of time in the lives of people is difficult at best to convey to a reader in late elementary or early middle school (3rd grade to 7th grade). The author attempts to convey the cultural significance of time using a timeline that, while defensible from the standpoint of popular scholarship, rings hollow from the standpoint of collective human experience. The reader has been warned that this book waxes philosophical at times, and on the subject of calendars and religion the author is floundering in deep water.
The text provides engaging details about the difficulties of merging a lunar and solar calendar--but absent clear illustrations a reader without prior exposure to science and astronomy will be spinning in a sea of equinoxes, ellipses, and phases of the moon.
Measurement of hours and minutes is discussed in a manner well suited to the audience--but without the support of clear detailed illustrations, the first time reader will come away feeling unenlightened.
John Harrison is given credit for his work at making an accurate sea clock--clearly the author has done his homework. It would have been great if the book included a bibliography to allow curious students to follow-up on the several tantalizing threads that could only be touched upon in the main chapters, for instance the story of longitude.
Coordinated universal time, the role of railroads, atomic clocks and relativity get appropriate credit and detail in this fascinating story of the development of time in the modern world.
At the end of Chapter Nine the author asks "despite all this, do we really understand time at all?" Not just the lead-in to the chapter on relativity, it is also a good point to review the value this book brings to the discussion of time and our further understanding.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No