Most Helpful Customer Reviews
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Gritty Gut-Wrenching Fiction, June 18, 1998
By A Customer
You almost have to have been A U.S. Navy Sailor to appreciate this book fully. Those who have "gone down to the sea in ships" through the years will understand what I mean. This book combines all the elements of good fiction (in my humble opinion). Good characters, most niether good noe evil, but human: war, love, honor, deciet, and friendship. My favorite aspect of this book is the air of mysticism applied to the sea nad the ship, you either have been to sea and understand it or you haven't and probably don't. The characters are very good, it is obvious that Mr. Fleming read Herman Wouk, the parallels between Arthur McKay and "Pug" Henry cannot be missed, but I believe this is a plus and as a long time member of the Pug Henry fan club I cannot fault him for it. If you are or have ever been on a Navy Combat vessel at sea READ THIS BOOK. If you haven't, read it anyway, and perhaps you will see what it is about this duty that forever changes those of us who have.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
What a page turner..., March 6, 2002
I read this book a while back. I just saw it in the library today. I remember it so well that I felt compelled to right a review. Anyone that is familiar with WW II and the naval campaigns will want to read this book. This is the story of a light cruiser with a new captain. The previous captain (if I remember correctly) was court martialed for cowardice. He was a close friend of the new captain. That's the first sub plot in this book. There are other plots that that happen throughout the book. The book is so well written and the character so well developed that I can still remember the pleasure of reading it. There were good guys and bad guys, creeps and regular Joes. The ship is like a small town. Oh, I left out the battle sequences. Wow! Incredible. Even the aftermath and cleanup after the battles was well handled. The cruiser limping back to port for a refit and overhaul. The ending is a little sad. But, after you read the book, you will understand why it had to be so. If you at all enjoy WW II naval action, this is a must read book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Jeff City--- Light Cruiser /Heavy Cruiser ??, January 8, 2011
A couple of reviewers at least, have referred to the Jeff City as a "light cruiser",(maybe such as Boise-class) but I think that it is actually probably intended to be an 9X 8inch gun "Treaty Cruiser"...each ship that i can think of that the Jeff moves into the shoes of, was a 10000 ton Portland/Indianappolis class cruiser? the following might be regarded as a <<<<<< Spoiler >>>>>> ------------ It begins playing the part of the USS Chicago from Savo Island..(an 8in treaty cruiser)...becomes USS Salt Lake City at battle of Bering Sea(I think another treaty heavy cruiser) becomes admiral Spruances flagship in later years of Pacific War ---USS Portland .. finally it steps into the ill-fated clothes of the --USS Indianappolis-- and shares its fate.. to play those 'roles" it needs each time to be a Quincy/Vincennes/Astoria/Houston style 8in cruiser, im pretty sure. Someone compares McKay to Hermann Wouks Pug Henry ...perhaps so, it is incidental that in "War and Remembrance", Henry is in command of the USS Northampton..another actual "treaty cruiser" sunk in the Solomons Campaign
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|