From School Library Journal
Grade 6-8–Why would Charlemagne (742-814) and Catherine the Great of Russia (1729-1796) qualify for a series on Ancient Civilizations? These misplaced biographies include abbreviated family trees (with no dates) and one inadequate map. Both titles suffer from awkward, choppy writing; unexplained references and unanswered questions; and major omissions (Gibson refers to Potemkin only as Catherine's adviser, not her lover; Whiting doesn't include much on Charlemagne's contributions to law or his private life). In addition,
Charlemagne includes a picture of Muhammad, which is unacceptable to Muslims.
Catherine has far more flaws, among them fictionalizing in the first chapter; an incomplete and inconsistent index, with some individuals listed under first name and some under surname; and a genealogical error, claiming that Catherine and her husband Peter were first cousins (they were second cousins).
–Ann W. Moore, Schenectady County Public Library, NY Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
About the Author
Karen Bush Gibson has been a freelance writer for more than 16 years. She has had many articles published in such publications as Boys Life, Backpacker and Army Times. She also teaches writing. With a special gift for telling a story, Ms. Gibson is the author of more than 20 educational books for children. She lives in Oklahoma with her husband and three sons.