(Updated September 30, 2011: I am still using the mower as my main mower and I still concur with everything I say below. Recently I discovered my Dremel gives a MUCH sharper blade than sharpening by hand with a file. After sharpening with the Dremel, the mower was able to go through damp 8" tall grass without the motor bogging down to a stall. Whatever electric mower you may get, I HIGHLY recommend you machine sharpen the blade every few cuts.)
(Updated April 26 and May 14, 2011: In the review below I added a slower RPM for the Toro, and a harder ability to clean the bottom of the deck. In the title I lowered the ideal price from $300 to $250.)
(Updated June 9, 2011: I hate the steel deck due to the sticking clumps of grass. I mow my lawn around sunset so the grass is not wet when I mow. The plastic deck (underside) of my CMM1200 wins over steel hands down because grass never sticks to the plastic. I also updated the battery run time below which is still good and the quietness which is good.)
INITIAL NOTES: *** Do not buy this mower if you routinely bag grass! The standard blade is horizontally flat and does not tip upward to give enough updraft. The result is a clogged chute when the bag is only one-fifth full (see more below). ***
*** With all battery mowers, always sharpen your blade (like a knife) which helps the motor to maintain RPMs, gives a cleaner cut to the grass, and helps the battery last longer. Sharpening takes just a minute with a simple 5"-7" file. No need to remove the blade even. I HIGHLY recommend machine sharpening the blade. ***
I have used a Black and Decker CMM1200 for the past three seasons on a 1/2 acre lot which is mostly grass. The CMM1200 is ok but I wanted to upgrade to a better mower. The e-Cycler is slightly better in some ways but is lacking overall. I would have given three stars, but lowered to two stars, because this mower should be better coming out four years after the debut of the CMM1200. Also, a $400 price is not justified for its limited features.
Despite the two stars, I have been using this mower as my main mower so far this season (basically to get my money's worth). I hope next season I can find a good battery mower that has the qualities I mention in my wish list at end of this review.
---------------
After Mowing More Than Forty Times Here's What I Like About The E-Cycler:
** The height adjustment is good ** I can mow from 1" to 4 1/2" (1" higher than the CMM1200). I routinely cut at 3" so it's nice to be able to raise the mower in case I miss mowing due to extended rains, being on vacation, etc. There is no single lever adjustment like other mowers but I don't adjust the height often so it's ok for me. compared to the CMM1200, the e-Cycler has an extra inch of height and goes 1/2 inch lower. The single lever height adjustment on the CMM1200 is a nice convenience though.)
** The blade width is good ** It is 19 3/4" wide. (an inch more than the CMM1200)
** The battery capacity is good ** I can mow my entire back yard (14,000 sq. ft) with 5" sparse grass, though the mower goes a bit slower after 10,000 sq. ft. I always split the front (3500 sq. ft.) and back yard into two different days so this is fine with me. (battery capacity is the same as the CMM1200.)
** The quietness is good ** Like other battery mowers, this mower is about half as loud as gas mowers. slightly more quiet than the CMM1200)
---------------
Here's What I Don't Like About The E-Cycler (Comparison To the CMM1200 In Parenthesis):
** Overall mowing ability isn't good ** It is underpowered and heavy (as a typical battery mower), leaves several grass blades uncut here and there, and doesn't completely mulch some grass clippings to small pieces. The motor strains and slows a bit when trying to mulch 2" of cut grass. The motor is fairly weak and should be TWICE as strong (even at the expense of battery life). 36V means nothing for power and only allows reduced operating amps to help battery life overall this is about the same mowing experience as the CMM1200 but I wanted to upgrade to have better mowing experience, not the same)
** Bags grass poorly ** This is a terrible design flaw but I rarely bag grass. When first starting the mower I noticed the empty bag did not puff up with air. After mowing for one pass I noticed the mower was spitting grass from underneath which usually means the chute is clogged. Sure enough the chute was clogged but there was only about 2" of clippings in the bag. I emptied the bag and tried another pass but the same result. I can see part of the problem is with the blade design - it's flat and doesn't curve up like a fan blade. I ordered a new blade from Amazon which looked like it has an upward angle to increase airflow but it did not... it was a standard replacement. Another problem is the chute opening is short and wide and meets the bottom part of the bag. Instead, the chute should be taller, more narrow and higher up relative to the bag so it can keep throwing grass as the bag fills up. Poor bagging is simply unacceptable and makes Toro appear inept. As a long-time mower manufacturer they should have done better. It is a shame and an embarrassment for this American company to release a mower with such a design flaw. I expect things to work reasonably well out of the box. the CMM1200 in the same area picked up about 3X as much grass before the chute became clogged - the bag was only about 1/2 full which is typical for this mower. The CMM1200 does a better job bagging because it has a taller opening for the chute and a sharp up-curve of the blade for stronger airflow.)
** Leaves strong wheel tracks in the grass ** slightly worse than the CMM1200, even though both have 2" wide tires)
** It feels heavier and harder to push than the CMM1200 (but really is about the same weight) ** It is only 4 lbs heavier than the CMM1200 (78 vs 74 lbs. - I weighed them individually with me on a bathroom scale. Perhaps it's the higher angle of the handle on the Toro making it seem harder to push.)
** The steel frame/deck ** I don't know about the longevity of a steel frame but it is much harder to clean/rinse and has a tendency to twist and bend. Even fairly dry grass loves to clump to the steel (or paint) on the underside. for the CMM1200 I didn't mind the plastic frame which was rather sturdy and I never had to clean grass underneath it with a hose. Grass tends to avoid sticking to the plastic underside and I could just use my blower to move away the bit that did stick underneath).
** The motor & battery cover is not user-removable which is absolutely ridiculous ** The four hex screws of the cover have an unusually narrow space around them so they require a special tool (normal sockets will not fit). This is just plain dumb and short-sighted. I cannot replace the battery myself and do simple maintenance unless Toro provides a tool to remove the screws. the CMM1200 cover could be removed with a screw driver which was great. An electric mower is extremely simply under the hood: Battery, motor and wires. Nothing to be scared of.)
** The charger gives a green light when not plugged into the mower which is silly ** Because of this, I can't tell if the battery is fully charged or if the charger is slightly unplugged from the mower. the CMM1200 charger is better because the light goes out if unplugged from the mower (while still plugged into the outlet) and is green or red depending on the charging status when plugged in to the mower)
** The key is in an awkward location near the motor and cannot be tied to the mower handle easily ** The key can be left in when charging which is a silly safety hazard (the CMM1200 key has to be removed when charging - a good thing - and came with a string to easily attach the key to the handle so the key won't be lost)
** The mulching cover is difficult to lift up, does not close completely, and does not sit flush with the underside of the deck ** When mulching, three handfuls of grass accumulates in a void that the mulching cover creates with the deck. Every time the mower is jostled when I reach the sidewalk or driveway a bit of that mulched grass spits out. That's annoying because there's more grass to clean up from the walkways. The spring for the cover is a bit strong so lifting up the cover when bagging is hard. Because of the way the bag latches onto the frame, I cannot tip the bag out slightly to see if the grass chute is clogged. this is worse than the CMM1200 which had a relatively seamless mulching plug that somewhat conformed with the underside of the deck. The CMM1200 back cover could be lifted slightly and the bag tipped back slightly to see if the grass chute is clogged or beginning to clog which was useful. The CMM1200 didn't spit out as much grass when reaching the sidewalk.
** The overall shape of the housing is a bit weird ** (CMM1200 has a similar odd look as well)
---------------
Wish List And Desired Improvements For The E-Cycler:
A stronger engine and/or a "boost" switch that would run the mower at more power for a shorter period of time. That way I could walk faster with the mower and save time. Instead of one battery, I would like two removable lithium batteries, so the mower could be a little lighter. Switching batteries is easy enough for my blower and trimmer, so the same can be done for a mower as well.
A faster RPM and more updraft. It seems some grass leaves are uncut because the RPM is too low. Bagging would improve with more RPM and a better updraft.
Read more ›