From School Library Journal
PreSchool-Grade 3?In this beautiful picture book, four everyday activities are depicted?making tortillas, gathering flowers, washing clothes, and singing a lullaby?as they are repeated by the women of a family over the last four generations. A little girl relates the simple text as her great-grandmother is shown making tortillas for her grandmother over an outdoor fire, her grandmother makes them for her mother in a farm kitchen with a cast-iron stove, her mother is shown cooking for her in a modern kitchen, and the child prepares paper tortillas for her doll on a toy stove. Each activity shares the refrain: "Every time it was the same, but different." The timeless quality of maternal love is evident throughout. Six Costa Rican women worked together to produce the striking acrylic folk-art paintings. With deeply saturated, glowing tones and a decidedly Central American style, the pictures enhance and extend the lyrical narrative, which is printed in English and in Spanish. The words and music of a traditional Spanish lullaby are appended. A lovely, nostalgic glimpse at Central American family life.?Denise E. Agosto, formerly at Midland County Public Library, TX
Copyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Ages 3^-7. Three generations of women (and a doll) give and receive tortillas, dresses, flowers, and lullabies. "My great-grandmother made tortillas for my grandmother; my grandmother made tortillas for my mother; my mother made tortillas for me; and I made tortillas for my doll." Each chapter ends with the phrase "Every time it was the same, but different." The words appear in English at the top of each page and in Spanish at the bottom. This gently celebrates the small daily gifts that mothers and daughters exchange, and by making the girl in each picture about the same age, Reiser shows how traditions continue generation after generation. The illustrations, attributed to Corazones Valientes in the book's imprint, were actually done collaboratively by six women who live in Costa Rica. They are painted in a folk art style, in rich colors glowing with intensity. Pair this with Betsy Hearne's
Seven Brave Women.
Susan Dove Lempke