Most Helpful Customer Reviews
19 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
No perfect in any shape or form, but still good for what it says it does..., August 26, 2006
This review is from: Toshiba Qosmio G35-AV650 17" Laptop (Intel Core Duo Processor T2500, 1 GB RAM, 200 GB Hard Drive, DVD SuperMulti Drive) (Personal Computers)
I had a lot of mixed reactions about this laptop. Most of the features were like... "oh it has this" shortly followed by "but wait, why?" You'll understand what I mean later on. PROCESSOR: This laptop came out at a very bad time. Granted the Core Duo with 2.0GHz is a step up from the AV600 and has much better clock speeds, it could have still been upgraded to the 2.16GHz. Also, with the Core 2 Duo processor line coming out in the very near future, it's a wonder why Toshiba didn't wait. With a premium laptop, the latest and greatest is always welcomed. MEMORY: Not bad. This laptop has two 100GB hard drives, allowing for 200GB of storage at a steadily quiet 5400rpm. The RAM however is very disappointing. Toshiba actually doesn't let you upgrade before you buy. What they do do is stick you with dual channel 512 sticks making 1GB total. Now, 1GB is pretty good for a casual laptop, but this is a PREMIUM laptop. 2GB would have been nice here. This laptop can actually be upgrades to 4GB, but I don't know how well it would run that, or if it would recognize all of it. DESIGN: Pretty nice. TV tuner built-in, nice media reader. Card reader. Everything else is pretty standard. The media controls are pretty nice, and I like the added security and the shortcuts on the trackpad. Keys are nice size, and the screen is really nice and bright at 1920 x 1200 maximum resolution running at a possible 1080p (only 1080i externally though). The black is very sleek and the build is pretty decent. The AV650 is heavier than Sony's AR190, so that's also kinda disappointing. PERFORMANCE: As I mentioned before the processor is a 2.0GHz processor... but besides that being slightly disappointing, so is the graphics card. Very similar to the AR190, this device also has an nVidida 7600 GT. Now if you compare this device to the AV600, it's a step up from the 7300, than it sounds like a good jump. But when you compare it to Toshiba's P105, which is almost a grand cheaper, and has a 7900 GS, you have to questions Toshiba's motives. This is far from a gaming machine, but it is still a pretty powerful machine. I also have some major gripes with the HD DVD features. For one, it's only readable. Unlike the AR190, you cannot directly burn onto the large capacity discs. Also, there are some hiccups in the viewing. And the software that runs some of its other features are pretty bad. BATTERY: Not bad. A big improvement over the AR190. I got about 165 minutes from one charge on very demanding setting. On normal usage, I got 181 minutes, so I was happy about that. It does tend to get pretty warm, so I wouldn't recommend keeping this on your lap, because it gets hot, and it's heavy, so it's best to leave this on a desk. BOTTOM LINE: It really is too early in the next generation gap to be dropping over $3,000 for high end media input computers, so I still say wait it out. I have already see price drops from various vendors on the AR190, and I will suspect he same will also happen with the AV650. This machine has a lot going for it, but I still say to just get something to hold you over. There are 19" SLI laptops out there for just a little more, so if you really want the ultimate computer, that's the way to go. I recommend the AR190 over this, and you can view that review that I wrote.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Kosmik Qosmio Experiences, August 31, 2006
This review is from: Toshiba Qosmio G35-AV650 17" Laptop (Intel Core Duo Processor T2500, 1 GB RAM, 200 GB Hard Drive, DVD SuperMulti Drive) (Personal Computers)
The Qosmio is very well constructed, sturdy, heavy, very heavy, but should stand up well to constant use as a desktop replacement. Weak points: 1. Truly inadequate customer support. Even when you push through to Level 3 (Toshiba employees in Irvine, CA), they are not even able to tell you what error messages generated by Toshiba software mean. "We'll have to ask Japan, and who knows if they will even reply". Other users report that on occasion, the Level 3 people will be able to solve problems, but this wasn't my experience. Level 1 and 2 are non-native-English-speaking outsource companies in Asia. American users apparently cannot use the worldwide Toshiba support forums, which is bizarre. 2. Truly terrible documentation (goes with 1). The product is essentially unsupported; you're on your own. Definitely not suitable for naive users. 3. High-gloss screen is a total pain. It is very hard to use in a normally-lit room. You have to adjust the screen very carefully to avoid reflections. The anti-reflection screens on other Toshiba units are vastly more practical (I own several of them). 4. HDDVD drive. This is still a work in progress. It sort of works, but requires updating drivers and applications. Check out the AVS Forum thread on the Qosmio for the latest instructions. 5. 1 GB of RAM shipped is marginal for power users. Strong points: 1. Once you get the dual hard drives configured as RAID 0 (Striping), the machine is extemely quick. Good luck figuring out how to do it. The manual is useless, so is tech support. 2. The machine really can make use 2 GB of RAM. I'm running SQL Server, IIS, etc., which together eat up about 1.3 GB 3. Plenty of USB connectors 4. Good connectivity with 1 GB Ethernet and HDMI AV output. 5. Quiet, even then running at high CPU usage. 6. Decent sound quality for a laptop, with large, top-mounted volume control 7. Much better build quality than functionally-similar Dell units (which seem a bit weak mechanically, sort of cheap plastic appearance). Who should buy this machine: 1. Not your elderly parents. 2. True desktop replacement, more or less portable. 3. Check for discounts or rebates. Overall: A rating of 4.0 is a bit generous; more like 3.5. I considered sending the machine back on more than one occasion. Lots of raw power, lots of frustrations getting the !@#$@#$ thing running properly. The review below reflects many of my feelings as well.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
My most enjoyable "Notebook" yet, January 11, 2007
This review is from: Toshiba Qosmio G35-AV650 17" Laptop (Intel Core Duo Processor T2500, 1 GB RAM, 200 GB Hard Drive, DVD SuperMulti Drive) (Personal Computers)
I purchased this "PC replacement" for work, since the 1 year older Sony laptop I had would barely run under Vista, and I was a Vista Beta tester. This Toshiba is fantastic! "Oblivion" runs effortless at all advanced settings (as a benchmark). There are only two minor glitches, depending on the use to which you intend to put the system. First, it is big! It really is a PC replacement. Calling it a notebook really isn't descriptive of its actual size. The screen is big, as well as fantastic! It's really spoiled me, relative to liquid crystal screens. Although it is portable, given a large enough pack, and while the computer itself is not that heavy, the adapter is. It will only run for a couple of hours without the adapter. The second glitch is that while there is a HD DVD drive, and while it does work, the software HD WinDVD player could not play "V for Vendetta." However, this is a software problem, not a hardware problem: the visual display was garbled.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|