2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Photos of stiffly-posed models instead of experienced Tai Chi practitioners, August 12, 2009
The models attempting to "demonstrate" the Tai Chi postures in Ronnie Robinson's book are clearly *posed*. Cartoon thought-bubbles saying, "Er...is this right?", or "Geez, how *long* did you say I have to hold this pose?" are missing, but there's a feeling that the author has only just darted out of the scene after having positioned his models.
This trivializes Tai Chi.
Instead of employees from a modeling agency in externally-imposed postures, author Robinson would have done better to have used longtime Tai Chi practitioners in his photos, the way B.K.S. Iyengar used photos of himself in the yoga poses described in Iyengar's _Light on Yoga_. In contrast to Robinson's artificially-positioned models, Iyengar's focus, visible in _Light on Yoga's_ photographs, is clearly *habitual* and *internal*. A longtime practitioner of yoga, Iyengar's physique, posture, and very being have been modified through continual practice of the mental and physical discipline of yoga. In assuming the postures, Iyengar *embodies* yoga.
Contrastingly, Ronnie Robinson's models look so self-conscious that it distracts from the book's rather cliche text. They seem more conscious of the camera than of their root.
In his book, _The Essence and Applications of Taijiquan_, Yang Chengfu (1883-1936), the best-known Tai Chi teacher, emphasized the importance of "stand(ing) in stillness", the position assumed prior to beginning the Tai Chi form, saying, "People all too easily neglect this posture, and really do not know the method of its practice or its application. It is all right here." He explained the primary benefits of this pose which, to the casual observer, looks simply like standing, arms at one's sides!
Tai Chi looks deceptively simple. Its subtleties cannot be overstated. It is an art form best conveyed via long-term, regular, one-on-one study with an experienced instructor. Barring that, we readers deserve, at the very least, photographs depicting such experienced instructors in the postures--photographs capturing each posture's subtleties.
There are several Tai Chi books available that will very likely do a better job, and which I hope to investigate. If I find a really good one, I'll post a reference here.
UPDATE: I like Jesse Tsao's _Compact Tai Chi_ (2000 paperback, ISBN 1-57863-126-2). It has a lot of genuinely helpful tips.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Recommended to beginners (like me), December 24, 2010
This book has worked very well for me. I recommend it to beginners interested in learning basic chi kung exercises and tai chi forms on their own.
The instructions, foot diagrams, and pictures have been very helpful; though I'm not particularly graceful, I have been able to do the execises and postures. Some of the work has been challenging (so please be kind to yourself if you do it), but overall, learning tai chi with this book has been fun.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No