10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Too Good to be True (but so what?!), September 14, 2006
This review is from: Totally Joe (Hardcover)
In Totally Joe, we are presented with the main character Joe (sometimes JoDan) Bunch's alphabiography--the story of his life from A to Z, complete with chapters that end with a Life Lesson to share with others. I must say, I like the idea of this writing assignment--it's simple enough, and structured and methodical in ways that satisfyingly feed my anal retentiveness. It brings an order to the book, alphabetical, sometime chronological, and always moving along.
At the heart of this alphabiography assignment is the task to be self-reflexive. (Now what self-respecting feminist isn't into being self-reflexive?) However, despite Totally Joe being presented as a confidential, journal-type text strictly between Joe and his teacher, Mr. Daly, we know as readers that we are to match Joe's self-reflexivity with our own. (Isn't all reading about this?)
In any case, I thoroughly enjoyed the book, and have been quite disappointed to see reviews from School Library Journal and Booklist that critique it for its idealism and treats its optimism as a liability instead of an asset.
What ever happened to hope? to dreams? (Or, for to letting fiction be fiction?)
I believe in the power of imagination to bring about change. Utopia should not be a dirty six letter word.
Is everything in Totally Joe completely believable? Hardly. But if it were, wouldn't that be something?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
I love Joe Bunch!, April 26, 2006
This review is from: Totally Joe (Hardcover)
Totally Joe by James Howe follows the life of the 12-going-on-13 year old narrator Joe Bunch, and the situations within his life in the form of an alphabiography assigned by his English teacher Mr. Daly. Each chapter begins with and is structured around a letter, and each ends with a "life lesson" that Joe has learned along the way. However the book is remarkable not just for its unique and creative format, but for breaking new ground with Joe as a 12 year old gay kid. Joe is not a character questioning his sexuality; he firmly knows he is gay. However he has to navigate this, along with issues of gender, sexism, masculinity, femininity, double standards, and oppression in his middle school setting. Howe manages to deal with complex issues normally reserved for older YA or adult literature such as same-sex dating (in particular, dating someone who is closeted), GSAs, and coming out to family at this young age without ever loosing cultural authenticity. The book offers numerous insights on teenage popularity and the cutthroat war zone mentality that accompanies it, and is written in extremely contemporary language that makes the protagonist (Joe) believable and real.
The book is extremely diverse, and includes various individuals that challenge social norms, like Addie's vegetarian parents or Brian's widowed father or Skeezie's single mother. It also shows individuals like Aunt Pam who is implied to be a victim of some form of domestic abuse. The book doesn't wrap itself up in preachy diatribes on these topics, but instead weaves these elements into the average daily life of Joe Bunch.
Some critics have said that Joe's liberal family is too much of a fantasy, and to some extent that may be true. It would be rare to find a family where the grandfather is so accepting that he gives a 13 year old a little pride bumper sticker, however it is not impossible for families like this to exist now, or to inspire the straight kids that read this book to make their families that accepting in the future.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
23 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Richie's Picks: TOTALLY JOE, October 1, 2005
This review is from: Totally Joe (Hardcover)
"Sometimes we live no particular way but our own."
--Robert Hunter/Jerry Garcia, "Eyes of the World"
Joe Bunch, The Early Years:
"My mom says that I played wedding for about a year and that I kept asking everybody if they would marry me. Even Jeff. (That was the only time anyone can remember Jeff threatening to clobber me on a regular basis.) I had my Lainy doll marry my Ken doll. I also had her marry some of my Barbies. And G.I. Joe. (I hated that the soldier doll had my name. I mean, please. I didn't play with him much. He was another Christmas present from my clueless grandparents. One time when they were visiting, my grandpa asked me if G.I. Joe had been in any wars lately. I said, 'No, but he and Ken got married last week.' Every Christmas since then, my grandparents have sent me a check.)"
"A dangerous book!" (I can just hear it being thundered from certain pulpits and radio talk shows.) "Boy dolls marrying boy dolls! Obscene! Pornographic!"
As some of you already know, Alabama state representative Gerald Allen, who is reported to have had at least five meetings with President Bush, introduced state legislation earlier this year that would ban public funding for any books with gay characters or content to protect children from "the homosexual agenda."
(No child left behind unless they're gay, right?)
For those books already in the state's public and university libraries, Allen suggests that people "dig a big hole and dump them in and bury them."
"But ain't that America, for you and me."
--John Mellencamp, "Pink Houses"
You may also have a tough time locating a copy of TOTALLY JOE in Oklahoma. According to an American Library Association press release issued earlier today:
"The Oklahoma House passed 81-3 a nonbinding resolution May 9 asking public libraries 'to confine homosexually themed books and other age-inappropriate material to areas exclusively for adult access and distribution.' The resolution explains that because 'children need guidance and protection by adults to ensure their maturation is timely' parents should be 'free from interference from the distribution of inappropriate publicly cataloged materials.'
"HR 1039 was introduced by Rep. Sally Kern (R-Oklahoma City), who released a statement after the resolution?s passage that affirmed lawmakers are 'not looking to ban any books' but merely acknowledging that 'there are some issues little children aren't emotionally equipped to tackle, and many parents believe the issue of sexual preference is one of them.' "
(Certain unenlightened library systems in Oklahoma are already scurrying to get these books back in the closet where they belong.)
"E.T. does not have a fabulous name and is majorly ugly, but ever since the first time I saw him (I was six), I couldn't get him out of my mind. I began thinking I was from some other planet and wishing I could go home, just like E.T. I would even look up at the sky at night and try to pick out which planet was mine. I had a name for it--Wisteria.
"I think that's really the name of a flower or a perfume or something, but I liked the sound of it. I never told anybody, not Bobby or my aunt Pam or anybody. Wisteria was just for me.
"I never pictured Wisteria very clearly in my mind. I didn't know what the houses looked like or the trees or people or anything. When I imagined myself living there, it wasn't what I saw that mattered. It was what I felt. I felt at home."
"Their eyes are all asking
Are you in, or are you out,
And I think, oh man,
What is this about"
--Ani DiFranco, "In or Out"
If TOTALLY JOE was a story about Joe and Colleen instead of Joe and Colin, then it would be automatically added to school library collections serving fifth, sixth, and maybe seventh graders. The language, tone, and plot are that innocent. But because this is the story of Joe coming out and trying to navigate shark-infested hallways and school boards while being who he is, you can count on the book immediately making various hit lists referenced by "concerned" parents, preachers, and politicians.
"But that's no fair because then all the kids who don't know who they are can't read those books and find out who they are."
--Response of an eighth-grade student to her teacher (Shari, my wife) reading an article aloud today about the aforementioned "situation" in Oklahoma.
TOTALLY JOE is a very sweet, very funny, very enlightening companion book to James Howe's THE MISFITS. Having now been part of Shari's teaching THE MISFITS for four years, instigating a No-Name Calling Week based on that book, and having written and produced a school play also based on THE MISFITS, these characters have thoroughly become part of me.
I didn't discover Cynthia Voigt's seven-book Tillerman cycle until after she'd already written the entire set, but I can imagine the long-awaited excitement of rejoining the characters in a new book in that series after coming to love Dicey, her family, and her friends. That's what TOTALLY JOE did for me. And, as Voigt did with many of the Tillerman books, TOTALLY JOE partially overlaps the events that we viewed from Bobby's perspective in THE MISFITS, and then moves the story forward beyond those events.
"There is a road, no simple highway
Between the dawn and the dark of night
And if you go no one may follow
That path is for your steps alone."
--Robert Hunter/Jerry Garcia, "Ripple"
Following Joe Bunch's path through seventh grade is sheer joy. TOTALLY JOE is a totally ground-breaking book about the life and times of a funny, introspective, and gay middle school student.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No