3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Touching Story for Teens, November 16, 2009
This review is from: Touch (Hardcover)
Forgive the pun in the title, but I think the title of the book, "Touch" has a lot of meaning to it, to what the book is about, and to how it feels to read it. Touching.
This is the story of a girl, Maisie (but it could be any girl), who has to deal with issues that every girl must face. The issue of growing up, of watching friends change before your very eyes, of watching your own body change into something you can barely recognize. Because that's what happens. Nobody even really realizes the moment when other boys and girls start to lose their cooties. Suddenly girls/boys aren't icky, they're fascinating. This story is about that. It's about four friends who grow up and realize that they aren't friends but three boys and a girl. And as the four of them struggle to understand that, they take steps and make mistakes that (unfortunately) affect them for the rest of their lives.
I loved the characters. Kevin and Chris, two of Maisie's friends, didn't really have personalities but they had an important role in the novel. The rest of the characters are amazing, even if you hate most of them as Maisie does. Maisie is a girl who could be any ninth-grade girl, dealing with problems that too many people have to face (losing friendship, divorce, and touching). Shakes was also amazing. I'm not sure why I liked him so much, considering what he did. Maybe because Maisie liked him so much. And while Kevin and Chris had, in a way, chosen to separate themselves, Maisie lost Shakes because of circumstances. And it hurt me as much as it hurt Maisie to see him drift away.
This book reads very quickly. It may be some 300-odd pages, but it goes by fast because the pace is constant, never slowing. The story is told as a retelling most of the time, so it feels as if Maisie is sitting down and telling you everything (which, I'm sure, is how it's supposed to read). I was so desperate to know what happens that I had to resist the urge to skip pages just to learn if everything would turn out all right. And in a way, the ending was better than it could have been, but still was very realistic. Given the circumstances, you know from the beginning that there's no way to have a perfect, happy ending. Maisie knows that too.
In the end, it was a quick read, but meaningful with no wasted space. I finished the book and thought about it for some time afterwards, so I know it left an impression. Especially if you're a teenage girl like myself (or maybe even a guy) you'll identify with this book in a lot of ways.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Had potential but . . ., July 3, 2009
This review is from: Touch (Hardcover)
While I agree that this is a timely book and something a lot of girls (and guys) deal with, I was neither shocked nor engrossed by this book. There is way too much exposition and the voice isn't strong enough to pull me along. I found myself skimming huge portions and flipping to the end just to see if I was right about the denouement--which I was.
I think the trouble is that this doesn't sound like a 16-yo girl. It sounds like a highly literate adult trying to sound like a teenager. Don't get me wrong: the voice is always grammatically correct and there are some beautiful passages here. I am not trying to imply that teenagers don't understand grammar or how to write. But there is a difference between reading literary fiction written by a highly skilled adult and literate fiction told in a voice that sounds authentic. Try reading this for a few chapters, and then go pick up Jay Asher's THIRTEEN REASONS WHY or almost anything by Laurie Halse Anderson (except PROM) to understand the difference.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Very heavy, October 22, 2009
This review is from: Touch (Hardcover)
Prose does an excellent job of handling what is likely to be considered a difficult topic to address in young adult literature. Even though the main character is 14 and books featuring 14 year olds are typically read by 10-14 year olds, I wouldn't recommend this to anyone younger than 14.
The aspects of Maisie's life regarding growing up, trying to find independence with two separate sets of parents, and her changing body are explored with tact and honesty, but everything involving `the incident' takes it from about 10mph to 70mph in no time flat. There is a level of ambiguity about the incident that plays up the story overall in an interesting way. However, personally I didn't enjoy reading the book, but I suppose that's not necessarily the point. I commend Prose on her courage in addressing difficult issues like sexual harassment and her honesty regarding all parties surrounding them.
-Lindsey Miller, [...]
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No