Most Helpful Customer Reviews
44 of 50 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
and one more thing, July 5, 2006
This review is from: Touched By Venom: Book One of the Dragon Temple Saga (Paperback)
In addition to other things already mentioned, I have one very strong issue with this book. I'll try to put this somewhat delicately.
It's a question of basic logic. The descriptions given of the heroine's erotic/masturbatory feelings and practices do NOT jibe with the reasonable, believable experiences of a person who has had a amateurish, anesthesia-free radical clitoridectomy in childhood. (The words "ripping out" are used. And "flensing flesh from bone.") Considering that the female circumcision is so painstakingly, protractedly and viciously -- almost lovingly -- portrayed by this author, early on, in extended painful detail, one wonders, for example, when later in the heroine's life she gets excited and reaches "down there," just what the hell she is reaching for. Scar tissue??
This mutilation is extremely painful to read (and I am female. Perhaps ESPECIALLY because I am female). Maybe that's what the author was going for, and so maybe that's a triumph, a tour de force, I don't know. Not being my cup of tea doesn't necessarily make it a failed novel. Blatant ignoring of logic and sense might make it so.
(I think perhaps a quick reread of some Alice Walker might be in order. I'm just saying.)
Sci-fi/fantasy is no excuse to throw out the rules with no explanation -- only those with little respect for the genre think it is. For my feminist SF fix, I'll stick to recommending Sheri Tepper and Joan Slonczewski for the time being. (This is not to say forever. We'll see, Ms Cross.)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
61 of 73 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Poorly Written, November 29, 2005
This review is from: Touched By Venom: Book One of the Dragon Temple Saga (Paperback)
Most people are commenting on the bestiality, the castration, the female degradation in this book, so with all that said, I thought I'd comment on the writing style of the book.
I've never read anything else by Janine Cross, and I don't believe I ever will, but if she continues to write in this manner she will have a very lousy career as an author. Her editor should have perchance made a note to her about this. Most of the plot doesn't go anywhere for almost half the book. Then it all happens very suddenly, and we then return to a lot of our main character, Zarq, doing nothing.
She fills in the time with useless facts about the area, the people, and the local customs. Well over half of this information is useless to understanding the world, or anything else relevant to Zarq's particular story. Things that are confusing are never cleared up, particularly when Zarq mentions something in 'noble's tongue' and doesn't bother telling us what it is she's saying in English.
Another point of interest is that Zarq will randomly, it seems, fixate on a certain task, and then become distracted by another. It seems near the end of the book that the author was at a loss of where to go with it, so she pulled up a very long forgotten plot point and decided to have Zarq fixate on it, only to have her get distracted by her never-ending lust for venom.
I'm very confused as to how a book so poorly written was ever even published to begin with, so I tell you now to save your money, and your time, and not bother reading this. Unless you are in the mood to laugh at something terrible, this just won't cut it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
24 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Venomously Bad, March 2, 2007
This review is from: Touched By Venom: Book One of the Dragon Temple Saga (Paperback)
This is not the most horrible book I've ever read, by any means. But it's sure as heck on the top ten list of things that I wish I had never read.
First of all, though the author is not a completely terrible writer, she has some cumbersome words and phrases that got me to raise an eyebrow.
However, these have been discussed quite enough, in my opinion, so I'm not going to get into this. I'm going to review a different, and what I feel to be equally questionable, aspect of the book.
She seems to have inserted some hot-button social issues into her book without doing research on at least one of them, namely female mutilation. The darkness of these issues doesn't bother me at all. Neither, in fact, does her use of them in her book. In fact, if she'd managed to pull it off, I might be recommending this story all over the place. However, she proves her utter ignorance of them to anyone who knows anything about a woman's body, and the way it works. Since Cross seems to know so little about the issues she brings up in her work, I have to question why she felt the need to bring them up. The only conclusion I can come to is that she wanted to score points with literary critics. I find it rather offensive that she felt the need to essentially trivialize someone else's real-life plight in such a manner. Then to do what appears to be absolutely no research on the subject? Pathetic.
If you want dark fantasy, you can do so much better than this.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|