Most Helpful Customer Reviews
41 of 42 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Buy this book!!, June 24, 2002
This review is from: A Tour of the Bulge Battlefield (Paperback)
In August 2001, I spent two weeks scouting the Ardennes area by car using the older Charles Whiting guidebook and "Time for Trumpets" by Charles MacDonald as my guides. I had a fascinating vacation, but spent too much time trying to figure out where the actual battle positions were located. For example, it took me several tries to discover the real Peiper Kampfgruppe attack route (I think). I only discovered the remaining WWII foxholes on the Prumerburg near St. Vith by accident. I never did find the dragon's teeth at Losheim, despite lots of looking. Happily, this type of problem is now solved by the Cavanagh book (which was not available to me last year}. He shows you where to find the interesting routes and places mentioned in "Company Commander" and several other books, plus there are lots of interesting historical bits of information that were new to me, even though I have read most of the well known books on the Battle of the Bulge (including Danny Parker's book, "Battle of the Bulge", another must-buy for any newcomer trying to understand what happened). Cavanagh throws in extras too, such as the Medal of Honor action descriptions for each of the soldiers who won it during the Battle of the Bulge. I actually followed all the tour routes in the Cavanagh book during my second two week Ardennes vacation in August 2002. The directions were mostly easy to follow, and I really enjoyed reading the guide's historical information as I went along. This guidebook uses the popular "then and now" approach to provide a captivating sense that you can find history where it was made, even with all the changes to the landscape in 60 years. You won't regret buying this book. It's a winner in all respects, and inexpensive too.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Take this book with you when you go, August 15, 2004
This review is from: A Tour of the Bulge Battlefield (Paperback)
I was a battlefield tour guide in Europe for over three years. One of our most popular tours was the Ardennes Offensive aka "The Battle of the Bulge". Since we only had a day, we would drive up from Luxembourg City, paralleling the 3rd Army's relief route, and tour the Bastogne perimeter. If I had this book, I would've recommended this to my customers who wished to visit other sites of the battle. "A Tour of the Bulge Battlefield" is designed for the tourist who wishes to tour the battlefield(s) for himself/herself. Well researched and written, one could almost use this book as a secondary source in itself. The six chapters cover the entire battle, from the north around Stavelot, to the south in the Ettlebruch/Diekirch area. Each chapter is in itself an excellent capsulation of the battle and movements, both German and American. However, this is not a guidebook in the traditional sense, there is nothing about lodging, and very little regarding food, and other questions most tourists have. Also, what few maps there are inadequate, surprising considering this book is designed for auto-touring.
If you get several maps, the excellent Michelin series comes to mind, plus a traditional guidebook, and some `net research regarding transport, renting a car in Belgium/Luxembourg/Germany, this book would make for an outstanding historical vacation.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent guide, July 5, 2004
This review is from: A Tour of the Bulge Battlefield (Paperback)
I recently followed the trail of the well-known 'Kampfgruppe Peiper', with the help of this amply illustrated guide, from the then frontline in December 1944 at the German border to La Gleize/Stoumont in the Belgian Ardennes, about 60 kilometers from its point of departure. With the help of this guide it turned out to be a fascinating experience. The reader gets a very good picture, by surveying the terrain and reading this text, of the heavy fighting which took place in this area in this fateful period that took its toll on civilians and military alike. This guide provides not only an excellent description of the route Peiper and his men took but also contains much interesting background information. It also provides descriptions of the routes taken by the main German formations in other sectors of the front during their failed push to the west. A plus of the book is definitely that it pays lots of attention to the German perspective on what happened. This aspect is often neglected in other English language literature on the subject, e.g. in the Toland volume on the Battle of the Bulge. A minor point of criticism on this book in my view concerns the maps. The book contains maps, but as the author himself says in the introduction, the reader needs the relevant Michelin maps of the area as well to complete this otherwise very useful battlefield guide.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
