33 of 34 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not-so-Traditional British Cooking, November 6, 2007
This review is from: Traditional British Cooking: Simple Recipes for Classic British Food (Hardcover)
I grew up in London, and have a very traditional English mother, so if there's one thing I know, it's British food. If you've never made British food before, I don't suggest that you start with this cookbook. The introduction states, "Traditional British Cooking brings you . . . British-inspired gems." And that's my main grumble with this cookbook. Many of the recipes aren't really traditional, but they might have British elements to them. For example, cheese and onion bread is a quite common recipe in British cookbooks. The authors call for leeks in their recipe, nothing wrong with that, but they also call for Asiago cheese. Note to authors: Asiago is an Italian cheese, and is definitely not a feature of traditional British cooking. The mashed potato recipe calls for two heads of garlic. If a British cook were feeling daring, she might toss in a clove or two, not two heads.
I once read that the beauty of British cookery lies in its simplicity; it's the quality of the ingredients that carries it through. The authors don't emphasise that you really need to buy proper British ingredients to make British food work. A Welsh rabbit (cheese sauce on toast) made with American cheddar and beer will be ghastly. I make mine with English cheddar and Bass ale, and it's heavenly.
Nevertheless, the recipes are quite good if you want to take British cooking beyond its roots. For a good starter cookbook, I'd recommend Hilaire Walden's Traditional British Cooking. It's the cookbook I reach for most often when I fancy having the things that I grew up with (which is almost every day). There are a few typos/omissions in that book, which have perhaps been corrected, as I have an early edition, and a couple of things that need to be changed (omit the lemon juice from the sticky toffee pudding sauce - it's horrible with it; roll the scones out to one-inch thick - scones don't rise all that much and will be too flat if not rolled out thick enough), but you can usually puzzle out what's missing and, overall, it's a splendid introduction to the glories of British food. Just remember: for success, top-notch ingredients, British wherever possible.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No