55 of 55 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Trail Life, March 20, 2009
This review is from: Trail Life: Ray Jardine's Lightweight Backpacking (Paperback)
When I found out Ray Jardine was publishing a new edition of Beyond Backpacking I went to his web site and ordered a copy immediately (it not yet being in stores at the time). Beyond Backpacking having gone out of print quite some time ago, I was eager to read this book so many backpackers talk about. Perhaps the anticipation caused me to have expectations that were a bit too high. Don't get me wrong, it is a good book, with some great ideas and information, I was just expecting, well...more.
Trail Life is an updated version of Beyond Backpacking which is an updated version of Pacific Coast Trail Hiker's Handbook. I'm not sure why Mr. Jardine thinks it is a good idea to keep changing the title. As far as I can tell it is more or less the same content somewhat edited and updated. Overall I like the book, or at least I like Ray Jardine. As a backpacker It is hard not to respect this man who has hiked over 25,000 miles and help to change backpacking in some fundamental ways, Mr. Jardine having been one of the `pioneers' of light weight backpacking.
Trail Life can be enjoyed by anyone who loves to hike and backpack, but I would be hesitant to recommend this book to beginners. Primarily because the book appears to be an all inclusive `everything you wanted to know about backpacking' kind of backpacker's bible - but it's not. There are many sections discussing gear or skills where Mr. Jardine leaves out several pertinent pieces of information. For example; there is a thirteen page chapter on water discussing dehydration, purification, etc. Included are a few paragraphs on boiling and using iodine. Nothing on chlorine dioxide products (e.g. Aquamira) or ultraviolet pens (e.g. SteriPEN). This type of omission makes it obvious this book was not updated enough.
Mr. Jardine appears to have quite a bit of distain for outdoor equipment manufacturers (perhaps for capitalism in general). He recommends we make our own gear and clothes - which is a good way to go at times, but he goes much farther. He feels that if we do buy commercially made clothes we should sew patches over the logos rather than be `walking billboards'. His contempt for commercial manufacture's causes him to spurn practically all their products - so the book gives no useful advice on what gear to buy in regards to cloths, tents, packs, bags - we should make it all ourselves.
On the more positive side, Mr. Jardine does give some great advice about hiking itself. He includes a wonderful chapter on "Trail Shock" discussing how he and Jenny (his wife) have experienced in most journeys the point early on in a trip where you muscles start to ach or get stiff and you begin to feel like you should quit. It is reassuring to know this happens to everyone from time to time. His chapters on mileage, resupplies, hiking partners, hiking enjoyment and many other chapters are filled with tips from his experiences. I wish the book was filled with more of this. I'm sure after the many trips he has walked there is much more insight into the hiking experience Mr. Jardine could share with us. I hope he writes a NEW book someday - leaving out his views about gear and how to sew, and share with us more of what trail life really can be like.
[...]
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Trail Life, September 9, 2009
This review is from: Trail Life: Ray Jardine's Lightweight Backpacking (Paperback)
Ray Jardine does it again with his updated guide to lightweight backpacking. This book is pretty definitive. Whether you are interested in trying backpacking or have years of experience, Jardine has useful information. Almost every facet of backpacking is covered from shelter and sleeping gear to clothing and innovative ways of staying dry. Jardine also emphasizes that the most expensive gear is usually not the best solution. He also discusses DIY projects for outdoor gear. If you want to start backpacking or if you'd like to find ways to reduce your packweight while increasing your mileage, this is the source.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent Book, September 26, 2010
This review is from: Trail Life: Ray Jardine's Lightweight Backpacking (Paperback)
As new to UL Backpacking I wanted to read what many consider to be the orginal source. Almost 400 pages detail his experience, gear, and thoughts during thousands of miles of backpacking. Sure, there's controversial stuff, tarps, quilts, organic food. But that's the whole idea to see what he's thinking and why. And, it doesn't come from nowhere, plenty of experience talking. I rate this 5 stars with the caveat to "absorb what is useful" train of thought and an excellent introduction to UL Backpacking from someone who seems to haev started many of the original ideas found today.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No