27 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Works Well, October 28, 2004
This review is from: Transforming Children Into Spiritual Champions: Why Children Should Be Your Church's #1 Priority (Hardcover)
This is a good solid book. Too many churches treat children's ministry like a babysitting service and an afterthought. I work at a school that provides MA in Children's and Family ministries and the many many students we have in the program are getting a graduate education in Children's & Family ministries. They are taking this seriuosly, their churches are taking it seriously, and so is George Barna in this book.
There are many stats to back up what he is saying and it is done in plain english. I appreciate the way Barna shares his research and does not seem so profit driven as other Christian writers from big publishing companies.
This, is a good book. Every elder in any church that cares should pick this up and give it a look before the church budgets are set for the following year. I highly recommend it. Joseph Dworak
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
27 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Thoughtful, well-reasoned challenge, May 26, 2004
This review is from: Transforming Children Into Spiritual Champions: Why Children Should Be Your Church's #1 Priority (Hardcover)
Barna is known for writing books based on superb research - and this one is no exception. Drawing from several national studies conducted among children, as well as others among families and church pastors, this book really challenged me to re-think my own assumptions and behavior regarding the importance of ministry to children. The book was helpful to me personally, not only by giving useful insights into why focusing on substantive ministry to children is so critical - he offers some very eye-opening information in that regard - but also providing specifics on how to reach kids more effectively. The last few chapters outline what churches can do to facilitate parents being more effective and how churches can assist parents rather than replace them. A disturbing book in some ways - the spiritual state of children, as described, is frightening - but a hugely helpful, practical and needed book. Every parent and every pastor should read this one!!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
33 of 39 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
This was a serious disappointment to me..., March 2, 2006
This review is from: Transforming Children Into Spiritual Champions: Why Children Should Be Your Church's #1 Priority (Hardcover)
I have never read anything by George Barna, though I have heard a great deal about him, as his statistics seem to be quoted by every Christian speaker under the sun. From that perspective, I expected great things from this book. Truthfully, I was disappointed.
To be fair, he does present a solid case that God cares deeply about children, so the church should care about children, too. But that's not something that any reasonable church leader would dispute.
His description of what effective churches are doing was compelling and caused me to consider those various strategies. However, I wish that he had been more specific through that chapter, to identity what specific churches had done in detail. Instead, he chose to speak in very general platitudes. Again, with such generalities, it is hard to disagree, but it also tends to be much less instructive to the reader.
My first primary criticism of the book is that, as mentioned in some other Amazon reviews, the statistical data seemed to be rather sparse. The book served largely as a forum for Barna to sermonize about ministering to children. Though he had some good things to say, his reputation suggests that he comes from a very objective place of analytical research. That did not seem to be the primary thrust of this book. Maybe I had unreasonable expectations, but this book is not a statistical analysis of the state of contemporary church ministries to children. A few stats are mentioned (and even repeated) throughout, but I wanted more.
I also felt like his claim that children's ministries should be THE primary focus of church ministry was a stretch, and not well-supported. That churches should make ministry to children ONE OF THE primary focal points is something worth articulating. And he raised good questions as to whether this is even the case in many churches. But to suggest, rather flippantly, that children's ministries should be elevated above all others seems to be such a dramatic charge that it ought to be extremely well-supported. Based on a lack of the unarguable factual data that I was anticipating, that case was not well made.
And as a final, if rather insignificant, complaint, one of the data charts was totally unreadable. I studied the chart for ten minutes and could not figure out what it was trying to illustrate.
I would suggest this book for anyone who thinks that children ought to be an afterthought for church leaders because Barna conclusively argues that this is far from the heart of God. But if you start with the perspective that children are important, I'm just not sure that Barna has much to offer.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No