12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Thorough documentation but no thriller ..., August 13, 2009
I purchased this book under the mistaken assumption that it would be in the mold of "Blind Man's Bluff" and the genre of submarine warfare narratives that are published so frequently lately. This was mainly due to the subtitle "The Defeat of the Soviet Submarine Force", which implied to me that the book would be full of tales of the detection and tracking of Soviet subs. This book is nothing of the sort. Rather, it is a technical memoir of the US Navy Long Range Acoustic Propagation Project (LRAPP) and their work. There are some stories of shipboard events, but they are always about various sea trials and oceanographic experiments. The book is more of an exercise in bureaucratic record-keeping, with a detailed listing of who did what, timelines, budgets, and heavy use of acronyms. There are some vignettes in boxes out of the main narrative that add some human interest and humor, but otherwise this is a tedious read.
The work described is truly remarkable, though, and is worth skimming past the dull recitals. The people were truly talented and achieved remarkable results. When read as a distillation of a highly technical subject, the book is quite accessible to the layperson and gives a feel for how the US Navy went from groping about blindly through the world's oceans and then, thanks to the techniques developed by LRAPP, could locate and track Soviet subs at great distances. The progression through the various oceanographic experiments that enabled this discovery is well-told (if you filter out the discussions on budgets and rank). I was particularly interested in the Arctic operations, which I believe my brother was involved (hey Ed!). The book covers the basics of ocean acoustics in plain English and has a much-needed technical glossary. The timeline, photographs, and figures are OK at best.
The author was not well served by the editing of this book. The flow of the text, by removing some repetitive tendencies, could have been much improved. The actual typography is atrocious, with hyphenated words occurring in the middle of lines, and entire sentences being cut off by text boxes.
Still worthwhile for the hardcore submarine reader.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Transparent Oceans, February 6, 2011
Transparent Oceans: The Defeat of the Submarine Force is an interesting history. It is a good source of information, giving the names of individuals and organizations who worked on ocean acoustics during the Cold War. The author's word usage is good and the text reads well. I enjoyed the book, having worked as an oceanographer for the Coast Guard during the period covered by the book, it brought back many pleasant memories. I would favorably recommend the book to anyone one interested in the history of the Cold War at sea.
The text needs some editing, words are hyphenated in the middle of a line, not at the end of the line where it would be appropriate. Also some portions of the text have been deleted, this is especially true of the text in the side bars. The figure captions are not informative and really need to be redone. The author's contention that the achievements in long range passive acoustic detection of submarine, was crucial in "Defeating the Submarine Force" is, at best, an exaggeration. Detection and classification are only the first steps in countering an under sea threat. He says nothing about how the very quiet submarines introduced by the Soviet Navy in the late 1980s would have been dealt with.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
My opinion, October 4, 2009
Title is amazing but content is not.
We wait for some new things about the sub war during the cold war between soviet and US. We find a poor history of the accoustic research made during around 30 years. It's interesting but doesn't justify the title.
I don't vote for this book except for those who are novice in this subject.
Kind regards
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
