From Publishers Weekly
Part "I Spy" game and part parable, Anderson's clever picture book is an eye-catching adventure. In rhyming couplets, narrator Mr. Grungy tells the tale of Jonah and the Whale. Anderson adheres to succinct plotting in verse form, but the story grows confusing after Jonah converts the Ninevites by saying "Change now or you will die!" The brevity of the text doesn't allow room for an explanation of Jonah's feelings of anger toward God and bitterness toward the people of Nineveh. The real plus here is the 3-D multimedia artwork. Anderson and Goolsby have created collages from such found objects as bottle caps, telephone cords, crackers, cereal and pretzels. Despite the inanimate ingredients, the composite images of the central characters convey both mood and emotion; Jonah's face consists of a three-pronged electrical outlet sporting a thatch of beard, and the whale, comprised of a soda bottle, watch bands, a bicycle light and cooking spatulas is a glittering wonder. Each spread also contains a "Trash & Treasure Hunt" which challenges readers to locate particular objects in the artwork ("Find at least ten metal things/ and something which unlocks a door."). Youngsters will find it hard to resist this fun and novel approach to studying a classic Bible story. Ages 3-up.
Copyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Kindergarten-Grade 2-Extremely busy yet entertaining double-page illustrations are the outstanding feature of this rhymed story of Jonah. Constructed from all sorts of found objects such as pretzels, pipe cleaners, electrical cords, dried peas, and much, much more, the collages are eye-catching. Children will have fun identifying the multiplicity of components and admiring how they are used to create the pictures. Each scene also has a "trash and treasure hunt" puzzle with instructions for locating various things in the picture. Although the versification of the text lacks fluidity, the poem is adequate and neatly tells how Jonah, hating Ninevites, tries to shirk God's assignment to warn them to mend their ways. He takes a ship sailing in the opposite direction. As the boat, a wonderful construction of tongue depressors, bottle caps, and such, sets out, a storm begins to rage. Knowing that God is angry with him, Jonah insists on being cast overboard into a sea of crinkled blue plastic wrap and from thence into the great fish's flotsam-filled belly. Spat out on the shore of Nineveh, he does his job and learns reluctantly that the people he considers trash are God's treasures. Not a first purchase, but clever.
Patricia Pearl Dole, formerly at First Presbyterian School, Martinsville, VACopyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.