1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
How easy it can be to lose yourself in activism and love, March 5, 2006
Julie leads a privileged life. She grew up an only child, her mother a successful Boston lawyer, her father an unknown sperm donor. She is finishing up her junior year at Wellesley, a prestigious private college, and has a healthy trust fund waiting for her. One night at a frat party, she meets Neil, who is writing his dissertation on the economics of deforestation. They start dating, so when Neil decides he's had enough of words and statistics and academia in general, Julie agrees to go with him to Oregon, the site of much of the deforestation Neil has been researching.
So Julie drives west with Neil and they become part of "the movement." For the first two weeks, they are in the forest, the site of secret camps and living platforms rigged high in old-growth trees to prevent them from being cut down. Julie enjoys herself at first. But it quickly becomes clear that Neil is so obsessed with the cause that he can't see beyond it. He's exceedingly cynical, reminding Julie that that if you try to tell an American about ozone depletion, global warming, and species and habitat destruction, you will get laughed at or categorized as a kook. So he has chosen action, and if people accidentally get hurt as a result of that action, then so be it.
Julie's love for Neil causes her to lose herself. She acquiesces to Neil's wishes and desires, whereas he does not do the same for her. She does and says things (or more often DOESN'T do or say things) based solely on how Neil will think and react. At one point, Julie is thinking about Cathy and Mole, two other members of the movement who are somewhat romantically involved. "I wondered how much her involvement with the movement was simply to please him." What is ironic about this observation is that Julie hasn't yet realized that much of her own involvement with the movement is simply to please Neil.
This story - narrated in the first person by Julie - is a tale of self-exploration and self-discovery, and a great deal of that has to do with Juile's mother. Throughout the summer, Julie is constantly reflecting on her relationship with her mother. Whenever she has a spare moment for idle thought, she is thinking about something related to her mother. "Running away" with Neil to Oregon for the summer was a rebellious act against her mother, and the consequence seems to be that Julie can't stop thinking about her.
Oregonians and other Northewesterners will enjoy the familiar descriptions of this scenic corner of the country, as well some of the local references in this book. My favorite was when Julie is being given a tour of the university town of Eugene, and her guide explains the abundance of coffee shops: "Northwest coffee is a necessary drug to cope with the unrelenting gray and rain."
I enjoyed this book a lot. Matson's prose is lovely to read, and the story she tells here is both interesting and informative, without being preachy. Though Julie's story, Matson shows the reader how easy it is to get caught up in ideals and rhetoric, and love too, and how hard it can be to find your way back out again.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Very good..., April 20, 2009
This review is from: The Tree-Sitter: A Novel (Paperback)
When I first saw this book, my thought was, "A fictionalized version of "Legacy of Luna." I put it back on the shelf. Later, I found myself drawn back to it. I'm so glad I read it. It reminded me, style wise, of Ann Hood's "Somewhere Off the Coast of Maine." (Hood endorsed the book; perhaps Matson is a protege.) It is a very nicely written examination of extremists in the environmental movement, told through a protagonist who is new to the politics. It is a light read, and yet has substance to it. I think a lot of people will enjoy this.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
Authentic people, places, and events, January 3, 2009
This review is from: The Tree-Sitter: A Novel (Paperback)
The characterization in this story is authentic, yet soft-focused with the polite remove of gentility.
There are some beautiful, ruminative sentences in this book. For example: "..time seemed infinitely generous when you were awake at sunrise. You could see vistas, you could let intention gradually take shape" (203) and "Just because you knew something was behind you, and that you'd never get it back, didn't mean you were finished with it, or ever would be" (241).
There are also some sentences whose meaning I appreciate in spite of a confused initial reading: "After the initial vertigo of loss--I'd been so certain, and if not Preston, then no one, no father--I grew to like the sound of it: Guardian" (97).
All in all, with the exception of priviledge afforded by wealth, I can easily walk in the shoes of Julie, the narrator. I could certainly have fallen for a brilliant, intense grad student with a passion for environmental activism and followed him across the country for the good of the trees. And the rest.
* I meant to give four stars. The edit option does not allow edits to the star rating.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No