Customer Reviews

Trout: An Illustrated History

5 star:		(13)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

After reading the reviews on this one I was just giddy with anticipation when it arrived. Any book on fish or fishing is a good one, and this one promised to be very good.

I don't read new books front to back - I browse at first, and flipped through "Trout", very impressed with the number of species and the marvellous illustrations. Then I went to Brook Trout - the fish of my youth, and still the one nearest and dearest my heart. Very good illustration and text.

I then went to the front and started through, and as fate would have it the Arctic Char was first up. That's when I started to worry. You see, I live in the Canadian Arctic, and have seen lots of Arctic Char - literally tens of thousands. I've studied them, fished them, eaten them, read about them, and learned about them. I am no "expert", but I know a few things.

Th fact of the matter is that from reading the text accompanying the illustration of the Arctic Charr, it is obvious that Prosek knows little of them. For example, he writes, "Eskimos cut a hole in a lake through ten feet of ice, fishing with a piece of seal meat on an ivory hook." Do tell. It gets better with, "In summer when the rivers run free, they catch them in nets made of Musk-ox or caribou sinew." Really. That stuff would have been half truths two centuries ago - today it is just plain wrong.

Those lines are tourist fiction reminiscent of the hogwash written by the early arctic explorers who, after a trip up north, could return home and write any mix of truth and fiction they wanted - because nobody knew any better.

That's my problem with the book. He knows little of Arctic Char, but proceeded anyway to write an inaccurate text - without the qualifier - "by the way I don't really know this, somebody told me and I didn't have time to check it out". Thinking what? Nobody would notice?

It's the other species in the book that worry me now - the odd, rare, and primarily western ones I have not had the pleasure of becoming acquainted with. Is that stuff accurate?

Still a great and very enjoyable book, and I recommend it to anyone who loves (okay, likes) trout. Enjoy the illustrations - just don't count on the information without checking it out.

Trout fishing is the most enjoyable thing I've ever experienced (yeah, even better than that!) Most of the books on trout lead you to believe that you have to achieve succeedingly higher levels of consciousness through concerted study of stream ecology, purchase of the most expensive equipment available, and years and years of practice and frustration in perfecting your casting skills. I've yet to see a book that simplifies the whole thing and tells you how you can wade into a stream in sneakers and shorts, armed with very little more than your rod, reel, and a few flies, and start catching fish right away.

No, Prosek's book doesn't do any of that, but it hints at the essential simplicity of trout fishing. The illustrations are riveting and serve well as reference plates. The commentary is blessedly sparse and gets to the point. It's a truly beautiful book and an obvious labor of love. Since so much literary claptrap surrounds fly fishing, I would have to compare most books on the subject to "Ulysses", while Prosek has produced a haiku that couples art and science. (I'm about to gag at my own literary allusion!)

If you want to get into the trout and fly obsession, buy this book for inspiration. Then, I guess I'll just have to write that book about cut-rate, simplified fly fishing as your next step!

This book will be different things to different people.

I can't speak to the accuracy of the text as one critic has but I will say that I learned a few interesting things.

As a hobbiest illustrator and amature artist, I do appreciate the excellent work of the young trout enthusiast and author. I would not consider the comments of our friend the "scientific illustrator" who claims, "On my first attempts at color, i could easily do that kind of work." Well said. I eagerly await your comments on Picasso's "bicycle parts".

This book is not a masterpiece but a work of art. I don't believe it to profess to be the definitive word on trout, yet it offers some interesting tidbits.

Most of all this book resides in the place that borders two wonderful worlds; that of trout and that of art. For those who are intrigued by either world, this book will make a very welcomed addition to your library. For those of us captivated by both worlds, this book is an absolute must.

This is a fascinating book. It provides a wonderful introduction to the varieties of trout in America. When I opened the book, the beautiful illustrations were the first to catch my attention. But after reading the informative and sometimes poetic text describing each species, I think the words paint an even more beautiful picture that reflects the author's passion and love for trout and their habitat. I recommend this book to anyone who wants to know more about trout beyond just the rainbow trout sold in the grocery store.

If you're a fly fisherman, reading this book can make you want to go out and discover all of these trout. Most of us have no idea of the variety of trout found in North America. After reading this book I wanted to travel to distant corners of the continent in search of Rio Yaqui and Sheephaven Creek Redband trout. Although lacking the detail of an Audubon or Peterson, Prosek's illustrations are beautiful, and capture the spirit of these gorgeous creatures. A must have for any angler who has ever enjoyed just looking at a trout.

I wonderful book detailing some lesser known and extinct trout strains, as well as most of the "common" trout in North Amrica. Beautiful drawings of the various trout represented.

Leafing through its pages in a bricks and mortar store, I had passed this book up in favor of Behnke's Trout and Salmon of North America. Joseph Tomelleri's ultra life like illustrations in that book tipped the scales when compared to Prosek's more stylized watercolors.

Let's just say I missed the point. While Trout and Salmon is a scientific work, Trout, An Illustrated History is a poetic exploration of our favorite fish. It engages the spirit as well as the intellect - not what one might first expect in a book about a game fish.

I took a second look after hearing Prosek interviewed on NPR's Speaking of Faith. While I wasn't too impressed by the author's somewhat pretentious on air ramblings, Krista Tippett, who I really like, seemed blown away by him. So I bought the book.

As it turns out, Prosek is an excellent writer as well as an outstanding illustrator. As we read in the Introduction, "The instructive nature of the trout stream is not forced upon its visitors, but held candidly by the water and the trees. The angler must make an effort to hear the stream's messages and see her beauty". And so it is.

The author's illustrations forgo the detail but capture the essence of the myriad varieties of trout. As one examines them, one realizes that they are reverentially rendered. And this is not misplaced. Prosek describes the mystique and attraction of his early encounters with trout: "They were the embodiment of what I held to be ideal".

I received Trout: An Illustrated History from Amazon 12/07, I have never had any bad experiences with Amazon ever...But this is the holiday's and this book Trout: An Illustrated History was a gift for my husband, I received it with a "ripped up" Jacket!!! not expected from Amazon.com so I'm disappointed. Quality control!!! what happened Amazon?

The book itself is very beautiful written with exceptional water color art, and we have another book from same author and I highly recommend it, if you have a trout lover in the family this book will surely please them.

I first saw this book while on vacation in Montana. I thought the pictures were just beautiful. When I got back home I bought the book so that I could have many of the pictures framed for our trout themed bedroom at our lake cabin.

Jim Prosek is an excellent artist and true fisherman. His drawings are beautiful. He is in love with trout and fishing and it comes through in this book he did while still an undergraduate at Yale.