From School Library Journal
Grade 4-7-This story of a sixth grader who is buoyed by her friendship with Judy, a handicapped girl, never quite floats. Courtney's social-climbing stepmother spends the family's meager funds recklessly before running away with another man. To add to her family's problems, her brother is arrested for supposedly dealing drugs, the principal thinks she has stolen money from his office, her father seems powerless to help, and her popular friends desert her. No adult intervenes in the situation except for Judy's mother, who tells Courtney, "we don't have time to belly-ache or sit and feel sorry for ourselves." Judy, who has a mobility disability, is entirely self-sufficient, upbeat, and able to defend herself. But she exists less as a character on her own and more as a symbol to show Courtney the way-thanks to her, Courtney learns that "If you fall down, just get up and keep going." Wallace re-creates the faction-ridden social structure of a middle school and has an ear for the dialogue of 12-year-olds, but the many subplots, the large number of minor characters to keep straight, and the didactic theme make this novel a less-than-essential purchase.
Susan Hepler, Alexandria City Public Schools, VACopyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.
Gr. 4-7. As Courtney enters the sixth grade, life promises to be wonderful. The most popular girl in the class befriends Courtney; she makes the cheerleading squad; and she even begins to get along with her stepmother. All of her newfound happiness disintegrates, however, as one event after another turns her life to shambles. Her brother gets arrested; her friends dump her; and her stepmother leaves, destroying her dad both emotionally and financially. At the height of her troubles, Courtney finds a true friend in Judy, a new girl shunned by the others because she walks with a cane and lives in the wrong part of town. The book is well written, with the foreshadowing of Courtney's troubles seen by the discerning reader. Wallace not only provides poignant glimpses at the way one challenged young person deals with obstacles, but also shows how Judy helps Courtney to realize her own courage in a manner that is inspirational without being sappy.
Susan DeRonne
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.