From School Library Journal
Grade 4-6-Banished to his room on Christmas Day, Ralph recounts the disasters that occur when his highly eccentric relatives come together to celebrate the holiday. Funny dialogue ("-I'm not going to sing `Away in a Manger' because I don't love the Little Lord Jesus and I don't think he has a sweet head-"); unique characters, from a demonic preschooler to a daft great-aunt; and hilarious but believable situations make this book a great read-aloud. It's reminiscent of Helen Cresswell's "Bagthorpes Saga" (Macmillan; o.p.), but accessible to younger readers. Fine is in fine form here.-S. P.
Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Gr. 5-7. Fine always has an amusing take on things, and here she casts a very British eye on Christmas. Ralph Mountfield, banished to his bed on Christmas Day, details what happens when 16 relatives descend on his house, and a family feud does them in. It's hard to decide who is the worst of the group: cousin Titania, an egotistical little twit who fancies herself a fairy; Great-gran, whose favorite line is, "If I had my own teeth, I'd bite you"; or the twins, who enjoy pelting dinner rolls at the cat. If Fine's humor isn't black, it's certainly very dark brown, so this story may best suit readers somewhat older than her usual audience. But kids who get the bitter, ironic tone will find this very funny, and fans of Harry Potter will enjoy the Briticisms and feel as if they've found their way to an all-Dursley Christmas.
Ilene CooperCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved