From School Library Journal
Grade 3-5-As a first-time camper, Winifred Fletcher is assigned to a different tent than her two pals from home and must make new friends. She is afraid her tentmates will treat her differently if they find out that her mother is dead so Winnie tells them that she is a famous artist instead. One lie leads to another. When her friends from home hear her lying and her father unexpectedly makes it for Visitors' Day, Winnie must cover up or own up. This satisfying, quick-moving story portrays the fun and challenge of camp life and making new friends. Frequent gray-and-white drawings capture Winnie's feelings and enhance the inviting text designed for beginning chapter-book readers. Though this is a sequel to Winnie Dancing on Her Own (Houghton, 2001), it stands on its own. Fans of family and friendship stories such as Paula Danziger's "Amber Brown" series (Putnam) and Johanna Hurwitz's "Russell and Elisa" series (HarperCollins) will truly enjoy meeting Winnie.
Jean Gaffney, Dayton and Montgomery County Public Library, Miamisburg, OHCopyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Gr. 2-4. In this sequel to
Winnie (Dancing) on Her Own (2001), motherless Winnie goes to summer camp with her two best friends. She has lots of fun--rock climbing, swimming, going to art class, making a new friend--but things become uncomfortable after she tells a lie and then can't stop lying. Not only does she say her mother is alive, she also claims Mom is a famous artist. As in the first book, the resolution is a little too easy. There's no rejection or jeering from her friends or anger from Dad when she's found out. But young readers will find a lot to talk about; they'll recognize that Winnie's lie is also a wish, and that camp is the kind of place where a kid can try to reinvent herself and become someone new for a while. Is lying the same as not telling? Geis' occasional, small pencil drawings show the girls and counselors enjoying the camp rituals and making friends.
Hazel RochmanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved