18 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Turkish Lover, June 11, 2006
This review is from: The Turkish Lover (Hardcover)
I often wondered, as I read this book, whether it was among the most self-serving blather I'd read in ages or one of the best books I'd read in years. Really, what's more self-serving than immortalizing your own existence in a book? And how much better when that book makes a former lover, who treated you poorly, look like a fool - repeatedly? In the end, though, the answer is - one of the best books I've read in years! If the periodic Spanish phrase intimidates the English-reading-only, don't let that stop you - almost every phrase is smoothly translated in the text.
Esmeralda Santiago, oldest of eleven children, runs away from home. At age 21, "runs away" sounds strange, but it is what she does. To be with her probably-Armenian-insists-he's-Turkish lover, Ulvi Dogan, she leaves her mother's home and begins to find herself by first leaving behind "Negi", the name she was called at home. Ulvi likes her just the way she is - naive, innocent, rather obedient and not at all a "spoiled American girl" - and calls her Chiquita. He treats her almost like property, looks on her family with disdain and works hard to keep her from growing, changing, and making friends. What Ulvi likes about her, and the way she honestly writes about it, makes the reader actually understand a little why she stays with this man, who is seventeen years older than she and would obviously not be able to have a relationship with a strong-willed, independent woman of his own age with opinions of her own - one who would certainly not let him call her "Chiquita". Without her honesty, the sentence "I was nothing Ulvi had told me many times." on page 23 would leave the reader wondering what could possibly be worth reading for the next 300 pages.
Esmeralda's relationship with Ulvi begins to end from the very start, when he returns from a stay in the hospital and locks himself in the bedroom to talk to another woman. It takes years to conclude. From Florida to New York to Texas and back to the east coast, often together, sometimes apart, Ulvi and Esmeralda seem to live two lives - his and theirs. Every break-up or time spent apart gives her more insight into herself and more courage to become Esmeralda, with her own life, until - one step at a time - she eventually finds herself, in every sense of the phrase, at Harvard. It seemed only fitting to me that her graduation should be in Boston in 1976, the 200th anniversary of the independence of America.
One small pleasure, for the nosy (like me!) reader: run "Ulvi Dogan" through a search engine. More than half of the hits are for this book, very few relate to "his" movie. A small thing, but I disliked the guy enough to smile when I saw that! I feel as if I should confess that I'm white, and living in a neighborhood that is mostly Hispanic and that a good chunk of the Spanish population here is Puerto Rican. Maybe that's what ultimately made this book such a pleasure - I could identify bits and pieces of culture and tradition from the book in the lives of people I know and care about. Or maybe it's that, despite her constant reference to her culture and the race issues that crop up throughout, Esmeralda's just a woman, and this is a story any woman of any age or race can relate to on some level. Either way, this title's well worth the time and has me looking forward (or, more accurately, backward) to finding her other works.
- AnnaLovesBooks
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Ode To Love, May 24, 2005
This review is from: The Turkish Lover (Hardcover)
Esmeraldo Santiago continues being captivating and at the same time totally refreshing. It is mainly because of her wonderful literary skill: distinctively interwoven poetic lyricism, rhapsodic narrative and rhythmic dialogue. Santiago's prose flows with a ready elegance, yet it has a seductive element that is quite subtle. She speaks for many young Latina women when she daringly exposes her vulnerability to the traditional and often overwhelming horrors of an abusive machismo ... whether boricua, dominicano, mexicano, Turkish or Anglo-Saxon. Ultimately, she triumphs gleefully with the astute realization that "there's always another train on the way."
THE TURKISH LOVER, unquestionably like the previous offerings from this powerfully talented writer, is certain to touch the lives of many of her readers. This latest work by Santiago is a joyous ode to love itself. Te felicito, hermana.
Alan Cambeira
author of Azucar's Sweet Hope...Her Story Continues.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Best book I ever read., January 28, 2005
This review is from: The Turkish Lover (Hardcover)
Don't let the title of this book fool you. It is NOT a story of some Turkish romance. Its the dynamics of how a highly intelligent, enlightened and educated young woman can still be in a dependant, abusive relationship. It shows that these rocky relationships, if you let them, can help us grow. Women should not feel ashamed if they have been in a relationship like this. We feel Esmaralda's vunerability in this book, as well as her great joys and accomplishments. As a Puerto Rican woman growing up in New York City in the 50's and 60's, she witnesses these thing early on, seeing how women are viewed in society, and in Puerto Rico. If you are without a man you are a Jamona, an old piece of ham. This is the story of a Puerto Rican woman who doesn't want that for herself , but must struggle with her independance without the help of her familia. I am envious of her independance and work ethic. I am also madly in love with the Puerto Rican culture. She describes her culture with such warmth, of the good and bad. Every turn of the book something exciting happens. The book contstantly moves forward. This book moved me and inspired me. The most moving part of this book is the conclusion that,no matter how successful and educated you are the most important thing is to be understoud, and accepted and loved unconditionally. Thank you Esmaralda for your vunerabelity. I can't wait to read your next book. Your dynamic life as touched me deeply.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No