Customer Reviews

The Turn-Around, Upside-Down Alphabet Book (ALA Notable Children's Books. Younger Readers (Awards))

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

When I conjure up the name Lisa Campbell Ernst, what instantly pops into my head is not a stark yet colorful alphabet book. This is the author/illustrator that brought us such memorable classics as, "Stella Louella's Runaway Book", and "Little Red Riding Hood". She has a bubbly cartoony style that I never seriously thought she'd break away from. But break away she has (and how) in this somewhat Laura Vaccaro Seeger-inspired, "Turn-Around Upside-Down Alphabet Book". Apart from being a bit of a mouthful, the book is an inventive take on teaching kids new ways to examine individual letter. And though it bears an uncanny similarity to Seeger's, "The Hidden Alphabet", Ernst's imbued it with enough wit and style to make it stand entirely on its own.

Now to read this book you better be prepared to do exactly as the title suggests. With each letter we see four different ways to view each letter. Turn the letter "A" one way and it's a bird's beak. Turn it another and it's a drippy ice cream cone. Placing her color contrasting letters in meticulously crafted positions, Ernst is able to draw the most remarkable images from her illustrations. At her best, she does amazing things with difficult letters. I was especially impressed with the "magic wand casting a spell" that came from her elegant letter "G". Ditto the "M"'s, "two fish playing chase". Ernst isn't afraid to stretch her images from time to time, however. The "point of a wishing star" that's supposed to come from an angled "A" is sketchy at best. Ditto the "mama duck and her two little ducklings" that springs from an inverted "K".

Another disadvantage to this book comes from the black borders that surround some of the letters. "The Hidden Alphabet" by Seeger is similar in layout to this book, but has thick black borders that never show the residue of oily fingertips. "The Turn-Around Upside-Down Alphabet Book" doesn't have this advantage. If you touch a page, that page stays touched. And considering that this is a book that is going to enjoy multiple repeated touchings, this works to its disadvantage. I know Ernst isn't to blame here, but for her sake I wish the publisher could've found a better black border substance to withstand the grubby prints of little fingers. After two readings, this book will show its age.

Otherwise, it's lovely. A fun way to get kids interested in the alphabet and nice eye-twisting almost optical illusionary twist on a tried and true form. As alphabet books go, it's fine n' dandy. Not the most inventive out there, but certainly not the least. For Ernst fans, it marks quite a departure. For people who've never encountered her work before, it's a lovely introduction.

What I really like about "The Turn-Around Upside-Down Alphabet Book" is that it is not going to loose it's usefulness six months down the road. Some ABC books, for example, that cater to toddlers loose all their appeal when the child becomes an older preschooler or kindergartener. This book, I think, has more staying power and won't become passé so quickly.

With a younger child, for example, you can just ignore the word-play and book turning [you turn the book to get the joke], and just point out the letters and the sounds they make. While with an older child you can sit back and share the joy of finding out what the author has *done* with the letters; what the jokes are.

In addition, you can play like we have to see what you can make out of the letters. (A good way to make writing fun.)

The only 'con' to this fun book is that it does get rather tiring to keep turning the book around to read the text. But in our opinion that's a pretty small drawback.

Four Stars. ABC fun for all ages.

Although a big fan of Lisa Campbell Ernst's previous books, this book sets a new standard for excellence in children's books. The innovative style she presents in this alphabet book is intriguing for both children and adults. While reading this book aloud to young neighbors, they soon learned the fun of using their imagination to determine what each letter might be if turned on its side or upside down. This book is a delight for all ages.

This book gets you hands-on, turning and twisting the book to change your perspective. Kinetic learning, visual learning - we love it. It works for all ages - it is not your typical alphabet book. My bigger kids (elementary ages) read and re-read it.

We are living through a golden age of children's book publishing. This book is amazing.

I can't believe the great reviews this book has received. It's absolutely awful! When I first flipped through it, I thought it was such a cute idea for a book; after sitting for a thorough read-through with my preschooler, I realize it just doesn't work. "A wave-tossed boat and buoy?, A pirate's eye patch?" Great concept, poor execution.

This book is more about imagination than learning the alphabet. Although you could use it to help teacher youngsters their ABC's, this is a book to let you look at the world from a different view. Like gazing at clouds on a summer day, this book lets children look at a simple graphic and transform their letters into things they see around them. It encourages you to look at the letters from all sides and find your own images.