3.0 out of 5 stars
Flawed and overwhelmingly biased, but not without merit., December 5, 2011
This review is from: Unfinished Business: South Africa, Apartheid and Truth (Hardcover)
Unfinished Business is a discussion of the various issues and events of the Apartheid era in South Africa missed, underrepresented, or forgotten by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC). It covers areas as far reaching as banishments, the infiltration of student and anti-apartheid organizations, and the personal tribulations of one of the authors - Dumisa Ntsebeza.
My issues with this book are several-fold. Firstly, the writing style is dry, a bit repetitive, and lacks flow. The book is slow and plodding at times, and has difficulty maintaining a logical and thematic focus within chapters. In this, it is difficult to read, especially considering the author is supposed to be a journalist/writer.
The book also seems to have trouble in it is not sure where it wants to go. It often mentions issues or events that it believes should have been covered at the TRC, but buries them amidst chapters on an entirely different topic. To this end, the book feels to be a failure, as it never makes a compelling, and more pressingly cohesive, argument on what exactly it feels the TRC should have covered that it did not and why. This becomes a glaring oversight when once considers the TRC report is thousands of pages, and this book maxes out at about 300. To paint the Commission with such a uncomplimentary brush - especially when one of the authors was involved with it - seems unfair without considerable explanation. Returning to the issue of focus, the reader eventually comes to understand that the authors feels the architects of apartheid should have been held to greater task, this is all well and good, but hardly a shocking conclusion. One wonders what they hoped to accomplish here. Certainly, the book has no legal ability to force this issue, but neither did the TRC, again asking what they expected the commission to do. This is especially true when one actually reads the TRC report and realize that it hopes to primarily focus on the individual acts and trevails of the apartheid era as opposed to widespread condemnation of the system of apartheid and its leadership - a process that had been well covered and indeed, without which the system would have never been overcome in the first place. That the authors want more to be done to the former leadership of the nation, their questions and exasperation should be aimed at the current ANC government, not a non-judicial commission of inquiry with an already dizzying mandate to fulfill.
More concerning is the lack of simple commitment to unbiased discussion of the unfinished business of the apartheid era. The book covers the struggle against the system with the same uncomplicated "good vs. evil" terms as the apartheid system painted their struggle against the resistance movements. At best it casts significant doubt on the intellectual honesty of the book, and at worst enjoins the reader to invalidate much of the books content due to the avowed, but unspoken bias it carries. Perhaps the most glaring moment of the book is when the authors indignantly discuss the humiliation and injustice heaped on Winnie Madikizela-Mandela when she has been banished. There is not even the most scant acknowledgement of her supposed involvement in the Mandela United Football Club allegations laid out by the TRC and which earned Ms. Madikezela-Mandela considerable condemnation from fellow TRC member Pumla Gobodo-Madikizela. The fact that there are no discussion or judgment passed of the trespasses of the ANC, APLA, or other resistance movements gives credence to those who would want to invalidate the entire content of the book. To this end, the authors negate much of the weight that they attempt to give their text except to those predisposed to regard it as unqualified truth.
Overall, this book is not a bad book. The content is somewhat worthwhile and bears note. The fact that the abuses by both sides have been covered in greater depth and with greater honestly in other texts, makes it difficult to recommend it on anything other than its price and availability.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Face The Facts, October 26, 2007
This review is from: Unfinished Business: South Africa, Apartheid and Truth (Hardcover)
If you think that post-apartheid South Africa has "buried" the past and is moving toward a brighter future....think again. This book confirms what I feared ever since the TRC was announced. So many unanswered questions...so much unfinished business. If you care anything at all about South Africa....read it...read it...read it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 45 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
HONESTY not just "TRC", March 19, 2004
This review is from: Unfinished Business: South Africa, Apartheid and Truth (Hardcover)
"How come you had to tell me that?" -Bob Dylan
READ IT AND WEEP! But ..."You gotta have a bullet-proof soul."
-Shadea. GO AHEAD...READ IT: "You shall know the truth...and the truth shall make you free." -Bible. Then, let us do the right thing...finally: REPARATIONS; LAND&WEALTH REDISTRIBUTION; RESTORATIVE JUSTICE! Let's not let the work of these two BRAVE WARRIORS be wasted for a moment. Not one word. Not one moment. "GO AHEAD ... READ IT! And,then...WORK4AZANIA...AZANIA...This is where we shall meet! Some day. Maybe one-day-sooner due to our attention to the "Unfinished Business" of South Africa and the world community envisioned by Bell and Ntzebeza.
Meet me there. -Azaniaphile
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
