37 of 45 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Excavating the Gold From This Pile of Dust, July 30, 2008
This review is from: Unholy Business: A True Tale of Faith, Greed and Forgery in the Holy Land (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
(Review is based upon Uncorrected Proof)
While reading this book I felt at times like a field archaeologist, sifting through piles of rubble and dirt to find a few precious artifacts of gold. The gold is there, to be sure, in small nuggets. You just have to be willing to dig for it.
Part travelogue, part human interest story, part crime report, part reporter's notepad, the genre of this book is difficult to pin down. It reminded me in many ways of
Walking the Bible: A Journey by Land Through the Five Books of Moses (P.S.) (without the religious insight) or
Under the Tuscan Sun: At Home in Italy(without the recipes). My initial annoyance and disappointment with "Unholy Business" was ultimately tempered when I realized that I was not reading a scholarly work on archaeology, history, linguistics or even criminal forensics, but a kind of breezy and highly personalized travelogue. In hindsight this is not surprising, as Nina Burleigh is listed as a staff writer for "People" magazine, which I dip into briefly during almost every visit to my doctor. The writing of "Unholy Business" fits precisely within the human-interest story found in "People." As a history, I would give the book a single star. As human-interest story cum travelogue, it deserves two stars, possibly the three awarded here.
Three supposed archeological artifacts figure prominently in this book: The James Ossuary (supposedly the repository for the bones of James, the brother of Jesus), the Joash Tablet (supposedly bearing an inscription which proved the existence of the First Temple) and a carved ivory pomegranate (supposedly an ornament for a small priest's scepter used in the First Temple). These are--or ought to be--the heart of the book. The problem is that Burleigh spends most of the book talking about background issues--the teeming and corrupt antiquities market in Jerusalem, the 30,000 archaeological sites in Israel, the tension between Orthodox Jews and American Evangelical Christians, and so forth--and only really gets to the crux of the matter in the latter half of the book. Hence, I feel like a digger on an archeological grid, sifting through sand, hoping to ultimately uncover the precious artifacts.
Some additional comments and observations:
1. My chief problem with this book was Burleigh herself and her decision to write this book. I kept asking myself, "What qualifies this person to write a book about the world surrounding the cradle of Judaism, Islam and Christianity?" I never found a satisfying answer. To be sure Burleigh is a fine reporter. Indeed, much of the book reads like a verbatim transcript of a reporter's notebook. But what really qualifies her to write this story? To her credit, Burleigh admits that she has virtually no background in the world of religion. "My own religious training was nonexistent," she says on page 19. Her only admitted contact with "believers" from any religious tradition came from Mennonite missionaries who visited her childhood home in the 1960's and 1970's. "From them I learned that there are some very decent people who live every waking minute in a state of unshakeable faith in an otherworldly power," she wrote. I question whether this fleeting contact with Mennonite missionaries in the United States qualifies her to get into the heads of any "believer" of any tradition. Her true bias against "believers" is revealed by her description of Jerusalem, as the location of "the death match between reason and superstition--monitored by laughing commerce." To her, belief is tantamount to "superstition." I am suspicious of any writer, reporter or otherwise, who presumes to understand a subject as complex as Jerusalem from that smug, self-satisfied height of self-delusional "reason."
2. I also question her understanding of the historical background of her subject. She exhibits a shallow understanding only--a reporter's understanding--of archaeology, of linguistics, of the Dead Sea Scrolls, of politics. For example she says innocently, "No one had ever found an archaeological object linked to the First Temple." (Page 17). My slack-jawed reaction was, "Uhhhh.. you mean, other than THE TEMPLE MOUNT ITSELF!!" Later she says of the Temple, "the remains of the platform that once supported this temple are known as the Wailing Wall or the Western Wall." (Pg. 16). This is ridiculously false and simplistic. The Temple Mount covers many acres. The western wall is only the smallest of the remains of a retaining wall--mostly Herodian--some distance removed from the actual foundation marks of the First Temple, plainly visible under the Dome of the Rock. Later she makes the wide-eyed claim that the purpose of the Temple was solely house the Ark of the Covenant. This is all very Indiana Jones-like in its simplicity, but it fails to do justice to the richness, the depth, the complexity and the profound significance of the First Temple, its environs, its service, its priesthood and everything that flowed out from it culturally, historically and spiritually.
3. On its face, the book appears well-organized. The chapters have appropriate titles, and even insightful and inviting quotations leading into the prose. The chapters are divided into distinct sections, usually focusing on personalities involved in the antiquities trade, scholars, archaeologists, police, etc. But the Prologue and Epilogue are rather jarring and disjointed. The Epilogue ought in some ways to be a satisfying culimination of the Prologue, or its mirror image. The Epilogue ought to bring us full circle, perhaps returning even slightly to the not unsympathetic portrait of Ada, the idiosyncratic epigrapher toiling in her fascinating home. But here Burleigh's epilogue seems unrelated stylistically or thematically with the strong Prologue. This Epilogue is more of a Joe Friday, Dragnet-style denouement: "In 2004 the Jerusalem District Attorney submitted Criminal File 482/04 with the District Court of Jerusalem..." (Page 243). We almost await Joe Friday's laconic voice intoning, "In a moment, the results of that trial."
4. Overall, her multitude of character sketches are beautifully done, but there is also much by way of very lazy description. Particularly annoying were the many character descriptions related to popular culture. When Burleigh gets lazy and can't come up with her own description, she uses the shorthand of popular movies and culture. Some examples of weak personal descriptions: "Her gap-toothed smile and sleepy eyes suggest the sultry actress Ellen Barkin" (Pg.1); "[A]n impish face reminiscent of Joel Grey in the movie Cabaret..." (Pg. 12); "an odd duck--lawyer, crank, P.T. Barnum, and Indiana Jones all rolled into one man" and comparable to "a Saul Bellow character" (Pg. 33); "Seeking a real-life Indiana Jones, one could do worse than visit Seymour Gitin...." (Pg. 91); and "A tanned, jocular man, he greeted us in the standard uniform of the dirt archaeologist--Indiana Jones hat, sweat-stained T-shirt, shorts and sandals" (Pg. 95). If Burleigh mentioned Indiana Jones one more time in her book, I was ready to jump off of the top of the Wailing Wall.
5. Really, this book reads much like the unredacted notepad of a newspaper reporter. We get too much here. There is too much Nina Burleigh here, and not enough James Ossuary. Her prejudices and quirks and likes and dislikes, continually obtrude themselves into the narrative. Examples: "In an interview over rugelach and black coffee at Morty's Deli in Washington..." (Pg. 54); He was "barely into his first cup of Nescafe when he received a call..." (Pg. 64). This is way too much information for my taste.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting Story about Archaeological Fraud, August 3, 2008
This review is from: Unholy Business: A True Tale of Faith, Greed and Forgery in the Holy Land (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
I read this book because I wanted a journalist's eyeview of the trade in looted and forged artifacts as well as the full story of the James ossuary that disappeared from the press after making such a splash in the early part of this century. In my opinion Nina Burleigh does a very good job of introducing the reader to the characters of the drama-- the scholars, the dealers, the buyers and the agents who are supposed to police them all. Far from finding them distracting, I thought the details she provided about the various people are entertaining and give good visual references. If this doesn't become a documentary then I will be very surprised.
She clearly showed the interests that individuals had in the various sites and the finds that might (or might not) connect them to the Bible-- monetary, reputation, political and religious. And then she brings her story back around to the detective work that led to the discovery of the hidden items, the scientific investigation of the various items that led to the prosecution.
She isn't terribly unkind to anyone, not even Hershel Shanks-- who I first read about when a misguided friend gave me a subscription to Biblical Archaeology Review-- a publication that is indeed quite shiny. Mr. Shanks at the time was being sued by Elisha Qimron, a scholar working on the Dead Sea Scrolls, for publication of his copyrighted work without permission. Mr. Qimron won, I later learned.
Anyway, I found this book informative and entertaining without sliding into the shrillness that can be found in a lot of discussions about religious claims on the Near East and its history. I can safely predict a few hackles will be raised anyway.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Proof, lies, and antiquities..., August 27, 2008
This review is from: Unholy Business: A True Tale of Faith, Greed and Forgery in the Holy Land (Hardcover)
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
During my twenty-four years as an evangelical Christian I devoured anything remotely validating the Bible's authenticity, such as the Noah's Ark expeditions and other key archaeological findings in the Middle East like the Dead Sea Scrolls. Two recent discoveries came to light as I was leaving my faith: The James Ossuary and the Jehoash Tablet. After much debate and analysis it turned out that these controversial items were sophisticated fakes, and their rise and fall is smartly documented in this fascinating book.
"Unholy Business" takes us into the seamy underbelly of the Middle East antiquities trade, specifically within Israel and the Palestine territories. Nina Burleigh covers the recent period when the above finds were unearthed, tested, and found wanting. The James Ossuary, a stone burial box, was inscribed with a phrase that made it the first archaeological object to substantiate Christ's existence (not to mention his father Joseph and brother/cousin James). As for the Jehoash Tablet, it was touted as proof of Solomon's Temple, thus augmenting the Jewish claim to the Temple Mount.
Both artifacts generated religious and political firestorms while being subjected to the scrutiny of reputable scholars. After rigorous analysis, the experts came to the conclusion that both items were bogus due to various inconsistencies and anachronisms. The persons held responsible for the frauds were charged with "creating a series of forgeries and scheming to sell them," and were subjected to a drawn-out legal ordeal that further tainted the situation, thus enabling some quarters to still claim that the items are genuine. Indeed, the title "Unholy Business" is an apt description of the entire affair.
The author does a good job documenting this fascinating ride with a well-written whodunit style that keeps us guessing. She draws us into the antiquities world and highlights its impact on Israel's complicated past and tumultuous present. We meet and get to know a cast of rogues, saints, and those in-between: Shady collectors, obscure academics, true believers, fervent nationalists, and intrepid law enforcement agents. Although we see good folks of both religious and secular persuasions, it was troubling how faith, politics, and profit corrupted the search for truth in "Unholy Business."
As a former Christian and current agnostic, I was particularly affected by religion's quest for relevance via the antiquities trade. I still remember how stoked my Christian friends and I became when something was unearthed that confirmed the Biblical record, how we rationalized away other items that contradicted it, and even our fervent desire to visit "our" Holy Land. The author's interactions with various pilgrims showed that these trends continue within the ranks of believers. It was sad how easily persons of faith and those seeking a national identity allowed their rationality to be compromised by profiteers.
In the end, some Christians will probably not be thrilled with this book due to its stance on the non-authenticity of the Ossuary and Tablet. However, the author performs a necessary service by shining a harsh light on those engaged in historical fraud, as well as on people who are willing to forego rigorous scholarship in order to validate their religious or political beliefs. "Unholy Business" is a well-written detective story about how archaeology's quest for truth can be corrupted by outside agendas and the lust for mammon. Recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
