Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
I'm just not cool enough, October 27, 2010
This review is from: United States of Americana: Backyard Chickens, Burlesque Beauties, and Handmade Bitters: A Field Guide to the New American Roots Movement (Paperback)
Instead of reading as a "Guide," The United States of Americana reads more like a Who's Who reference list of where you should be shopping and what music to listen to if you want to jump on the new American roots movement bandwagon. Many chapters (most notably the clothes, leather working, and part of the food, and music sections) is a list of "cool" young hipsters "doing their thing". Reading it, I feel less guided and more pushed (with their blogs and websites listed so you can go check them out).
Lack of Gender
While I thoroughly enjoyed reading about men's facial hair, the different types of mustaches (really!), the origins of each liquor, and almost every sidebar, I was disappointed to see there was little, if no, female influence on any of these topics. Sure, knitting and crafts scream "the woman's job," but regarding clothes, grooming, leather work, and even music, historical influences and subsequent revelations were male-oriented. Where are the women's trends? Hats, fascinators and headpieces are all making enormous resurgences in women's fashion; it would have fit nicely between straight razors and bowler hats. It would have been nice to read how today's movement is affecting the "other" gender, since I consider myself a woman participating in this new American roots movement. Gender's not even mentioned facetiously until the crafts chapter. Mentioning Martha Stewart doesn't count, and boiling women down to crafts and burlesque is predictable.
Music
It is clear that Reighley is a music lover. The passion (albeit, a bit of snootiness) that shines through in his chapter "Songs of Pioneers" is obvious. But it leaks a little into other chapters, such as "Design and Décor." Why bring up Jon Langford (a whole section on him) and the American music community AGAIN, in the Design and Décor chapter? Completely off topic! Could have omitted those 2 pages entirely - or plopped them in the music chapter.
Pros
In addition to the catchy style of writing, I like being able to put names like Velocipede and Dirigible with their odd object counterparts. Some parts of the book were incredibly informative and fun to read: topics such as mustache variations, as mentioned before, types of liquors, early American musicians, and types of fibrous crafts. Honestly, the epilogue was one of the best parts of the book - I just wish Reighley had imparted more of that sincerity and personal touch to the rest of the book.
Bottom Line: I'm Just Not Cool Enough
The overall tone of the book, while well written, witty and fun to read, is a bit snobbish. I feel like I'm just not cool enough to read this book or take part in this movement - even though I'm 26, lived in Brooklyn for 8 years, and am a dirt-broke, starving artist. Furthermore, I keep chickens, have a garden, can and preserve food... and yet I felt these topics were lacking when it came to the "United States of Americana." Where is the part about keeping a garden in the "Food" chapter? And how are we not talking about being green, conserving resources, leaning more towards self-sufficiency and sustainability as a motivator in this new roots movement? I'd hedge my bets that the state of the economy is what is inadvertently encouraging a lot of young folks (my generation specifically) to this sort of lifestyle, in conjunction with a desire to tread lighter on the planet. So why do I feel like this movement is only for the hip and the wealthy?
Overall, a nice, easy read, but I feel like it lacked in the true heart and soul of the movement...every day, normal people trying to live simpler lives.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The right writer for a broad but fascinating topic, October 8, 2010
This review is from: United States of Americana: Backyard Chickens, Burlesque Beauties, and Handmade Bitters: A Field Guide to the New American Roots Movement (Paperback)
In a lesser journalist's hands, this book could've easily gotten lost - after all, what do chickens, boots and burlesque all have in common? Luckily Reighley isn't just a veteran music journalist, he's both a skilled interviewer and a seasoned critic of popular culture in general, able to show you what unifying strands connect the current popularity of knitting to both punk rock's DIY culture and the current state of feminism. As an interviewer Reighley finds the choicest insights from a wide range of truly fascinating characters, but it's his ability to weave these ingredients together into one grand narrative that makes this book really rock.
There's a paradox in all this: what's the big Story in a bunch of people doing old stuff? As the answers unfold, it becomes clear that all of these quirky old-fashioned hobbies (some of which have turned into lucrative professions) are a vivid (and mostly authentic) search of meaning, intimacy and a sense of realness against the backdrop of Facebook America (where your friends literally are electric). Even as Walmart and other huge corporations own more and more of our commerce, our government, our time and our culture, the underground of DIY artisans is burgeoning too, from your local farmer's market to Etsy.com, and even as YouTube and Pandora transform what it means to consume music, odds are there are more and more artists in your community finding greater satisfaction busking blues, bluegrass or old-time music, or trading in their turntables for belly dance and burlesque costumes.
In short, this is an ambitious but unforgettably effective book about who we are in 2010 as we as a nation mine our traditions for anything we can reuse or recycle that will make our lives feel realer than our Friends Lists and Status Updates and credit ratings and poll numbers. And, best of all, Reighley accompanies all his thought-provoking research and cultural critic work with practical DIY tips, in case all this reading about backyard chickens got you hankering for a coop of your own. In the end, this book may not change your life, but it might well inspire you to LIVE MORE, and tell you exactly how to get started.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
Review by Bibliotropic ([..]), March 28, 2011
This review is from: United States of Americana: Backyard Chickens, Burlesque Beauties, and Handmade Bitters: A Field Guide to the New American Roots Movement (Paperback)
Ultimately, I can't deny that this was a very interesting concept for a book, especially with North American's current mindset and economic factors. More people every day are turning to green alternatives, and looking back on how things used to be done before we became a throwaway society. The author clearly did a large amount of research before putting pen to paper, so to speak, and for that, I commend him.
It was, however, not what I was hoping for in a book. While some parts were definitely interesting, with a focus on the history behind things and an aspect of DIY, long portions of it were devoted to nothing more than profiles of companies that have weathered the blast and are still going strong after 100 years or more. Which is fine... if you don't mind reading chapter after chapter of company profiles. I would have rather seen a few more profiles of up-and-comers, people or small companies who were really getting into the DIY spirit and making their own clothes, perhaps, instead of relying on other people to do it for them. Reighley acknowledges that DIY is an essential part of the movement, but ignores a golden opportunity to showcase that.
Certainly, "buy American" is part of the culture as well, but if you actually get down to the grass roots, you'll see a great number of people who are more interested in doing for themselves instead of letting others do for them. It's a fine line to walk, but I wish Reighley had looked a little deeper into that instead of presenting a few food vendors and letting that be the end of it.
That being said, I did learn quite a bit, not just from the various and sundry pieces of trivial commentary that Reighley throws in but also from the sections not devoted to CEO interviews and product reviews. Though I'm not much of a drinker, the section on alcohol fascinated me, and taught me things I didn't even know I didn't know. There were good tips on preserving food, too.
I particularly like that he admitted that Canada exists, even if it was only as a minor footnote. Let's face it, Canada's got as many DIY back-to-earth sustainability as America does, but many people ignore that and act as though America's the only one that can, and thus does, bother with it. Which is just untrue. Even if it's just a footnote, I'm glad that Reighley acknowledged that "North Americana" might actually be a better term to use for some things.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|