Emily Dickinson wrote "The Brain--is wider than the Sky," and who can argue with that? Quoted by Nobel-winning scientist Gerald M. Edelman and his Neurosciences Institute colleague Giulio Tononi in A Universe of Consciousness, Miss Emily neatly explains the problem of conscious awareness, then ducks out of the way as the two scientists get to work solving it. Testable theories of consciousness are mighty lonely, as even the soberest mind can be driven to tears of madness pondering its own activity. Centuries of work by philosophers and psychologists like James and Freud have made little progress by starting with awareness and working backward to the brain; these days we have a secure enough base to try looking in the other direction and building a theory of the mind out of neurons.
Though Edelman and Tononi do make a good effort to help out the lay reader, ultimately A Universe of Consciousness is aimed at the interdisciplinary gang of scientists and academics trying to understand our shared but invisible experience. The first sections of the book cover the basic philosophical, psychological, and biological elements essential to their theory. Swiftly the authors proceed to define terms and concepts (even the long-abused term complexity gets a reappraisal) and elaborate on these to create a robust, testable theory of the neural basis of consciousness. Following this hard work, they consider some ramifications of the theory and take a close look at language and thinking. This much-needed jump-start is sure to provoke a flurry of experimental and theoretical responses; A Universe of Consciousness might just help us answer some of the greatest questions of science, philosophy, and even poetry. --Rob Lightner --This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
A woman senses that a room is light or dark and is aware that she has done so. A photocell senses the same thing without awareness. The difference is consciousness--something everyone recognizes but no one can fully explain. Edelman (director of the Neurosciences Institute in San Diego) and Tononi (a senior fellow there) propose what they call the dynamic core hypothesis to explain the neural basis of conscious experience. "This hypothesis states that the activity of a group of neurons can contribute directly to conscious experience if it is part of a functional cluster, characterized by strong mutual interactions among a set of neuronal groups over a period of hundreds of milliseconds." They call such a cluster the dynamic core because of "its ever-changing composition yet ongoing integration." In telling their tale, the authors describe brain structure and function, review earlier efforts to explain consciousness and come to a discussion of higher-order consciousness--the kind that humans have. "Our position has been that higher-order consciousness, which includes the ability to be conscious of being conscious, is dependent on the emergence of semantic capabilities and, ultimately, of language. Concomitant with these traits is the emergence of a true self, born of social interactions, along with concepts of the past and future."
EDITORS OF SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN --This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.See all Editorial Reviews
This is the most complete and convincing account of the development of the embodied brain yet written. Read morePublished 4 months ago by Charles Scurlock
Although the true nature of consciousness may be as elusive as ever, Edelman & Tononi make a compelling case for it arising as a 'dynamic core' of integrated neural responses to... Read morePublished 12 months ago by R. H. Page
It is redundant the admiration suscited by the Reading of one more of yours writings, and this opens news ideas about the interaction among consciousness and imagination.Published 14 months ago by Antonio Sapienza
I first read Edelman's "Bright Air Brilliant Fire" sometime around 1990; at that time I was beginning to change my "search for the meaning of 'Truth'" from studying... Read morePublished 19 months ago by "Suttle Fox"
Finally, presented here, is an alternative (actually a solution) to the mind/brain hard problem. Edelman and Tononi posit that consciousness is not a separate entity from the... Read morePublished on August 17, 2012 by MokuDo Taobul
I found the book interesting and appreciated the attention given to the neural circuit of the cortex-thalamus- and various subsystems (especially the basil ganglia). Read morePublished on February 13, 2012 by barryb