Mainstream hard rock is an unfortunate genre, generally stacked with a list of number one hits that reach the top less by musical talent and more by their clean fit into blockbuster films and into fashionable youth-centered shopping outlets. Red certainly does not bother trying to break out much, even if it fits in the heaviest subcategory of the over-filled genre. However, Red has an "X" factor here - it may be all formula, but it is also all heart.
The biggest thing that separates "Until We Have Faces" from the Nashville rockers' previous work is a much-welcomed substitution of melodrama with genuine talent. It's never been easy (if even possible) to lodge a complaint against lead singer Barnes' vocal prowess - fluctuating between a smoother Chris Daughtry at times, a rather angry Josh Groban at others, and, impressively, an emotionally charged Tim Lambesis (of As I Lay Dying fame) at yet others. Yet, with this album, the music quality has been kicked up more than just a notch. The safe-rock characteristics of Red's previous albums have been ditched in favor of much more ambition. Guitars are split into multiple parts rather than played in unison, and drums pound out much more complex rhythms, using the double-bass pedal much more than what would be expected from a band of this genre. There is actually quite a bit of heavy metal influence here - more so than many self-proclaimed "metal" bands themselves convey. Likewise, the strings, synths, and background vocals are cut down to see time only when they are appropriate, not every moment (looking at you, "Innocence and Instinct").
In fact, this album really never works against itself. Production quality is arguably perfect, and the track listing provides an interesting listen from start to finish. The kickoff comes in the form of the incredibly aggressive "Feed the Machine." Where most hard rock bands would suffice with a short, two-and-a-half-minute burst of energy at the beginning of an album, Red effectively draws the song out for over five minutes. Since the rest of the album never really matches the intensity found here at the start, the length is actually appreciated because it's just so satisfying. It is said that it is better to leave the listener wanting more than wanting less, but finding that sweet spot between the two is an achievement on its own. "Faceless" slows things down just a bit, but compliments the first song perfectly. The album feels rather formulaic from this point on, but it is almost impossible not to get behind the tight rhythms, technical riffs, and gorgeous melodies heard throughout. The album swings between heavy ballad and fist-pumping rock from here, with the climax coming in at "Watch You Crawl," which reinstates some of the energy found in "Feed the Machine" to carry the album to its end. This is where the listener hears Red at their finest, laying down some of the best lyrical, melodic, and rhythmic work the band has ever done. The album's energy starts to decline at this point, but only on a smooth curve that keeps things interesting. "Best Is Yet To Come" is the last (and best) rock ballad of the album, and it's followed by the epic "Hymn for the Missing" which starts out softly with pianos and strings and, thankfully, remains soft until the end.
Red's latest is, at its core, the perfect mainstream hard rock album. The lyrical message is honest yet hopeful and upbeat, the music is well-crafted and nuanced with technical complexity, the production is tight, and the vocals stand out as some of the best in any genre today. Red has certainly proven themselves to be forceful and aggressive while retaining a wide appeal. Perhaps the subtle ambition in this album will further spur the group to think a bit more outside the box and craft something more unique on their next project, but for now, "Until We Have Faces" is as impressive as modern rock albums come. If modern mainstream rock is remembered twenty years from now, Red should be one of the names associated with the genre. Here is an album that makes stereotypical schlock un-typically slick.
Ten-Point Scale: 8.5 out of 10
Genre: Hard Rock / Modern Rock
Recommended: Highly
NOTE: Many people have complained that this album is, in fact, not heavier than their previous work, which was something hyped about the album. This is a misunderstanding of the term "heavy" - More overall volume, louder guitars, or faster drums do not make for a "heavier" sound, per se. It would be nearly impossible to make anything here "louder" than their previous work and it still be digestible at all. This album incorporates many more heavy-metal-styled riffs and rhythms than in previous works, which results in a significantly heavier musical structure. Red has always been louder and more aggressive-sounding than, say, even most Metallica, yet Red remains mainstream rock and Metallica remains heavy metal. Red is, however, much more pop-like in song structure and chord progression, while Metallica does far more experimentation and uses both fast and slow rhythmic breakdowns and guitar solos/duets to achieve it's sound. In this regard, "Until We Have Faces" more closely resembles classic metal than simply much-louder pop-rock. This is just an observation from a musician - perhaps this sheds light on why I (as well as Red) view this album as being much heavier than the others.