This work sets a high standard for college-level edited history surveys. I assigned this work (or the bulk of it at least) for an African American History course in Spring 2001. It's traditional for students to dislike textbooks designed for classroon use, but this is far from the least popular one. There are many good surveys of African American history, and while none is completely satisfactory, "Upon These Shores" has several strong features. The level of expertise and writing of most chapters is extremely high; some of the premier scholars in the field are represented here, including Peter Wood, Joseph Miller, Gayraud Wilmore, and Charles V. Hamilton among others. The chapter bibliographies are very helpful, and the illustrations nicely complement the text. Ultimately, the deciding factor in assigning this book was the numerous well-chosen excerpts from primary sources embedded in the various chapters. This helped to acquaint students with the raw materials for doing history, gave direct access to Black voices from the past, and---not least---saved students money since they didn't have to buy a separate collection of sources.
"Upon These Shores" does have some drawbacks. It lacks an index, a minor but distinct annoyance. There is a good chapter on Black feminism, but coverage of African American women in other chapters is rather perfunctory, though the section on the antebellum gender division of labor is very insightful. The result is that womens' issues regrettably seem largely segregated into one chapter. Contributors mostly define "race rellations" in black-and-white terms, leaving readers less informed on encounters with other ethnic groups. Still, this work does not claim to be fully comprehensive, and what's here is quite good indeed.
The course itself covered four centuries of history, really too much to do in one semester. I supplemented "Upon These Shores" with the following works: Olaudah Equiano, "Interesting Narrative;" David Walker, "Appeal to the Colored People;" WEB DuBois, "Souls of Black Folk;" Anne Moody, "Coming of Age in Mississippi," & shorter writings by Diop, Appiah, Frederick Douglass, Harriet Jacobs & Nat Turner.