Most Helpful Customer Reviews
120 of 136 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
This book tells the reader to "go look on the internet", October 31, 2010
This review is from: Urban Survival Guide: Learn The Secrets Of Urban Survival To Keep You Alive After Man-Made Disasters, Natural Disasters, and Breakdowns In Civil Order (Paperback)
There is useful advice in this book. Unfortunately, the information that is given is sparse and so general/introductory in nature, that I could take little away from it. The author presents a number of pertinent topics in summary only, with advice to visit his blog or search the internet for additional information. I don't purchase books to provide me with lists of links, or keywords for Google searches, or to sell me additional advice/guides/tools/books from the author.
Several areas of the book are annoying or off-putting. The author also fails to define several acronyms (TEOTWAWKI is used first on page 113, and several times thereafter, and not defined until page 159). It's written in a condescending and (from my male perspective) a sexist tone (I wouldn't buy this for a wife or a girlfriend). Finally, the writing is OVERTLY political and religious, and this devisive tone detracts from the message of survival and preparedness.
I've not spent a great deal of time researching and preparing for survival in disaster situations. Most of the information I've learned about the subject has been from the web, including the CDC, Are you ready, etc. There is little additional *useful* information presented in this book. And some of the topics are laughably bizarre or unrealistic - how to create disguises, how to "vet" a team of experts, or items like: "live in a state that prohibits gun confiscation".
However, little does not mean none, so I cannot say this purchase was a total waste. Topics such as `Why to avoid shelters', `Urban Movement' and `Secrets to cheaply harden your home' were useful. Still, the information is presented in a light manner that describes WHY these activities/preparations are useful, with scant detail on the HOW to accomplish or implement the recommendations. If you're looking for a polished and dense tome of PRACTICAL advise, look elsewhere. If you buy it, make sure to read it before the power goes out, because you'll need an internet connection to find out how to actually survive.
Worst case scenario: the paper will make for nice kindling when disaster strikes. But, remember for 75 cents you can always buy a full newspaper.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good book for the Neo-Urban Survivalist, February 7, 2011
This review is from: Urban Survival Guide: Learn The Secrets Of Urban Survival To Keep You Alive After Man-Made Disasters, Natural Disasters, and Breakdowns In Civil Order (Paperback)
The Good:
-The author puts in a lot of good info pertaining to the subject, and uses examples of survival situations as recent as Hurricane Katrina. Even the most experienced person will still learn something here.
-Easy to read; no degree needed.
-At the end of each chapter the author recaps the important points and gives the reader suggestions for homework to help make the lesson more memorable.
The Bad:
-Spelling and grammar errors. I caught approximately ten spelling and/ or grammatical errors without even looking for them. Not overly distracting, just mildly annoying. I'd expect better given the price of this book.
-The author repeatedly references his website for more information, and constantly promotes his Urban Survival Program (not free). There are a few points where he leaves you hanging lest you check out his website. Again, annoying.
-Information, even within a chapter, tends to bounce around a bit, and could go a lot more into detail.
If you are new to the "Urban Survival" topic, then this book will be great, however, if you've read any other survival books, or watched Youtube survival videos then you may only take away a few new points.
In my opinion, this book wouldn't be worthy of 5 stars even if the problems were resolved. I think the content needs to be a little more in-depth given the nature of the topic. I would've given it 3.5 stars if I could have, instead of 4. Resolve all of the issues and it would be 4.5 solid stars.
That's my 2 cents.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
44 of 54 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Outstanding Resource - a Must Read, April 1, 2010
This review is from: Urban Survival Guide: Learn The Secrets Of Urban Survival To Keep You Alive After Man-Made Disasters, Natural Disasters, and Breakdowns In Civil Order (Paperback)
This book is a must-have, regardless of where you live. I was already in "preparation mode" when I discovered Mr. Morris' Urban Survival online course. He delivers a tremendous amount of knowledge in a format that is easy to understand - and apply. Whereas some authors write about doom and gloom and the necessity to build mini-fortresses in the wilderness, Mr. Morris lays out succinct and practical plans for surviving in-place. It really helped me to organize and prioritize my preparations. I am much more confident now with the direction my preparations are heading, and with the breadth of knowledge I gained through his online course. Even if you believe you'll never face a disaster scenario, this book will teach you how to become more self-reliant. If you believe that some form of disaster, break-down, or collapse is in our future - all the more reason to order this book today! Learn, train, prepare - and enjoy life!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|